1Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo2Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo3Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo4Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo5Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo6Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo7Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo8Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo9Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo10Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Framewo
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
2
H. De-icer B
because its proficiency rating was lower than the TDM at each temperature tested. J. De-icer Bbecause its proficiency rating was higher than the TDM at each temperature tested.
4
Comets originate from regions of our solar system that are very far from the Sun.
5
The comets are formed from debris thrown from objects in the solar system: they have a nucleus of ice surrounded by dust and frozen gases.
6
When comets are pulled into the Earth’s atmosphere by gravitational forces and become visible, they are called meteors.
1 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Meteors become visible about 50 to 85 km above the surface of Earth as air friction causes them to glow.
Most meteors vaporize completely before they come within 50 km of the surface of Earth.
Recently, images taken by two instruments, UVA and VIS, revealed dark spots and streaks in the Earth’s atmosphere.
The significance of these dark spots and streaks is not fully understood.
The Small Comet Theory asserts that these spots and streaks are due to a constant rain of small ice comets,
but some scientists argue that the spots are just random technological noise.
◀ Previous2 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
UVA and VIS technologies provide images of energy that cannot be seen by the human eye. Both instruments take images in the magnetosphere, in which they orbit. The layers of Earth’s atmosphere are shown in Figure 1.
Two scientists debate whether there is a constant rain of comets burning up in Earth’s magnetosphere.
Small comets are pulled into Earth’s atmosphere by gravitational effects and burn up in the magnetosphere.
Small comets are about 20 to 30 feet in diameter and burn up in the magnetosphere because they are much smaller than the comets that become meteors.
◀ Previous3 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1
Comets with larger diameters will burn up in portions of the atmosphere much closer to Earth.
3
About 30,000 small comets enter the Earth’s magnetosphere every day.
4
The dark spots and streaks on UVA and VIS images occur when the small comets begin to boil in the magnetosphere, releasing krypton and argon and creating gaseous H 2 O,
which interacts with hydroxyl, OH – , radicals.
5
Images taken by these instruments at different points in time show the same frequency of dark spots and streaks and give conclusive evidence in favor of the Small Comet Theory.
◀ Previous4 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1
If the spots and streaks were due to random technological noise
then the frequency of their appearance would fluctuate.
3
The dark spots and streaks in the UVA and VIS images are due to technological noise, not small comets.
4
If the Small Comet Theory were true,
and 20 small comets bombarded Earth’s atmosphere per minute, there would be a visible bright object at least twice every five minutes.
5
This is because, as objects enter the Earth’s mesosphere, they burn up, creating large clouds of ice particles.
6
As the ice particles vaporize, they become approximately as bright in the sky as Venus.
◀ Previous5 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Because comets rarely enter Earth’s atmosphere, such bright flashes are rare, occurring far less than two times every five minutes.
Therefore, the Small Comet Theory cannot be correct.
Further, since comets originate from regions of space beyond the orbit of the farthest planet, they contain argon and krypton.
If the Small Comet Theory were true and Earth were bombarded by 30,000 comets per day, there would be 500 times as much krypton in the atmosphere as there actually is.
◀ Previous6 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
1
27. According to Scientist 2
which of the following planets in our solar system is most likely the closest to the region of space where comets originate?
3
28. Based on Scientist 1’s viewpoint, a comet that burns up in the thermosphere would have a diameter of: J. greater than 30 ft. 29. Which of the following generalizations about small comets is most consistent with Scientist 1’s viewpoint?
5
A. No small comet ever becomes a meteor. B. Some small comets become meteors. C. Small comets become meteors twice every five minutes. D. All small comets become meteors.
◀ Previous7 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
30. During the Perseids, an annual meteor shower, more than 1 object visibly burns up in the atmosphere per minute. According to the information provided, Scientist 2 would classify the Perseids as:
F. typical comet frequency in the magnetosphere. G. unusual comet frequency in the magnetosphere. H. typical meteor frequency in the mesosphere.
J. unusual meteor frequency in the mesosphere. 31. Given the information about meteors in the introduction, at which of the following altitudes above the sea level on Earth would a meteor NOT be visibly glowing?
◀ Previous8 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
32. Suppose that a study of meteors of various sizes revealed that a large meteor observed during the study period was visible in the stratosphere before it vaporized completely. How would the findings of this study most likely affect the scientists’ viewpoints, if at all?
F. It would not affect either scientist’s viewpoint. G. It would strengthen Scientist 1’s viewpoint only. H. It would strengthen Scientist 2’s viewpoint only.
J. It would weaken both scientists’ viewpoints. 33. Scientist 1 would most likely suggest that astronomers attempting to take pictures of small comets in the atmosphere should use enhanced imaging technology to look in which region?
◀ Previous9 / 10Next ▶
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
Analytical Data, Comparative Structures & Scientific Frameworks
A. The region between 15 km above sea level and 50 km above sea level B. The region between 50 km above sea level and 85 km above sea level C. The region between 85 km above sea level and 600 km above sea level
◀ Previous10 / 10