4.2.64 · Cell Membranes and Transport
Investigating Diffusion — Cambridge AS & A Level Biology 9700 Revision Notes & Topical Questions
5 min read 10 parts Lesson 13 of 20 1 quiz
Lesson summary
4.2.6 Investigating Diffusion — CAMBRIDGE AS & A LEVEL BIOLOGY 9700 — REVISION NOTES notes: Investigate how surface area, concentration, temperature and molecular size affect diffusion using agar, dye and Visking tubing models, and evaluate the methods.
- Why models
- Indicators
- Explanation
- Depth reached
- Concentration gradient
- Dye in agar
Part 1 of 8Models of diffusion
Why models
- Why models diffusion cannot be seen directly,
- so agar jelly is used,
- because it is mostly water and dissolved substances diffuse through it like cytoplasm.
Indicators
- Indicators they show how far a substance has travelled.
Set-up
- Set-up the substance diffuses from a source into a block that mimics a cell.
- (the surrounding liquid)
Links
- Links the work illustrates Fick's law and the surface area to volume ratio, and shows why cells are small.
Part 2 of 8Agar blocks containing indicator
1
Make agar jelly containing phenolphthalein and a little sodium hydroxide so that it is pink, pour it into a shallow dish and let it set.
2
Cut blocks of different sizes, for example 1, 2 and 3 cm cubes, using a scalpel and ruler on a tile.
3
Place the blocks in equal volumes of dilute hydrochloric acid (for example 0.1 mol dm-3) at a constant temperature.
4
Time how long each block takes to become completely colourless as acid reaches the centre.
5
Alternatively, remove blocks at a fixed time, cut them in half and measure the depth of colour change with a ruler.
Results
- Results smaller blocks with a larger surface area to volume ratio decolourise faster.
Explanation
- Explanation the diffusion distance is shorter and the surface area is large compared with the volume to be reached.
Depth reached
- Depth reached acid diffuses to about the same depth in a given time in any block, but it reaches a larger fraction of a small block.
Safety
- Safety dilute acid and alkali irritate skin and eyes, so wear eye protection and cut away from the hand.
Part 3 of 8Other variables to investigate
Temperature
- Temperature repeat with acid at 20, 30, 40 and 50 °C in water baths, where higher temperature gives more kinetic energy and faster diffusion.
Concentration gradient
- Concentration gradient use different acid concentrations, where a steeper gradient gives a faster rate.
Dye in agar
- Dye in agar place a drop of potassium permanganate or a dye crystal on agar in a petri dish and measure the diameter of the coloured circle at timed intervals.
- Dyes with a larger molecular mass spread more slowly.
Rate
- Rate calculate it as 1 ÷ time, or as distance diffused ÷ time.
Part 4 of 8Visking tubing
Visking tubing
Fill a section of Visking (dialysis) tubing with starch and glucose solutions and place it in a tube of water.
After a set time, test the water outside with iodine solution for starch and Benedict's reagent for glucose.
Repeat at intervals to see whether either substance has diffused out.
Result
- Result glucose passes through the pores but starch does not.
Conclusion
- Conclusion a non-living partially permeable membrane can select by molecular size.
Part 5 of 8Calculating and presenting results
1Recording
- Recording record each time to the nearest second and repeat at least three times for each block size.
2Processing
- Processing calculate a mean and then the SA:V of each block from its dimensions.
3Graph
- Graph plot time or rate against SA:V or temperature, and draw a line of best fit.
4Anomalies
- Anomalies check for anomalous results and decide whether to repeat them.
Part 6 of 8Evaluating the investigation
| Limitation | Improvement |
|---|---|
| End point judged by eye | Use the same observer, a colour standard or a colorimeter |
| Blocks cut unevenly | Use a sharper cutter or a template |
| Acid concentration falls as it is used | Use a larger volume of acid |
| Few repeats | Do more repeats and use a digital timer |
Limit of the model
- Limit of the model an agar block has no membrane with transport proteins, active transport or metabolism, which a real cell has.
Link to cells
- Link to cells a 10 micrometre cell has a very high SA:V and is supplied within a fraction of a second,
- but the centre of a 10 cm block would take hours to receive oxygen by diffusion alone.
Part 7 of 8More from the specification
Facilitated diffusion
- Passive movement through transport proteins.
Channel protein
- Hydrophilic pore for specific ions or water.
Animal cell
- A cell with a nucleus, cytoplasm, cell membrane and mitochondria but no cell wall, chloroplasts or large vacuole.
Osmosis
- The net movement of water molecules from a region of higher water potential to a region of lower water potential through a partially permeable membrane.
Movement
- An action by an organism or part of it causing a change of position or place.
Carrier
- A female with one recessive sex-linked allele who is unaffected.
Sucrose
- The sugar mainly transported in phloem.
Endocytosis
- Bulk transport into a cell using a membrane vesicle.
Bilayer
- A double layer of phospholipids with tails facing inwards.
Water potential
- A measure of the tendency of water to move; pure water has the highest.
Selectively permeable
- Allowing only some substances through.
Size effect
- Size effect a larger block has more volume but proportionally less surface area, so diffusion to its centre takes longer and is less effective.
Part 8 of 8More on this topic
- Make the agar with very dilute sodium hydroxide and Universal Indicator (purple), or use phenolphthalein.
Key terms
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Agar | A water-based jelly used as a model of cytoplasm. |
| Indicator | A chemical that changes colour depending on pH. |
| Visking tubing | Partially permeable dialysis membrane used to model cell membranes. |
| Surface area to volume ratio | Surface area divided by volume. |
| Diffusion distance | The distance particles must move to cross a surface or enter a cell. |
| End point | The point at which a visible change shows a reaction is complete. |
| Rate | Change in a quantity divided by time. |
Avoid these mistakes
1
Saying the acid diffuses faster into small blocks — the speed is the same, but the time to reach the whole block is shorter.
2
Confusing diffusion distance with surface area — they are different factors.
3
Not controlling temperature, which directly affects diffusion rate.
4
Stating that Visking tubing is fully permeable — it is partially permeable by molecular size.
Topic quiz · 4 questionsQuiz for this lesson
Last updated: