- A drinking water laboratory receives a water sample that may contain several dissolved metal ions.
- Although the solution looks perfectly clear, chemists can identify and separate each metal ion by adding carefully selected reagents.
- Suddenly, white, black, yellow and reddish-brown precipitates appear one after another.
- In this lesson you will discover how chemists use precipitation reactions as a scientific tool to identify unknown substances and separate metal ions in environmental, industrial and medical laboratories.
- Guiding question How can invisible dissolved metal ions be identified and separated using observable chemical reactions?
Exploration
- Imagine two clear solutions are mixed together. Within seconds
- a bright yellow solid appears. Answer before studying the lesson:
- Why did a solid suddenly form although both solutions were transparent? Answer: The ions in the two solutions combined to form a compound that is insoluble in water, so it separated from the solution as a solid.
- What information might the colour of the precipitate provide? Answer: The colour is a characteristic clue to which metal ion and which anion have combined.
- Is the colour of the precipitate alone enough to identify the ion, and why? Answer: No. Different ions can give precipitates of the same colour (for example several white precipitates), so further tests are needed.
A precipitate→, A precipitate is an insoluble solid that forms and separates from a solution when ions in the solution combine.
A precipitation reaction→, A precipitation reaction is a reaction in which dissolved ions combine to form an insoluble solid compound.
(a) Precipitation reactions
- The table gives the chemical formulas and colours of the precipitates formed by various metal ions with different anions.
- The sign × means that no precipitate is formed.
| Metal ion |
Cl− |
S2− (acidic) |
S2− (basic) |
OH− |
| Ag+ |
AgCl white |
Ag2S black |
Ag2S black |
Ag2O brown |
| Pb2+ |
PbCl2 white |
PbS black |
PbS black |
Pb(OH)2 white |
| Cu2+ |
× |
CuS black |
CuS black |
Cu(OH)2 bluish-white |
| Fe2+ |
× |
× |
FeS black |
Fe(OH)2 greenish-white |
| Fe3+ |
× |
× |
FeS black |
iron(III) hydroxide, reddish-brown |
| Al3+ |
× |
× |
Al(OH)3 white |
Al(OH)3 white |
| Zn2+ |
× |
× |
ZnS white |
Zn(OH)2 white |
- Different metal ions produce precipitates with characteristic colours when they react with specific anions.
- Chloride ions form white precipitates with Ag+ and Pb2+.
- Sulfide ions form black precipitates with Cu2+, Fe2+ and Fe3+, and a white precipitate with Zn2+.
- Key concepts selective precipitation, complex ion formation, solubility.
- Selective precipitation , Selective precipitation is the separation of particular metal ions from a mixture by adding a reagent that precipitates only some of the ions.
- Solubility , Solubility is the extent to which a substance dissolves in a solvent such as water.
- A complex ion , A complex ion is an ion formed when a metal ion binds to molecules or ions such as ammonia, for example [Ag(NH3)2]+.
(b) Precipitation reactions with other anions
(i) Reaction with the chromate ion CrO42−
- Ag+ produces a reddish-brown precipitate of silver chromate, Ag2CrO4.
- Pb2+ produces a yellow precipitate of lead(II) chromate, PbCrO4.
- It reacts with Fe3+ to produce a dark blue precipitate.
Nature of Science: Prediction
- Predict what will happen when silver nitrate is added to a chloride solution, and what evidence would confirm the prediction.
- Answer A white precipitate of silver chloride, AgCl, will form. The evidence is the white solid that appears, which dissolves in excess aqueous ammonia and turns black when exposed to light.
(i) Chloride precipitates
- PbCl2 is soluble in hot water.
- AgCl dissolves in excess aqueous ammonia, producing diamminesilver(I) ions, [Ag(NH3)2]+.
(ii) Hydroxide precipitates
- Among Ag2O, Pb(OH)2, Cu(OH)2, Fe(OH)2, iron(III) hydroxide, Al(OH)3 and Zn(OH)2:
Soluble in excess aqueous sodium hydroxidePb(OH)2, Al(OH)3 and Zn(OH)2.
Soluble in excess aqueous ammoniaAg2O, Cu(OH)2 and Zn(OH)2.
(d) Separation of metal ions
- By using the precipitation reactions of metal ions, specific metal ions can be separated from an aqueous solution that contains several metal ions.
| Step |
Operation |
Metal ions that precipitate |
Precipitate (colour) |
| 1 |
Add dilute hydrochloric acid |
Ag+, Pb2+ |
AgCl (white), PbCl2 (white) |
| 2 |
Pass hydrogen sulfide gas through the solution (acidic) |
Cu2+, Cd2+ |
CuS (black), CdS (yellow) |
| 3 |
Add excess aqueous ammonia |
Fe3+, Al3+ |
iron(III) hydroxide (reddish-brown), Al(OH)3 (white) |
| 4 |
Pass hydrogen sulfide gas through the solution (basic) |
Zn2+, Mn2+ |
ZnS (white), MnS (pale pink) |
| 5 |
Add aqueous ammonium carbonate |
Ca2+, Ba2+ |
CaCO3 (white), BaCO3 (white) |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Claim | A white precipitate alone is not enough to identify a metal ion | whiteprecipitatealoneenough |
| Evidence | AgCl, PbCl2, Al(OH)3 and Zn(OH)2 can all appear white. | AgClPbCl2appearwhite |
| Reasoning | Use information from this lesson to explain why additional chemical tests are necessary before identifying an unknown ion | informationlessonexplainadditional |
| Answer | - Several different ions give white precipitates
- so the colour cannot decide between them. Extra tests separate them by their other properties: PbCl2 dissolves in hot water but AgCl does not
- AgCl dissolves in excess ammonia and turns black in light
- Al(OH)3 dissolves in excess sodium hydroxide but not in excess ammonia
- whereas Zn(OH)2 dissolves in both
| Severaldifferentionsgive |
- Based on the flowchart showing the separation of six metal ions (Ag+, Al3+, Cu2+, Fe3+, Pb2+ and Zn2+) from a mixed aqueous solution, answer the following questions.
- Identify the chemical formulas and colours of precipitates C, E and F. Identify the name and colour of precipitate J.
- Identify the chemical formulas of the complex ions formed when the metal ions in precipitate C and in filtrate I react with ammonia.
- Explain the purpose of the underlined operation in the flowchart (boiling, then adding dilute nitric acid, then adding excess aqueous ammonia).
- Explain the problem that would occur if hydrogen sulfide (H2S) gas were mistakenly passed through the mixed aqueous solution before the addition of dilute hydrochloric acid (HCl).
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Add dilute hydrochloric acid to the mixed solution | - precipitate A (AgCl
- PbCl2) separates from filtrate B (Al3+
- Cu2+
- Fe3+
- Zn2+)
| precipitateAgClPbCl2separates |
| Pour hot water on precipitate A | precipitate C (AgCl) remains and filtrate D contains Pb2+ | AgClremainsfiltratecontains |
| Add aqueous potassium chromate K2CrO4 to filtrate D | precipitate E (PbCrO4) | precipitatePbCrO4 |
| • | Pass sufficient hydrogen sulfide H2S through filtrate B (acidic): precipitate F (CuS) and filtrate G (Al3+, Fe2+ (Fe3+), Zn2+). | Passsufficienthydrogensulfide |
| • | Boil filtrate G to remove the remaining hydrogen sulfide, add dilute nitric acid HNO3, and then add excess aqueous ammonia NH3: precipitate H (Al(OH)3 and iron(III) hydroxide) and filtrate I (Zn2+). | Boilfiltrateremoveremaining |
| Add excess aqueous sodium hydroxide NaOH to precipitate H | precipitate J (iron(III) hydroxide) and filtrate K ([Al(OH)4]−) | ironfiltrate |
Explanation
- Confirm the reactions one by one.
- When dilute hydrochloric acid is added, the ions that produce precipitates are Ag+ and Pb2+, and the formulas of the precipitates are AgCl and PbCl2.
- Of these, the one that does not dissolve in hot water is AgCl.
- When aqueous potassium chromate is added to the solution in which PbCl2 was dissolved in hot water, Pb2+ and chromate ions CrO42− react to produce a yellow precipitate of lead(II) chromate, PbCrO4.
- The ions in filtrate B are Al3+, Cu2+, Fe3+ and Zn2+. Because dilute hydrochloric acid was added in step 1, the solution is acidic. When hydrogen sulfide is passed through it, only Cu2+ produces a precipitate, whose formula is CuS.
- The ions in filtrate G are Al3+, Fe2+ (Fe3+) and Zn2+. When an aqueous base is added to them, they produce precipitates of Al(OH)3, iron(III) hydroxide and Zn(OH)2 respectively. Of these, the one that dissolves in excess aqueous ammonia is Zn(OH)2.
- Al(OH)3 dissolves in excess aqueous sodium hydroxide, whereas iron(III) hydroxide does not.
Answers
- C: chemical formula AgCl, colour white. E: chemical formula PbCrO4, colour yellow. F: chemical formula CuS, colour black. J: iron(III) hydroxide, colour reddish-brown.
- C: the ion in precipitate C is Ag+, so the complex ion formed with ammonia is [Ag(NH3)2]+. I: the ion in filtrate I is Zn2+, so the complex ion formed with ammonia is [Zn(NH3)4]2+.
- The hydrogen sulfide added in step 4 reduced Fe3+ to Fe2+. Dilute nitric acid is added to oxidise Fe2+ back to Fe3+.
- Ag+ and Pb2+ would precipitate prematurely as sulfides, which would prevent their separation from metal ions such as Cu2+. As a result, the later analytical procedures, such as dissolving Pb2+ in hot water and detecting it with chromate (CrO42−), would become impossible.
- Many electronic devices contain valuable metals such as silver and copper.
- Instead of mining new metals, industries can recover these metals from electronic waste using precipitation reactions.
- Recovering metals helps to:
- reduce mining waste
- conserve natural resources
- decrease environmental pollution
- support a circular economy
- Chemical engineers often design automated systems that continuously separate dissolved metal ions during water treatment and mining.
- Which property of precipitates would be most important when designing such a system?
- Explain your answer.
- Answer The most important property is the solubility of each precipitate under different conditions (in hot water, in acid or base, and in excess reagent). Because the system must precipitate one group of ions while leaving the others dissolved, the engineer chooses reagents and conditions so that each precipitate forms or dissolves selectively and can be filtered off cleanly, for example PbCl2 dissolving in hot water while AgCl does not.
- Choose the correct answer.
- Zn(OH)2 dissolves in excess ammonia.
- Zn2+ forms a red precipitate.
- Fe3+ dissolves in ammonia.
- Fe3+ forms no precipitate.
Answer: A.→Zn(OH)2 dissolves in excess ammonia (forming [Zn(NH3)4]2+), whereas iron(III) hydroxide does not.
- To dissolve AgCl.
- To dissolve PbCl2.
- To dissolve CuS.
- To remove Zn2+.
Answer: B.→PbCl2 is soluble in hot water, while AgCl is not.
3. For each question, identify the appropriate metal ions from the list (A to G).
- (A) Ag+ (B) Cu2+ (C) Fe3+ (D) Fe2+ (E) Al3+ (F) Pb2+ (G) Zn2+
- Which metal ions produce a precipitate when dilute hydrochloric acid is added? (Select all that apply.) Answer: A and F (AgCl and PbCl2).
- Choose all metal ions that produce a precipitate when a small amount of aqueous sodium hydroxide is added. Answer: A, B, C, D, E, F and G (all seven form a hydroxide or oxide precipitate).
- From the precipitates in (b), choose all that dissolve when excess aqueous sodium hydroxide is added. Answer: E, F and G (Al(OH)3, Pb(OH)2, Zn(OH)2).
- From the precipitates in (b), choose all that dissolve when excess aqueous ammonia is added. Answer: A, B and G (Ag2O, Cu(OH)2, Zn(OH)2).
- (A) Ag+ (B) Al3+ (C) Cu2+ (D) Fe2+ (E) Fe3+ (F) Pb2+ (G) Zn2+
- When aqueous ammonia is added, a bluish-white precipitate is produced, but when more aqueous ammonia is added, the precipitate dissolves to form a deep blue aqueous solution. Answer: C (Cu2+).
- When dilute hydrochloric acid is added, a white precipitate is produced. When this precipitate is exposed to light, it turns black. Answer: A (Ag+).
- When aqueous ammonia is added, a white precipitate is produced, but when more aqueous ammonia is added, the precipitate dissolves to form a colourless aqueous solution. Answer: G (Zn2+).
- When aqueous potassium hexacyanidoferrate(II) is added, a dark blue precipitate is produced. Answer: E (Fe3+).
- When hydrochloric acid is added, a white precipitate is produced, and when aqueous potassium chromate is added, a yellow precipitate is produced. Answer: F (Pb2+).
5. Operations (i) to (v) were performed on a mixed solution containing six metal ions: K+, Ag+, Ca2+, Zn2+, Cu2+ and Al3+.
- Write the chemical formulas of the precipitates formed at each step (a) to (e) and of the ions present in the final filtrate (f).
- Add dilute hydrochloric acid, giving precipitate (a).
- Pass hydrogen sulfide gas through the filtrate (acidic), giving precipitate (b).
- After heating the filtrate, add excess aqueous ammonia to make it basic, giving precipitate (c).
- Pass hydrogen sulfide gas through the filtrate (basic), giving precipitate (d).
- Add aqueous ammonium carbonate to the filtrate, giving precipitate (e) and the final filtrate (f).
| Precipitate |
Formula |
Reason |
| (a) |
AgCl |
Ag+ precipitates with chloride. |
| (b) |
CuS |
Cu2+ precipitates with sulfide in acidic solution. |
| (c) |
Al(OH)3 |
Al3+ precipitates with ammonia, while Zn2+ stays dissolved as [Zn(NH3)4]2+. |
| (d) |
ZnS |
Zn2+ precipitates with sulfide in basic solution. |
| (e) |
CaCO3 |
Ca2+ precipitates with carbonate. |
| (f) |
K+ |
The ion that stays in the final filtrate. |
1. Complete the table by identifying the chemical formula and colour of the precipitate formed when each metal ion reacts with the reagent. If no precipitate forms, write ×.
| Reagent |
Ag+ |
Pb2+ |
Cu2+ |
Al3+ |
Zn2+ |
| Hydrochloric acid |
AgCl, white |
A: PbCl2, white |
B: × |
C: × |
× |
| Hydrogen sulfide (acidic) |
D: Ag2S, black |
E: PbS, black |
F: CuS, black |
× |
G: × |
| Aqueous ammonia (small amount) |
H: Ag2O, brown |
I: Pb(OH)2, white |
Cu(OH)2, bluish-white |
Al(OH)3, white |
J: Zn(OH)2, white |
| Aqueous NaOH (small amount) |
K: Ag2O, brown |
Pb(OH)2, white |
L: Cu(OH)2, bluish-white |
M: Al(OH)3, white |
N: Zn(OH)2, white |
2. Identify the cation (A to H) that corresponds to each observation (a) to (e).
- (A) Ag+ (B) Cu2+ (C) Fe3+ (D) Al3+ (E) Zn2+ (F) Ba2+ (G) Na+ (H) K+
- When a small amount of aqueous ammonia is added, a bluish-white precipitate is produced, and when an excess is added, the precipitate dissolves to form a deep blue solution. Answer: B (Cu2+).
- When hydrochloric acid is added, a white precipitate is obtained, and when aqueous potassium chromate is added, a reddish-brown precipitate is obtained. Answer: A (Ag+).
- When aqueous potassium hexacyanidoferrate(II) is added, a dark blue precipitate is produced. Answer: C (Fe3+).
- When a small amount of aqueous ammonia is added, a white precipitate is produced. Excess ammonia does not dissolve it, but excess aqueous sodium hydroxide does. Answer: D (Al3+).
- It produces a red-purple flame in a flame test. Answer: H (K+).
3. A solution contains eight metal ions: Pb2+, Cu2+, Fe3+, Zn2+, Ba2+, K+, Ag+ and Al3+. The operations in the diagram were performed to separate and identify each ion.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Operation 1 | - add hydrochloric acid to the mixed solution
- giving precipitate A and solution A
| hydrochloricacidmixedsolution |
| Operation 2 | - add boiling water to precipitate A
- giving precipitate B and solution B
| boilingwaterprecipitategiving |
| Operation 3 | - pass hydrogen sulfide (acidic) through solution A
- giving precipitate C and solution C
| passhydrogensulfideacidic |
| Operation 4 | - boil solution C
- add dilute nitric acid
- then add excess aqueous ammonia
- giving precipitate D and solution D
| boilsolutiondilutenitric |
| Operation 5 | - add excess aqueous sodium hydroxide to precipitate D
- giving precipitate E and solution E
| excessaqueoussodiumhydroxide |
| Operation 6 | - pass hydrogen sulfide (basic) through solution D
- giving precipitate F and solution F
| passhydrogensulfidebasic |
| Operation 7 | - boil solution F
- then add aqueous ammonium carbonate
- giving precipitate G and solution G
| boilsolutionthenaqueous |
- Identify the name and chemical formula of precipitate B. Answer: silver chloride, AgCl (PbCl2 dissolved in the boiling water).
- Explain why dilute nitric acid is added in operation 4. Answer: The hydrogen sulfide of operation 3 reduced Fe3+ to Fe2+, so dilute nitric acid is added to oxidise it back to Fe3+.
- Write the chemical formula of the complex ion present in solution E. Answer: [Al(OH)4]− (Al(OH)3 dissolves in excess sodium hydroxide, while iron(III) hydroxide remains as precipitate E).
- From the initial eight ions, identify those present in solution G and write their formulas. Answer: K+ only (Ba2+ was precipitated as BaCO3).
- A solution contains Ag+, Pb2+, Cu2+ and Zn2+.
- Design the shortest possible sequence of reagents that separates all four ions, and justify every step using the chemistry you learned.
- Answer (one possible design):
- Add dilute hydrochloric acid. Ag+ and Pb2+ precipitate as AgCl and PbCl2, while Cu2+ and Zn2+ stay in the filtrate.
- Pour hot water on the precipitate. PbCl2 dissolves (Pb2+ passes into the filtrate, confirmed with potassium chromate as yellow PbCrO4) and AgCl remains.
- Pass hydrogen sulfide through the acidic filtrate of step 1. Cu2+ precipitates as black CuS, while Zn2+ stays dissolved.
- Make the remaining filtrate basic (with ammonia) and pass hydrogen sulfide again. Zn2+ precipitates as white ZnS.