Theme E — Nuclear and Quantum Physics
E.1.6 Deviations from Rutherford Scattering — IB Physics HL Revision Notes & Topical Questions
5 min read 9 parts Lesson 8 of 45 1 quiz
Curriculum Equation Key قوانين الرقم الهيدروجيني والاتزان الأيوني - pH & Acid-Base Equilibrium FormulasFast Exam Solution
pH = -log[H⁺] | pOH = -log[OH⁻] | pH + pOH = 14 | [H⁺][OH⁻] = 10⁻¹⁴
Word Equation & Conditions: الرقم الهيدروجيني = -لوغاريتم تركيز أيون الهيدروجين | pH + pOH = 14
Location & Specifications: الاتزان الأيوني، كيمياء 3 ثانوي، التحصيلي، و AP Chemistry.
Lesson summary
E.1.6 Deviations from Rutherford Scattering — IB PHYSICS HL notes: Explain why high-energy alpha particles deviate from Rutherford scattering and what this shows about the strong force, nuclear size and quarks.Assumption — only electrostatic repulsion between point charges acts, …
- Prediction
- Observation
- Range of the strong force
- Closest approach
- Electric force
- Greatest deviation
Part 1 of 7What Rutherford predicted
Assumption
- Assumption only electrostatic repulsion between point charges acts, and the target nucleus stays fixed
Prediction
- Prediction as the scattering angle increases, the number of alpha particles scattered decreases
Agreement
- Agreement found correct at low to moderately high energies for alpha particles of a few MeV on gold
Failure
- Failure the prediction fails if the projectile gets close enough to feel other forces or the target recoils
Part 2 of 7Deviations at high energy
1Energy
- Energy above about 27.5 MeV significant deviations are observed
2Observation
- Observation the number of back-scattered alpha particles falls sharply to zero instead of following the expected rate
3Cause
- Cause the alpha particles come close enough to the nucleons to feel the strong nuclear force
4Range of the strong force
- Range of the strong force significant below about 1.5 fm and acting over roughly 1–3 fm
5Evidence
- Evidence deviations provide evidence for the strong nuclear force
6Closest approach
- Closest approach it becomes comparable to the nuclear radius
Part 3 of 7Effect of the target nucleus
Electric force
- F = kqQ/r2, so a nucleus with smaller charge lets the alpha particle approach closer at the same energy
Gold
- Z = 79
Aluminium
- Z = 13, so alpha particles get closer and more deviation is seen
Greatest deviation
- Greatest deviation high alpha energy and target nuclei of low nucleon number
Light targets
- Light targets if the target is as light as the alpha particle, it recoils, so scattering angles differ from the fixed-target calculation
Part 4 of 7Electron diffraction and nuclear size
Electrons as probes
- Electrons as probes they do not feel the strong force and interact only electromagnetically and weakly
Wavelength
- λ = h/p can be smaller than a nucleus at high energy
Pattern
- Pattern scattered intensity shows diffraction with a first minimum that gives the nuclear radius
Charge distribution
- Charge distribution electron scattering probes the nuclear charge distribution
Part 5 of 7Deep inelastic scattering
1Higher energy electrons
- Higher energy electrons many GeV electrons on protons deviate from point-like scattering
2Result
- Result there are small hard point-like centres inside the proton
3Charges
- Charges the centres have fractional charge
4Conclusion
- Conclusion protons and neutrons contain quarks
5First done
- First done at Stanford in the late 1960s
Part 6 of 7What each probe shows
| Projectile | What deviation shows |
|---|---|
| Alpha particles | The strong force and the range of nuclear forces |
| Electrons | The charge distribution and radius of the nucleus |
| Very high-energy electrons | The internal structure of nucleons |
Part 7 of 7More from the specification
Alpha trajectory around nuclear orbit
- Alpha trajectory around nuclear orbit high-energy alpha particles penetrating close nuclear distances deviate from Rutherford scattering, escaping classical Coulomb scattering orbit.
Deviations from Rutherford Scattering
- At extremely high alpha particle energies, particles penetrate close enough to the gold nucleus to experience the attractive strong nuclear force,
- causing deviations from pure Coulomb scattering predictions.
Hydrogen Spectral Series
- Electron transitions down to the n=1 ground state produce the ultraviolet Lyman series, transitions to n=2 produce the visible Balmer series,
- and transitions to n=3 yield the infrared Paschen spectrum.
The Rydberg Equation
- The wavelengths of emission photons from atomic hydrogen are calculated using the Rydberg equation: 1 / λ = RH * (1/n₁² - 1/n₂²),
- where RH is the Rydberg constant.
Quantization of Photons and Energy Levels
- Absorption spectra are produced when cold atomic gas absorbs photons whose energy precisely matches the difference between atomic levels, leaving distinct dark absorption lines on a continuous spectrum.
Angular momentum
- L = Iω for a rigid body; L = mvr⊥ for a particle.
Emission spectrum
- The set of discrete wavelengths emitted by excited atoms of an element.
Photon
- A quantum of electromagnetic energy, E = hf
Spectrum
- Range of colours in white light.
Constant
- Not changing.
Momentum
- P = mv, a vector.
Density
- Mass per unit volume.
Absorption
- The conversion of wave energy to internal energy of the medium.
Energy level
- A discrete energy an electron in an atom can have
Photon energy
- E = hf = hc/λ, the energy carried by one photon.
∆E
∆E hf = E2 − E1
What the symbols mean: E = energy of one photon (J) · h = Planck constant (6.63 × 10−34 J s) · f = frequency (Hz)
Key terms
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Strong nuclear force | The short-range attractive force between nucleons. |
| Rutherford scattering | Scattering of charged particles by a nucleus through electrostatic repulsion alone. |
| Deep inelastic scattering | Scattering of very high-energy electrons by nucleons that revealed quarks. |
| Electron diffraction | Diffraction of electrons used to measure nuclear radius. |
| Quark | A fundamental particle that makes up protons and neutrons. |
Avoid these mistakes
1
Saying the deviation shows Coulomb's law fails — other forces, the strong force, come into play.
2
Using electrons to explain the strong force — electrons do not feel it.
3
Forgetting that Rutherford scattering assumes a heavy fixed target.
4
Thinking deviations appear at low energies — they appear when the particle gets close at high energy.
5
Confusing electron diffraction with alpha scattering — electrons probe charge distribution and alphas probe the force range.
Marked practiceQuizzes for this lesson
Last updated:
\n