المناهج الدراسية
تسجيل الدخول
نص الدرس

Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird

English — Second Secondary — Term 2

Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird

Unit 6 The Space We Share: Concept 6 A World for All, Lesson 6.1 Nobody owns a migrating bird

Unit 6 The Space We Share: Concept 6 A World for All, Lesson 6.1 Nobody owns a migrating bird

وجه المقارنةالفكرة الأساسيةكلمات مفتاحية
Section AGlobal ResponsibilityGlobalResponsibility
A World We Borrow
  • When communities and ecosystems share finite resources
  • conflicting interests make absolute control impossible
  • so sustainable outcomes require negotiated governance built on shared evidence and mutual recognition of legitimate needs
communitiesecosystemssharefinite
  • Name a bird that migrates to the shores of Egypt.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 1 / 12
Discussion in groups of four

Discussion in groups of four

  • Can you think of an animal, a plant, or a resource that crosses borders without anyone’s permission? What problems might this create for the countries involved? (Analyze)
  • Why might funding for wetland conservation be ‘the first thing cut when budgets tighten’? (Analyze)
  • Who should be responsible for protecting a species that no single country can claim? (Evaluate)
  1. Do you think individual countries should be legally responsible for protecting species that spend only a fraction of their life cycle within that country’s border? Why? Support your answer with evidence.
  2. Compare the long-term economic and environmental impacts of developing a wetland with conserving it for ecotourism. How should we balance these priorities? Justify your answer.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 2 / 12
Reading text: A World We Borrow

Reading text: A World We Borrow

  • An original pedagogical reading text custom-authored by the national curriculum development team; scientific evidence and conservation perspective synthesized from international wildlife conservation reports.
  • Every fall, several billion birds leave their breeding grounds in northern Europe and Asia.
  • They travel south without passports or awareness of the borders they cross.
  • Many of them fly directly over Egypt.
  • Their route is so reliable that birdwatchers can predict, almost to the week, when the sky above certain wetlands will fill with birds.
  • The journey is staggering by any measure.
  • A single Eurasian curlew may cover several thousand kilometers in just a few weeks.
  • It depends on a chain of wetlands, river deltas, and coastal marshes, and each one belongs to a different country, with its own laws and priorities.
  • If a single link in that chain disappears because a wetland is drained for agriculture, built over for housing, or simply left too polluted to support the insects and fish that migratory birds depend on, the consequences are felt not by the country that made the decision, but by ecosystems thousands of kilometers away that never had any say in the matter.
  • Conservationists describe this as one of the clearest examples of what it means, practically rather than poetically, to share a planet.
  • No single country can protect a migratory species alone; a wetland perfectly preserved in one country doesn’t really help a bird that starves during a stopover in another.
  • International agreements now attempt to coordinate this kind of protection, though enforcement varies enormously, and funding for wetland conservation is frequently the first thing cut when budgets tighten.
  • For local communities living beside these wetlands, the birds bring both value and tension.
  • Ecotourism built around birdwatching can provide real income, yet the same wetlands are often wanted for development precisely because they sit on valuable, flat, well-irrigated land.
  • Balancing these competing pressures rarely has an easy answer; it requires constant negotiation between people who will never meet, and who often disagree profoundly about what protecting it should actually cost them.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 3 / 12
JRE: weigh the two views

JRE: weigh the two views

  • Consider the views below. Which position do you find more convincing? Use the JRE framework to defend your answer.
  1. Wetlands should be preserved because the ecotourism built around birdwatching can provide real, ongoing income.
  2. The same wetlands sit on valuable, flat, well-irrigated land that communities may urgently need for development.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 4 / 12
Comprehension Check

Comprehension Check

  • Answer the following questions.
  • (Analyze) According to the text, why can no single government protect a migratory species alone?
  • (Explain) What are the two major challenges facing international agreements when attempting to protect migratory species?
  • (Evaluate) Do you think international agreements are an effective way to protect species that cross many borders? Justify your view.
  1. (suggested answer) Because migratory birds depend on a chain of wetlands that belong to different countries; a wetland perfectly preserved in one country does not help a bird that starves during a stopover in another.
  2. (suggested answer) Enforcement varies enormously between countries, and funding for wetland conservation is frequently the first thing cut when budgets tighten.
  3. (suggested answer) They are a necessary start because only coordination between countries can protect the whole chain of wetlands, but they are only effective if they are enforced and properly funded.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 5 / 12
True / False / Not Given

True / False / Not Given

  1. State whether each statement is True (T)
  2. False (F)
  3. or Not Given (NG). Justify your answer.
Statement T/F/NG Justify your answer
1. Migratory birds can travel several thousand kilometers relying on a chain of wetlands. T
  • (suggested answer) The text says a curlew depends on a chain of wetlands
  • deltas and marshes
2. Every wetland along a migration route belongs to the same country. F (suggested answer) The text says each wetland belongs to a different country.
3. Funding for wetland conservation is described as stable and rarely cut. F (suggested answer) The text says funding is frequently the first thing cut.
4. Ecotourism built around birdwatching can provide real income for local communities. T (suggested answer) The text says it can provide real income.
5. The article names the countries that have signed the international conservation agreements. NG (suggested answer) The text never names the countries.
NOTE←If you mark a statement Not Given (NG) in one line, write what the text would need to say for you to decide whether it is True (T) or False (F), and where in the text you looked.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 6 / 12
Vocabulary

Vocabulary

  • Match the following words with their meanings.
Words Meanings
1. staggering
  • a. become more limited
  • especially because less money is available
2. stopover b. people who work to protect nature and wildlife
3. tighten c. extremely impressive or surprising in scale
4. enforcement d. making sure people follow rules or laws
5. curlew e. having had the water removed from it
6. drained f. a short rest or stop during a long journey
7. conservationists g. a large bird with a long, curved beak
Answers (suggested answer)←1-c, 2-f, 3-a, 4-d, 5-g, 6-e, 7-b.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 7 / 12
Practice (Identify – Analyze)

Practice (Identify – Analyze)

  • Write FOUR sentences using words from the text to describe a natural resource shared by different countries, communities, or species.
  • Then choose one sentence and explain why sharing it fairly can be challenging.
  • Model answer (suggested answer) The wetland is a shared resource for migratory birds. Conservationists protect it, but its drained edges are wanted for farms. The stopover is essential for the curlew. Enforcement of the rules is weak. Sharing the wetland fairly is challenging because farmers, fishermen, and birds all need it, and each country follows its own laws.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 8 / 12
Grammar: Reported Speech

Grammar: Reported Speech

  • When we tell someone what another person said, we usually do not repeat their exact words.
  • Instead, we report the idea using reported speech.
  • This is especially useful for reporting the opinion of conservationists.
  • A reported sentence usually begins with a reporting verb such as said, told, explained, added, replied, or claimed followed by (that) and a clause.
  • The word that is optional and is often dropped in spoken English.
  • Subject + said (that) + clause. Example: The farmer said (that) he needed more land.
  • Subject + told + person + (that) + clause. Example: The farmer told the officer (that) he needed more land.
  • Note the difference say is not followed directly by a person (say to somebody), while tell must be followed by a person (tell somebody).

Changing the Tense

  • When the reporting verb is in the past (said, told, explained), the verb in the reported clause usually moves one step back into the past.
  • This is called backshift.
  • Note Remember to change pronouns and time/place expressions when needed (for example today becomes that day).

Changing Pronouns and Possessives

  • Because we are now speaking about the person, not as the person, pronouns and possessive adjectives usually change to match the point of view of the reporter.
  • When we report a question, we change the word order of the question to statement order.
  • We make changes to the tenses and other words for reported statements.
  • For Yes/No questions, we use if or whether to report the question.
Direct speech Reported speech
  • “Fishing is our livelihood
  • ” the fisherman said
The fisherman said (that) fishing was their livelihood.
“We will lose our income,” the farmers said. The farmers said (that) they would lose their income.
  • “We can protect the wetland
  • ” the conservationist said
The conservationist said (that) they could protect the wetland.
“Are you happy to have a pet?” my friend asked. My friend asked if I was happy to have a pet.
“What’s your favorite hobby?” Nada said to Dina. Nada asked Dina what her favorite hobby was.
“I protect this wetland,” she said. She said (that) she protected that wetland.
“We depend on this land,” the farmers said. The farmers said (that) they depended on that land.
“My livelihood is at risk,” he said. He said (that) his livelihood was at risk.

Why We Change Time and Place Expressions

  1. When the moment of reporting is different from the moment of speaking
  2. time and place words usually shift as well
  3. because now for the original speaker may not be now at the time of reporting.
Direct speech Reported speech
now then / at that time
today that day
tomorrow the next day / the following day
yesterday the day before / the previous day
this wetland / this reserve that wetland / that reserve
here there

When NOT to Backshift

  1. The tense does not need to change when the situation reported is still true
  2. is a general fact
  3. or is a scientific or permanent truth
  4. because backshifting could wrongly suggest the situation has ended.
  1. The conservationist said that migratory birds depend on wetlands. (still true
  2. a general fact
  3. so no backshift is required)
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 9 / 12
Grammar in Context

Grammar in Context

A. Fill in the gaps with the correct reported form of the verb in brackets.

  • Migratory birds face many dangers during their long journeys, so conservationists said that they (1) …….. (need) protection in every country they visited.
  • They explained that some wetlands (2) …….. (be) destroyed while the birds were traveling.
  • Experts warned that conservation (3) …….. (decrease) if national budgets became tighter.
  • Finally, they predicted that protecting migratory birds (4) …….. (require) greater international cooperation in …
  • Answers (suggested answer) (1) needed, (2) were, (3) would decrease, (4) would require.
  1. a. The farmer said that fishing were their livelihood. b. The farmer said that fishing was their livelihood. c. The farmer said that fishing is their livelihood. d. The farmer said that fishing being their livelihood.
  2. a. Grace said that elephants destroys her crops every year. b. Grace said that elephants destroying her crops every year. c. Grace said that elephants destroyed her crops every year. d. Grace said that elephants had destroys her crops every year.
  3. a. She asked where was I going. b. She asked where I was going. c. She said where I am going. d. She asked where did I go.
  4. a. Ali asked if had I finished my homework. b. Ali asked if did I finish my homework. c. Ali asked if I have finished my homework. d. Ali asked if I had finished my homework.
  5. a. The conservationist said that they would coordinate protection efforts. b. The conservationist said that they will coordinate protection efforts. c. The conservationist said that they coordinate protection efforts. d. The conservationist said that they are coordinating protection efforts.
  6. a. Researchers said that farms and reserves can managed together. b. Researchers said that farms and reserves could managed together. c. Researchers said that farms and reserves could be managed together. d. Researchers said that farms and reserves can be management together.
  7. a. Nour said that she is trying to fill the gap left by turtles. b. Nour said that she trying to fill the gap left by turtles. c. Nour said that she has trying to fill the gap left by turtles. d. Nour said that she was trying to fill the gap left by turtles.
  8. a. Zeina asked Mariam how old she was. b. Zeina asked Mariam how old are you? c. Zeina asked Mariam how old you are. d. Zeina asked Mariam how old she is.
Answers (suggested answer)←1-b, 2-c, 3-b, 4-d, 5-a, 6-c, 7-d, 8-a.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 10 / 12
Speaking: Role-play, The Wetland Meeting

Speaking: Role-play, The Wetland Meeting

  • In groups of four, hold a short meeting to decide the future of a wetland that migratory birds depend on.
  • Each student takes one role below and argues for their priority, using at least one reported speech sentence.
Role Priority
Conservationist wants the wetland fully protected for migratory birds
Local developer
  • wants to build housing on part of the flat
  • well-irrigated land
Fishing community member depends on the wetland’s fish and clean water for daily income
  1. From my perspective, …
  2. I understand your concern, but…
  3. If we protect this land, then…
  4. A fair compromise might be…
  1. After the role-play
  2. agree as a group on ONE final decision and be ready to explain your reasons to the class.
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 11 / 12
Presentation

Presentation

  • As a guest speaker for your school’s “Environment Week”, prepare a 2-3 minute presentation for classmates and their families to help them understand a resource that is shared across borders or among species.
Your presentation must include
DescribeName the resource and where it is located.
ExplainShow who or what depends on it and why no single group owns it.
AnalyzeWhat happens when one part of the system or chain is disrupted?
EvaluateWhat does your example concede or acknowledge about the genuine needs of local communities?

Build your ideas

  1. This resource is shared by / among…
  2. If it disappears, then…
  3. This situation represents…
  4. One important tension is…
  5. In my opinion, this example shows…
  6. Although some people believe…, I think…
Lesson 6.1: Nobody owns a migrating bird · 12 / 12