المناهج الدراسية
تسجيل الدخول
نص الدرس

Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves?

English — Second Secondary — Term 2

Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves?

Section B: Speaking Up for Others. Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves?

Section B: Speaking Up for Others. Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves?

Voiceless Voices for the Planet←، Wildlife cannot file a complaint and an ecosystem cannot lobby governments, so sharing the planet often depends on people who are willing to advocate for those who have no voice of their own.
  • What does it mean to advocate for wildlife or an ecosystem that cannot speak for itself?
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 1 / 9
Discussion and JRE

Discussion and JRE

JRE (Justify – Reason – Evidence)

  • To what extent is it fair to ask fishermen to change their equipment to protect sea turtles, if doing so affects their livelihood?
  • Justify your answer.
  • (Evaluate) Have you ever seen someone take action to protect an animal, place, or cause? What did they do?
  • (Analyze) Why might listening to opponents, rather than only campaigning against them, make a campaign more effective?
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 2 / 9
Reading text: The Girl Who Wouldn’t Forget

Reading text: The Girl Who Wouldn’t Forget

  • An original pedagogical reading text custom-authored by the national Curriculum Development team; adapted from a youth marine conservation profile series, from international marine conservation reports, youth environmental leadership frameworks and evidence-based reading skills.
  • Nour was fifteen when she found a sea turtle tangled in a discarded fishing net on a beach near Hurghada.
  • By the time she and her cousin pulled it free, it had already died.
  • She still remembers deciding, on the walk home, that she was too angry to simply forget about it by the following week, the way she suspected most people who saw something like that probably did.
  • What began as a single Instagram post showing the photograph, captioned with barely more than a few furious sentences, slowly turned into something closer to a campaign.
  • Nour started organizing monthly beach cleanups, initially with three friends and a handful of trash bags, sharing details of each cleanup on her social media account.
  • Marine biologists occasionally comment that turtles cannot speak for themselves, cannot lobby a government or file a complaint about a net left in the water, which is precisely the gap Nour says she is trying to fill.
  • Local fishermen were not always welcoming.
  • Several told her directly that fishing was their livelihood, not a hobby, and that a teenager posting photographs online understood little about the cost of switching to more turtle-friendly equipment.
  • Nour has since spent considerable time simply listening to these objections rather than dismissing them.
  • Her campaign now includes a small fund, built from donations, that helps cover the cost of safer net attachments for fishermen willing to try them, a compromise she describes as more effective than any amount of online outrage alone.
  • Three years on, her cleanups have regularly drawn more than sixty volunteers, and two local hotels have begun funding equipment directly.
  • Nour insists she has not solved anything close to the wider problem, and marine plastic continues to arrive on the same beaches regardless of how many cleanups she organizes.
  • What she believes she has done, more modestly, is to prove that a single furious teenager with a phone can build something that outlasts the anger that started it, provided she is willing to keep showing up long after the initial outrage fades.
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 3 / 9
JRE: read the two views

JRE: read the two views

  1. Read the two views
  2. then decide which one you agree with. Weigh both cards before you judge.
One viewNour’s campaign shows that a single act of anger can grow into something that genuinely helps others.
The other viewLocal fishermen had a legitimate, competing concern, since nets were ‘their livelihood, not a hobby.’
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 4 / 9
Comprehension Check

Comprehension Check

  • Answer the following questions.
  • (Analyze) According to the text, what specific event motivated Nour to start her campaign?
  • (Explain) What does the writer mean by describing Nour’s role as filling ‘the gap’ left by turtles’ inability to speak for themselves?
  • (Explain) Why were local fishermen not always welcoming of Nour’s campaign at first?
  • (Evaluate) Do you think listening to opponents, as Nour did, is more effective than pure online activism? Justify your view.
  1. (suggested answer) She found a sea turtle tangled in a discarded fishing net near Hurghada, and it had already died when she and her cousin pulled it free.
  2. (suggested answer) Turtles cannot lobby governments or complain, so Nour acts as their voice and does what they cannot do for themselves.
  3. (suggested answer) They said fishing was their livelihood, not a hobby, and that a teenager online understood little about the cost of switching to turtle-friendly equipment.
  4. (suggested answer) Yes, because listening led to a fund for safer nets, a compromise that works better than online outrage alone.
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 5 / 9
True / False / Not Given

True / False / Not Given

  1. State whether each statement is True (T)
  2. False (F)
  3. or Not Given (NG). Justify your answer.
Statement T/F/NG Justify your answer
1. Nour found the sea turtle when she was fifteen years old. T (suggested answer) Nour was fifteen when she found it.
  • 2. Nour’s campaign began with a large
  • organized group of volunteers
F (suggested answer) It began with a single post and three friends.
3. Some fishermen said switching equipment would be costly and could affect their livelihood. T (suggested answer) They said it was their livelihood and a costly change.
4. Nour’s campaign has completely stopped plastic from reaching local beaches. F (suggested answer) Marine plastic continues to arrive.
5. The text states how much money each hotel contributed. NG (suggested answer) No amounts are given.
NOTE←If you mark a statement Not Given (NG) in one line, write what the text would need to say for you to decide whether it is True (T) or False (F), and where in the text you looked.
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 6 / 9
Vocabulary

Vocabulary

  • Match the following words with their meanings.
Words Meanings
1. tangled a. an organized series of actions with a specific social or political goal
2. discarded b. continues to exist for longer than something else
3. campaign c. caught or twisted together in a confused mess
4. lobby d. to try to persuade a government or official to support a particular cause
5. livelihood e. an agreement reached when each side gives up part of what they wanted
6. compromise f. thrown away because no longer wanted
7. outlasts g. a person’s main way of earning money or supporting themselves
Answers (suggested answer)←1-c, 2-f, 3-a, 4-d, 5-g, 6-e, 7-b.
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 7 / 9
Writing in Action: Social Media Post for Analysis

Writing in Action: Social Media Post for Analysis

  • Read this post carefully. You will analyze its language and assess its reliability in the activities below.
  • @OceanHeroesNow, 2.1M followers: SHARK NUMBERS COLLAPSING WORLDWIDE!!
  • Scientists CONFIRM it’s already too late for some species.
  • Every fishing boat is destroying the ocean.
  • Share before this gets banned from the platform!
  • Tag someone who needs to see this NOW.
  • 356,000 likes, 68,000 reposts, 12,400 comments. Fact-check rating: MISLEADING
Feature What to Look For Example from the Post
Emotional language Words designed to alarm or provoke outrage COLLAPSING / destroying
Absolute language Claims with no qualification or evidence Every fishing boat / too late for some species
Urgency signals Language creating pressure to act immediately Share this before it gets banned! Tag someone NOW
Missing information No named source, study, or specific data ‘Scientists CONFIRM’ with no named scientists or study
Oversimplification A complex issue reduced to one villain Blaming ‘every fishing boat’ equally
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 8 / 9
Writing Task

Writing Task

  • Write a post for your school’s media club page.
  • Evaluate ONE example of a viral post about wildlife or an environmental crisis, using the reliability table on the previous page.
  • Concede Although some environmental crises are genuinely urgent, exaggeration can make people distrust real evidence.
  • Then, conclude by explaining how to check a claim like this before sharing it.
Lesson 6.3: Who speaks for those who cannot speak for themselves? · 9 / 9