Curriculum
Course: ACT SCIENCE
Login

Curriculum

ACT SCIENCE

Timed Practice

0/28 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material
Text lesson

Princeton Review ACT Science Prep — Chapter 9: Science Practice Test 1: Answers and Explanations

MasterStudy LMS Complete Reference — ACT Science Mastery: Princeton Review ACT Science Prep — Chapter 9: Science Practice Test 1: Answers and Explanations.

1Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations2Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations3Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations4Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations5Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations6Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations7Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations8Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations9Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations10Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations11Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations12Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations13Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations14Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations15Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1
Step A:: Count the number of correct answers: __________. This is your raw score. Step B:: Use the score conversion table below to look up your raw score. The number to the left is your scale score: _________.
2
Test 1 Scale Conversion Table: Data Table Row(s):
Scale Score | Raw Score
36 | 39–40
1 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

35 | 38
2

34 | 37
3

33 | 36
4

32 | 35
5

31 | 34
6

30 | —
◀ Previous2 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
29 | 33
28 | 32
27 | 31
26 | 29–30
25 | 28
24 | 26–27
◀ Previous3 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
23 | 25
22 | 23–24
21 | 21–22
20 | 20
19 | 18–19
18 | 17
◀ Previous4 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

17 | 16
2

16 | 14–15
3

3
4

Data Table Row(s): 15 | 13

14 | 12 13 | 10–11 12 | 9 11 | 8 10 | 7 9 | 6 8 | 5 7 | 4 6 | 3 5 | — 4 | 2 3 | 1 2 | — 1 | 0
5

4
6

The question asks which supplement best meets the criteria that it will maintain as much of (patients’) initial bone density as possible if it is taken for 3 years.
◀ Previous5 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

Use Table 1 and compare the bone density between 0 months and 36 months for each supplement, as these are the initial value and the value at 3 years.
2

For Bonegenic, the bone density goes from 130 in month 0 to 117 in month 36 for a decrease in bone density of 13 mg/cm 3 over three years.
3

5
4

For Calcitrenix, the value goes from 128 to 121 for a decrease of 7 mg/cm 3 .
5

For Strength+, the value goes from 131 to 118 for a decrease of 13 mg/cm 3 .
6

For Vitagrow, the values go from 127 to 116 for a decrease of 11 mg/cm 3 .
◀ Previous6 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
The smallest decrease occurred when patients took Calcitrenix.
The correct answer is (B).
6
The question asks for a comparison of the initial average serum CTX of patients given the Strength+ supplement in relation to 510 pg/mL.
Use Table 2 and look up the initial average serum CTX for Strength+ patients.
At the initial time of 0 months, the average serum CTX is 507 pg/mL

which is less than 510 pg/mL.
◀ Previous7 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

The correct answer is (H).
2

7
3

The question asks which supplement(s) are consistent with the prediction given.
4

The prediction is that as the time of treatment with a supplement increased, the average serum CTX would always decrease.
5

Use Table 2 and check to see which supplements showed a decrease across time from 0 months to 54 months.
6

For Bonegenic, the average serum CTX decreases each time from 0 months to 18 months to 36 months

but then it increases from 36 months to 54 months.
◀ Previous8 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Eliminate (D) because it includes Bonegenic.
8
For Calcitrenix, the average serum CTX decreases at every time interval.
Eliminate (C) because it does not include Calcitrenix.
No remaining answers include Strength+

so check Vitagrow next to determine if (A) or (B) is the correct answer.
For Vitagrow, the average serum CTX decreases at every time interval.
◀ Previous9 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Eliminate (A) because it does not include Vitagrow.
9
The question asks for the graph that best shows the average serum CTX across supplements at 18 months.
Use Table 2 to find the values of average serum CTX for each supplement.
At 18 months, Strength+ has the highest average serum CTX at 389 pg/mL.
Eliminate (F) and (H) since these graphs do not show Strength+ as having the highest average serum.
◀ Previous10 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

Compare the graphs for (G) and (J).
2

The graphs show different values for Vitagrow.
3

10
4

Check Table 2 for the average serum CTX at 18 months for Vitagrow

the average serum CTX is 299 pg/mLwhich is shown on the graph for (J). The correct answer is (J).
5

11
6

The question asks for the supplement that showed the least change in average bone mineral density from 18 months to 36 months of treatment.
◀ Previous11 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

Use Table 1 to compare the values of bone mineral density between 18 months and 36 months for each supplement.
2

For Bonegenic, the bone density goes from 120 in month 18 to 117 in month 36 for a difference of 3 mg/cm 3 .
3

For Calcitrenix, the bone density goes from 122 in month 18 to 121 in month 36 for a difference of 4 mg/cm 3 .
4

12
5

For Strength+, the bone density goes from 122 in month 18 to 118 in month 36 for a difference of 4 mg/cm 3 .
6

For Vitagrow, the bone density goes from 123 in month 18 to 116 in month 36 for a difference of 7 mg/cm 3 .
◀ Previous12 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Bonegenic has the least change in bone density.
The correct answer is (A).
13
The question asks if the data in Tables 1 and 2 support the statement that patients with the lowest average bone mineral density initially took the same supplement as the patients who had the greatest average serum CTX at 54 months.
Use Table 1 to find the supplement given to patients with the lowest average bone mineral density initially.
At 0 months, patients given Vitagrow had the lowest average bone mineral density at 127 mg/cm 3 .
◀ Previous13 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
1

14
2

Next, use Table 2 to see if patients given Vitagrow had the greatest average serum CTX at 54 months.
3

At 54 months, patients given Vitagrow had the lowest average serum

so the results do not support the statement.
4

Eliminate (F) and (G) because they indicate that the statement is supported.
5

Compare (H) and (J).
6

Choice (J) incorrectly states that Strength+ patients initially had the lowest average bone mineral density.
◀ Previous14 / 15Next ▶
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Theoretical Principles & Core Foundations
Eliminate (J).
15
The question asks for the range of months when the increase in accumulated sediment depth was the least at Location D.
The accumulated sediment depth at Location D is shown in Figure 3. Look at Figure 3 and find the line showing the sediment depth for Location D.
The smallest increase will be the line that is most horizontal.
Out of the four answer choices, the line between May 2007 and September 2007 is the most horizontal.
◀ Previous15 / 15
1Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts2Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts3Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts4Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts5Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts6Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts7Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts8Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts9Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts10Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts11Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1
Eliminate (A), (C), and (D) since these time periods show a greater, rather than smaller, increase in accumulated sediment depth. The correct answer is (B).
2
The question asks why the researchers recorded average temperature.
Read the answer choices for key terms and use POE.
The answer choices all mention snowmelt.
1 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1

In the description of the study, it says the researchers studied snowmelt-fed rivers.
2

Increased snowmelt would increase the sediment in the rivers, as sediment will be carried with the snowmelt into the river.
3

Eliminate (F) and (H) because snowmelt would increase sediment rather than prevent or limit it.
4

3
5

Eliminate (J) because lack of snowmelt would not increase sediment flow into rivers. The correct answer is (G).
6

4
◀ Previous2 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1

The question asks for a graph that shows the accumulated sediment depth for Locations D–F in September 2007. The accumulated sediment depths for Locations D–F are shown in Figure 3. In September 2007, Location F had the highest accumulated sediment depth.
2

Eliminate (C) because it shows Location E as having the highest accumulated sediment depth.
3

Eliminate (D) because it shows Location E and Location F as having the same accumulated sediment depth.
4

5
5

Based on Figure 3, Location D had the lowest accumulated sediment depth in September 2007. Eliminate (B) because it shows Location D as having a higher accumulated sediment depth than Location E. The correct answer is (A).
6

6
◀ Previous3 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
The questions asks for the temperature when there was no additional sediment accumulation at Locations A–C.
The data for Locations A–C are shown in Figure 2.

Use Figure 2 to find the times when the sediment accumulation did not increase, which will be the time periods when the line is horizontal.
The sediment accumulation did not increase between January 2007 to May 2007 and between January 2008 to May 2008.

In both of these time periods, the temperature, indicated by the bars, is less than −2.5°C.
7
Eliminate (H) and (J). Both time periods are roughly halfway between −2.5°C and −5.0°C

which is greater than −4.0°C. The correct answer is (G).
8
◀ Previous4 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1

The question asks whether the measured sediment at an inner curve of the river at Location E would be greater or less than 2 cm in September 2007.
2

The data for Location E is shown in Figure 3.
3

Based on Figure 3, the accumulated sediment depth at Location E in September 2007 was 2 cm.
4

Based on Figure 1, for a meandering river such as Location E, the accumulation of sediment is greater along the inner curves of the river.
5

9
6

Eliminate (A) and (B) because the accumulated sediment depth would be greater than 2 cm, not less. Eliminate (C) because it incorrectly states that the sediment concentration is greater in the center than along the inner curves. The correct answer is (D).
◀ Previous5 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
10
The question asks if the accumulated sediment depth in the straight-channel river was greater or less than the accumulated sediment depth in the meandering river.
The passage states that Locations A–C were on a straight-channel river and Locations D–F were on a meandering river.
Compare the accumulated sediment depth in Figure 2 (straight-channel river) to the accumulated sediment depth in Figure 3 (meandering river).
In Figure 2, the accumulated sediment depth ranges from less than 0.1 cm to 0.5 cm.
11
◀ Previous6 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
In Figure 3, the accumulated sediment depth ranges from less than 0.5 cm to about 3.5 cm.
At each time interval, the accumulated sediment depth is less in the straight-channel river.
Eliminate (F) and (G) because they incorrectly state that the sediment depth is greater in the straight-channel river.
Eliminate (J) because it incorrectly states that the highest values for accumulated sediment depth for the straight-channel river is 0.3 cm and the meandering river is 2.8 cm.
The correct answer is (H).
12
◀ Previous7 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1

The question asks for the humidity and storage time that resulted in the least amount of mass burned in Experiment 3. The results for Experiment 3 are shown in Table 3. The data shows PMB

which is described in the passage as percentage of mass burned.
2

Look for the smallest PMB on Table 3. Note the trends.
3

The PMB increases as the storage time increases

so 5 days will have a smaller PMB.
4

Eliminate (B) and (D).
5

PMB decreases as humidity increases

so 35% has a smaller PMB than 10% humidity.
6

The correct answer is (C).
◀ Previous8 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1

13
2

The question asks what the PMB would be for a storage time of 20 days and an air pressure of 60 psi in Experiment 2. Look for the data for the PMB at a storage time of 20 days in Table 2. The PMB is listed for air pressures of 20 psi, 40 psi, and 80 psi.
3

The PMB values increase with higher air pressures.
4

Thus, the PMB at an air pressure of 60 psi will fall between the values for 40 and 80 psi.
5

At a storage time of 20 days, the PMB is 76.7% at 40 psi and 80.3% at 80 psi.
6

The correct answer is (G).
◀ Previous9 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
14
The question asks what the PMB would be with a storage time of 10 days and a humidity of 30% based on Experiments 1 and 3. Since humidity is not mentioned in Table 1, read the description of Experiment 1 to find the humidity percentage.
The humidity for Experiment 1 was 25%.
Based on Table 1, at 25% humidity and 10 days of storage time, the PMB was 68.5%.
Based on Table 3, at 35% humidity and 10 days of storage time, the PMB was 63.4%.
15
◀ Previous10 / 11Next ▶
Mechanisms, Detailed Processes & Governing Concepts
1

Therefore, the PMB at 30% humidity and 10 days of storage time would be between 63.4% and 68.5%. The correct answer is (B).
2

16
3

The question asks how the PMB would have changed if the accumulated ashes had not been collected from the burn chamber before the remaining sample was weighed.
4

Read the description of Experiment 1 to learn more about the accumulated ashes.
5

The passage says that the remaining sample and all accumulated ash were removed and weighed to find the average sample final mass (SFM).
6

If the accumulated ashes were not collected, the SFM would have been less.
◀ Previous11 / 11
1Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations2Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations3Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations4Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations5Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations6Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations7Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations8Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations9Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations10Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations11Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
1
Eliminate (G) and (J) because they indicate the SFM would have been greater. Based on the equation, a smaller SFM would result in a greater PMB. The correct answer is (H).
2
The question asks how many branches were not burned at the conclusion of Experiment 1. Read the description of Experiment 1 to find out how many branches were burned.
The passage says that researchers collected 100 branches.
Later it states that 10 branches were burned and that the process was repeated 6 additional times.
1 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Therefore, the total number of branches burned was 70. Since the researchers started with 100 branches, 30 branches were not burned.
The correct answer is (B).
3
The question asks how the PMB of acacia burned in ordinary dry air compared to the PMB of acacia burned in compressed air.
These words do not appear in the tables

so skim the surrounding text to find the word compressed.
This word appears in the description of Experiment 2

which was similar to Experiment 1 except that the dry air…was compressed.
◀ Previous2 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
1

Compare the results of Table 1 to the results of Table 2 for each storage time.
2

4
3

For the acacia stored in dry air for 5 days, the PMB is 64.3% and for the acacia stored in compressed air (20 psi) for 5 days, the PMB is 67.6%.
4

The PMB in compressed air is greater.
5

Eliminate (G) and (H) because these indicate that the PMB in compressed air is always the same as or always less than that of dry air.
6

Compare the remaining data points in Table 1 to the data points with the same storage time for 20 psi in Table 2.

For each storage time, the PMB in compressed air is greater.
◀ Previous3 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
1

The correct answer is (F).
2

5
3

The question asks how the SFM compared to the SIM in Experiment 1. Based on the description of Experiment 1, the average sample initial mass (SIM) and the average sample final mass (SFM) are used to calculate PMB using the equation.
4

Use POE to find the relationship.
5

If the SFM and the SIM were equal, the equation would equal 0.

Since none of the values on Table 1 are 0, the SFM and SIM were not equal; eliminate (A).
6

If the SFM were greater than the SIM, the equation would result in a negative number.
◀ Previous4 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
6
Since none of the values on Table 1 are negative, the SFM was not greater than the SIM

eliminate (B). If the SFM were less than the SIM, the equation would result in a positive number. Since all the values on Table 1 are positive, the SFM was always less than the SIM. The correct answer is (C).
7
The question asks which of the devices listed could detect changes in the concentrations of carbon dioxide.
Look for information about changes in carbon dioxide concentration.
The passage says that changes in the carbon dioxide concentration of a solution can be observed by monitoring pH changes.
◀ Previous5 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
1

A pH sensor would detect these changes whereas the other instruments listed would not.
2

The correct answer is (H).
3

8
4

The question asks for the approximate pH of the phenol red solution in Vial 2 after 48 hours.
5

Table 2 shows that the color of the solution in Vial 2 after 48 hours is yellow.
6

Refer to Table 1 for the relationship between solution color and pH.
◀ Previous6 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
According to Table 1, a yellow solution has a pH of less than 6.6.

Eliminate (B), (C), and (D) because all of these pH values are greater than 6.6.The correct answer is (A).
9
The question asks how the set-up for Experiment 2 differed from the setup for Experiment 1. Look at Table 3 for the data for Experiment 2. According to Table 3, Vial 3 was exposed to light but Vial 4 was not.
Eliminate (H) since it states that both vials in Experiment 2 were exposed to light,

and eliminate (J) because it says that both of the vials were kept in the dark.
The remaining answer choices use the term primary producers

which is an organism that produces sugars through photosynthesis.
10
◀ Previous7 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Eliminate (F) because the only organisms in Experiment 2 were goldfish

which are not primary producers. The correct answer is (G).
11
The question asks whether Experiment 3 is consistent with the student’s prediction that phenol red solution would turn yellow after 48 hours when exposed to light in the absence of cellular respiration and photosynthesis.
Use POE.
According to Table 4, after 48 hours, the solution in Vial 6 was yellow.
Eliminate (A) since it states that the solution in Vial 6 was orange.
◀ Previous8 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
1

The solution in Vial 7 was orange in Table 4. Eliminate (D).
2

Table 4 also shows that Vial 7 was exposed to light

while Vial 6 was not.
3

12
4

Since the question is about a solution that is exposed to light, eliminate (C). The correct answer is (B).
5

13
6

The question asks why the color of the phenol red solution in Vial 1 differed from the color of the solution in Vial 2 after 48 hours.
◀ Previous9 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
1

Refer to the passage and look for key terms in the answer choices.
2

Equations 1 and 2 show the reactions of photosynthesis and cellular respiration, respectively.
3

According to the equations, photosynthesis requires sunlight as a reactant,

while cellular respiration does not,so eliminate (F) and (G) because they state that sunlight is necessary for cellular respiration.
4

14
5

The passage states that photosynthesis consumes carbon dioxide. Eliminate (J)

which states that photosynthesis would cause the cabomba in Vial 1 to consume less, rather than more, carbon dioxide than the cabomba in Vial 2. The correct answer is (H).
6

15
◀ Previous10 / 11Next ▶
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
Key Experimental Procedures & Practical Investigations
The question asks whether an unknown solution that causes the phenol red solution in Vial 1 to turn yellow is likely to be acidic or basic.
Table 2 shows that the solution in Vial 1 was orange after the 48-hour incubation period.
According to Figure 1, orange solutions have a pH between 6.6 and 8.1 and yellow solutions have a pH below 6.6.

This means that the pH of the solution decreased as it changed color from orange to yellow.
◀ Previous11 / 11
1Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo2Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo3Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo4Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo5Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo6Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo7Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo8Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo9Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo10Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo11Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo12Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1

1
2

Eliminate (A) and (C)

which state that the pH of the solution increased rather than decreased.
3

To choose between the remaining choices, you need some outside knowledge.
4

Acidic solutions have a pH less than 7.0

while basic solutions have a pH greater than 7.0.Eliminate (B) since addition of a basic solution would cause the pH to increase rather than decrease.
5

The correct answer is (D).
6

2
1 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
The question asks for the color of the solution in Vial 7 after 48 hours with exposure to light if the vial had contained a tadpole.
According to Table 4, Vial 7 contained neither a cabomba nor a goldfish, was not exposed to light,

and remained orange after the 48-hour incubation period.
A tadpole is an animal

so find the vial that was also exposed to light and contained an animal.
Vial 3 was exposed to light and contained a goldfish.
The solution in Vial 3 turned yellow after the 48-hour incubation period.
3
◀ Previous2 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Eliminate (H) and (J) since they both indicate that the solution would turn dark pink. Eliminate (G) since it incorrectly claims that the tadpole would undergo photosynthesis. The correct answer is (F).
4
The question asks how the wind force varies as V is increased, based on the results of Experiment
2. The results of Experiment 2 are shown in Table 2.
Use Table 2 and look for the relationship between the values of V and the wind force, F w.
For each trial in Table 2, the value for V increases, from 3.0 m/s in Trial 6 to 7.0 m/s in Trial 10.
◀ Previous3 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1

For F w, the value is 1.73 N for Trial 6 and increases in every trial, ending with a maximum F w of 9.42 N in Trial 10.
2

The correct answer is (A).
3

5
4

The question asks which calculation would always result in zero, based on Experiments 1 and 2. The information for all variables in the answer choices is in Table 1

so choose any trial and plug in the values to calculate each answer.
5

Start with (F).
6

For (F), refer to Trial 1 in Table 1.

When the value of –1.22 N for F Tv is subtracted from the value of 1.22 N for F B, the result is 1.22 – (–1.22), which does not equal zero.
◀ Previous4 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1

Eliminate (F).
2

6
3

For (G), when the value of 0.28 N for F w is subtracted from the value of 1.22 N for F B, the result does not equal zero.
4

Eliminate (G).
5

For (H), when the value of –1.22 N for F Tv is added to the value of 1.22 N for F B, the result is 1.22 + (–1.22) which equals zero.
6

Keep (H).
◀ Previous5 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
For (J), when the value of –0.28 N for F w is added to the value of 1.22 N for F B, the result does not equal zero.
Eliminate (J).
The correct answer is (H).
7
The question asks whether a specific method of determining wind force would be an appropriate method to use in all the trials, given that the method was only valid for wind forces greater than 0.4 N.
Begin by examining Table 1 and looking at the wind force F w values for Trials 1 through 5.

Trial 1 had a wind force value of 0.28 N, which is less than the 0.4 N stated in the question.
◀ Previous6 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1

Eliminate (A) and (C)

which both state that the value of F w exceeded 0.4 N in all trials.
2

8
3

Since the method is unreliable to calculate forces less than 0.4 N, the method would be inappropriate for Trial 1. Eliminate (D) since it indicates that the method would be appropriate to use in Trials 1–10. The correct answer is (B).
4

9
5

The question asks at which horizontal wind speed the value of F Th would be equal to F Tv in Experiment 2. The results of Experiment 2 are shown in Table 2. Examine the columns for F Th and F Tv in Table 2. The value of F Tv remains constant at –5.64 N.
6

For the value of F Th to equal the value of F Tv, F Th would also have to equal –5.64 N.
◀ Previous7 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
The value –5.64 N is between –4.81 N in Trial 8 and –6.92 N in Trial 9.

The wind speed is likely between the values of the wind speed for these two trials.
10
In Trial 8, V = 5.0 m/s, and in Trial 9, V = 6.0 m/s. The only value between 5.0 m/s and 6.0 m/s is 5.5 m/s in (H). The correct answer is (H).
11
The question asks for the radius of the balloon in Experiment 1 corresponding to an experimental value, F w, of 1.65 N.
The results of Experiment 1 are shown in Table 1. Determine the relationship between the radius, r, and F w.
◀ Previous8 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
As seen in Table 1, as r increases, F w also increases.
The greatest value of F w is 1.51 N

which is when r = 0.7 m.
Since there is a direct relationship between r and F w and 1.65 N is greater than 1.51 N, the radius will be larger than 0.7 m.
12
Eliminate (A) and (B)

which both indicate a radius less than 0.7 m.
To choose between (C) and (D), look at the values of F w to estimate the rate of increase.
◀ Previous9 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1

As seen in Table 1, the value of F w increases by at least 0.2 N for every 0.1 m increase in the radius, r.
2

Eliminate (D) since a radius greater than 0.8 meters would result in a value of F w greater than 1.51 N + 0.2 N = 1.71 N.
3

The correct answer is (C).
4

13
5

The question asks for the statements about r or V that best indicates the main difference between the experiments.
6

The first part of the answers refers to Experiment 1

so look at r and V in Experiment 1.In this experiment, the passage states that r was varied, and V was constant at 2.0 m/s.
◀ Previous10 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1

Eliminate (F) and (G), as they both incorrectly state that r was held constant rather than varied.
2

Next examine Experiment 2.
3

14
4

You need some outside knowledge here: an independent variable is also known as a manipulated variable because it is a variable whose value is manipulated by the experimenter. In Experiment 2, the value of V was manipulated by the scientists

so V is an independent variable. Eliminate (H). The correct answer is (J).
5

15
6

The question asks for the vector notation of the force of the wind, in N, during Trial 5. The question states that the notation lists the horizontal component first followed by the vertical component.
◀ Previous11 / 12Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Since the question asks about wind force, look at F w.
The value for F w = 1.51 N in Trial 5. The passage states that the wind force, F w, was purely horizontal.
This means that the value of the vertical component, V y, must be zero.
16
Eliminate (A) and (C) since they both have a non-zero vertical component ( V y ). Eliminate (D), as it shows a negative V x component of the vector. The correct answer is (B).
◀ Previous12 / 12
1Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation2Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation3Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation4Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation5Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation6Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation7Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation8Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation9Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation10Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation11Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
1

1
2

The question asks which term accurately represents the process by which the charged particles were formed, according to both scientists.
3

According to Scientist 1, electrically charged ash particles are created in a process called fractoemission,

and according to Scientist 2, collisions cause the particles to become charged in a process known as ice charging.
4

Eliminate (F) because neither explanation mentions combustion or burning.
5

2
6

Ionization means the process of uncharged particles becoming charged

which is consistent with both explanations. There is no mention of weathering or condensationso eliminate (H) and (J). The correct answer is (G).
1 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
3
The question asks which scientist’s viewpoint, if either, is inconsistent with the assertion that the ash particles would not have crossed the freeze line before the lightning strikes.
Scientist 2 states the particles rise above the freeze line prior to lightning strikes slightly downwind from the vent and high in the ash plume,

which is inconsistent with the new information.
Eliminate (A) and (B) because they do not include Scientist 2. Scientist 1 never mentions the freeze line.
Eliminate (D).
The correct answer is (C).
◀ Previous2 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
4
The question asks whether the charged particles were generated prior to or after the eruption, according to each scientist.
Work one hypothesis at a time and use POE.
According to Scientist 1, when the magma is fractured, electrically charged ash particles are created,

then charged particles are expelled during the eruption.
Therefore, Scientist 1 believes the particles are charged prior to the eruption.
Eliminate (H) and (J).
◀ Previous3 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
1

5
2

According to Scientist 2, neutral ash particles are ejected in dense ash plumes at high speeds and then after the plume has crossed the freeze line, collisions cause the particles to become charged in a process known as ice charging. Eliminate (G). The correct answer is (F).
3

6
4

The question asks whether Scientist 1’s theory is strengthened or weakened by the new evidence that previously charged particles are discharged before they can reach an altitude of more than 10 km.
5

Refer to the passage and look for data about altitude.
6

According to the passage, volcanic lightning was observed in the ash cloud following the eruption, with some branches of lightning extending up to 15 km above the volcanic vent.
◀ Previous4 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
1

7
2

There is no evidence that every one of the lightning branches was above a certain altitude.
3

Eliminate (B) since it states that all lightning extended 15 km above the vent.
4

Eliminate (D) since it states that all lightning extended more than 10 km above the vent.
5

Scientist 1 claims that lightning bolts are generated to resolve the difference in charges of ash particles.
6

8
◀ Previous5 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
However, if these particles are discharged before they reach 10 km, Scientist 1 would not expect the observed lightning extending up to 15 km above the volcanic vent during a volcanic eruption. Eliminate (C). The correct answer is (A).
9
The question asks which new evidence would most support Scientist 1’s explanation.
Refer to the passage and look for key terms in the answer choices.
Choice (F) mentions the formation of ice particles.
However, it is Scientist 2 who explains volcanic lighting as dependent on the formation of ice

while Scientist 1 never mentions ice particles.
◀ Previous6 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
1

Eliminate (F) as it refers to the wrong hypothesis.
2

10
3

Similarly, LIVS are only mentioned by Scientist 2, who states that the absence of LIVS means the lightning observed must have been due to ice charging.
4

Eliminate (J) as it supports the wrong scientist’s viewpoint.
5

Scientist 1 claims that lightning bolts always occur less than a kilometer downwind from the vent.
6

Eliminate (G) because evidence of lightning damage 5 km downwind of Mt.
◀ Previous7 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Vesuvius’s vent would weaken Scientist 1’s hypothesis.
Choice (H) mentions 2,100-year-old silicate-rich lava on Mt.
Vesuvius.
11
Scientist 1 states that fractures in silicate-rich magma, like that found at Mt. Vesuvius in 79 BCE caused the fractoemission charging. The correct answer is (H).
12
◀ Previous8 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
The question asks whether Scientist 1 would agree that Br radicals might have been present in the Mt. Vesuvius ash and whether Scientist 2 would agree that LIVS might have been present given the occurrence of lightning strikes in the core of the ash plume of Mt. Vesuvius in 79 BCE. Work one hypothesis at a time and use POE.
13
According to the passage, Scientist 1 states that volcanic lightning leads to the creation of Br radicals in the ash plume immediately surrounding the lightning strike, and sediment found within a kilometer of Mt.
Vesuvius contains evidence of high concentrations of Br radicals in the ash from 79 BCE.
This supports the presence of Br radicals

so eliminate (A) and (B).
14
◀ Previous9 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
1

Scientist 2 claims that when volcanic lightning occurs in the densely packed core of the ash cloud immediately following the eruption, as occurs with fractoemission charging, round crystals called lightning-induced volcanic spherules (LIVS) are produced

so eliminate (C)which says that Scientist 2 would not agree that LIVS might have been present in the ash when lightning did occur under these conditions. The correct answer is (D).
2

15
3

The question asks if the positively charged particles discussed by Scientist 1 would increase or decrease in mass as a result of becoming charged.
4

A bit of outside knowledge could help

but is not really needed to answer the question.
5

An atom

which is neutrally charged, becomes positively charged if it loses an electron.
6

Without knowing that, use the information in the passages and POE.
◀ Previous10 / 11Next ▶
Comprehensive Problem Solving & Synoptic Evaluation
1

16
2

Scientist 1 says that the positively charged particles travel faster and higher in the ash cloud, indicating that they are lighter than the negatively charged particles.
3

This implies that they have decreased in mass

so eliminate (F) and (G)which both indicate an increase in mass.
4

According to (J), the particles gained a proton.
5

But since protons have mass, this would involve an increase rather than a decrease in mass

eliminate (J).
6

The correct answer is (H).
◀ Previous11 / 11
Accepted payment methods