- Imagine a chemist working in a quality-control laboratory who receives two identical bottles containing colorless liquids.
- One liquid is used to preserve biological specimens, while the other is commonly found in nail polish remover.
- Although they look almost identical, simple chemical tests show that they behave very differently.
- One forms a brilliant silver mirror inside a test tube, while the other does not react at all.
- How can chemists distinguish between compounds that appear so similar?
- What does their molecular structure reveal about their chemical behavior?
- In this lesson we explore how the structures of aldehydes and ketones determine their properties, reactions, laboratory identification and real-world applications.
Guiding question→How do chemists distinguish between aldehydes and ketones using their chemical reactions?
Exploration
- A laboratory receives two unlabeled bottles containing colorless liquids.
- Bottle A forms a silver mirror when heated with Tollens’ reagent (an aqueous solution of ammoniacal silver nitrate).
- Bottle B shows no visible change.
- Discuss:
- Are the two liquids the same compound?
- What evidence would help identify each substance?
- Why might one react while the other does not?
- Answers (worked out; the book gives no answer key):
- No. They are different compounds, because they behave differently in the same test.
- The silver mirror test (Tollens’ reagent) and Fehling’s test a positive result shows a reducing compound, an aldehyde.
- Bottle A contains an aldehyde, which is easily oxidised and therefore reduces the silver ions. Bottle B contains a ketone, which is not easily oxidised and has no reducing property.
Aldehydes→, Aldehydes are compounds that contain a formyl group (aldehyde group) –CHO; their general formula is R–CHO.
- Aldehydes are obtained by oxidising primary alcohols, and upon further oxidation they become carboxylic acids.
- Aldehydes are easily oxidised, so they show reducing properties.
(i) Silver mirror test
- When an aldehyde is added to an aqueous solution of ammoniacal silver nitrate and heated, silver ions Ag+ are reduced and metallic silver precipitates.
(ii) Reduction of Fehling’s solution
- Fehling’s solution contains Cu2+.
- When an aldehyde is added to Fehling’s solution and heated, copper(II) ions Cu2+ are reduced, producing a red precipitate of copper(I) oxide Cu2O.
Structure of science
Key fact→Although aldehydes and ketones both contain a carbonyl group C=O, the position of this group determines their chemical behavior.
Key concepts→aldehydes, Fehling’s solution, ketones, iodoform reaction.
(i) Formaldehyde HCHO
- It is a colourless, toxic gas with a pungent odour.
- It is highly soluble in water.
- It is obtained by oxidising methanol in the air.
- An aqueous solution containing about 37% formaldehyde is called formalin, and it is used as a preservative solution for animal specimens and similar materials.
- It is a colourless, toxic liquid with a pungent odour.
- It is obtained by oxidising ethanol with an aqueous solution of potassium dichromate acidified with sulfuric acid.
- Structure in formaldehyde the carbonyl carbon carries two hydrogen atoms; in acetaldehyde it carries one hydrogen atom and one CH3 group.
Ketones→, Ketones are compounds in which two hydrocarbon groups are bonded to a carbonyl group; their general formula is R1–CO–R2.
- Ketones are obtained by oxidising secondary alcohols.
- They are not easily oxidised and do not show reducing properties.
- Aldehydes exist that are structural isomers of ketones.
- It is a colourless liquid with a pleasant odour.
- It is miscible with water in any proportion.
- In the laboratory it is obtained by the oxidation of 2-propanol or by the thermal decomposition of calcium acetate.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Iodoform reaction | , The iodoform reaction occurs when an organic compound with a specific structural unit is heated with iodine I2 in an alkaline aqueous solution, producing a yellow precipitate of iodoform CHI3 with a characteristic odour. | occursorganiccompoundspecific |
| Note on the book | - the English page says “characteristic color” while the Arabic page says “characteristic odour”
- the precipitate is yellow and iodoform has a distinctive odour
| Englishpagesayscharacteristic |
Structural requirements
- The reaction is given by compounds whose molecules contain one of the following structural units (where R is a hydrogen atom or a hydrocarbon group):
- Compounds with the structure CH3–CO–R (for example acetaldehyde, acetone).
- Compounds with the structure CH3–CH(OH)–R (for example ethanol, 2-propanol).
- Compounds with structure (ii) are oxidised by iodine during the reaction and converted into structure (i).
- Consequently, they also give the iodoform reaction.
Think as an Engineer
- Quality-control engineers in a pharmaceutical company must verify whether an alcohol has been completely oxidised during production.
- Which laboratory test would you recommend: the silver mirror test, Fehling’s test or the iodoform test?
- Justify your recommendation using chemical evidence.
- Answer (worked out) The silver mirror test (or Fehling’s test). Oxidation of a primary alcohol passes through an aldehyde before reaching the carboxylic acid, and only the aldehyde reduces Ag+ or Cu2+. A negative result shows that no aldehyde remains, so the oxidation has gone all the way to the acid. The iodoform test is not suitable, because ethanol and acetaldehyde both give a positive result, so it cannot show whether the alcohol has been oxidised.
Note on the book→these tests detect the aldehyde, not the alcohol itself, so they show the end of the oxidation indirectly.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Claim | - Aldehydes are reducing agents
- while ketones are not
| Aldehydesreducingagentswhile |
| Evidence | Use results from both laboratory tests | resultsbothlaboratorytests |
| Reasoning | Explain how oxidation state and molecular structure account for the observed differences | Explainoxidationstatemolecular |
| • | Answer (worked out) | Answerworked |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Example | Keywords |
|---|
| Evidence | - an aldehyde gives a silver mirror with ammoniacal silver nitrate and a red precipitate of Cu2O with Fehling’s solution
- a ketone
| propanone gives no change in either test | aldehydegivessilvermirror |
| Reasoning | - the carbonyl carbon of an aldehyde carries a hydrogen atom
- so it can easily be oxidised further to a carboxylic acid (a higher oxidation state)
- and in doing so it reduces Ag+ and Cu2+. The carbonyl carbon of a ketone is bonded to two hydrocarbon groups and has no hydrogen atom to lose
- so it is not easily oxidised and shows no reducing property
| — | carbonylcarbonaldehydecarries |
Warm Up
(a)→Answer the questions about the experimental procedures and results (I to III) regarding methanol.
- About 7 mL of methanol is put into a test tube and warmed in a water bath.
- A copper wire heated until it became copper(II) oxide is brought close to the liquid surface of the methanol; the blackened part of the copper wire turns red.
- To confirm the product of Experiment II, an ammoniacal silver nitrate aqueous solution is added, and the inner wall of the test tube is covered with a silvery-white substance.
- (i) In Experiment II, what did copper(II) oxide change into?
- (ii) In Experiment II, what did methanol change into? Name the substance and write its structural formula.
- (iii) What characteristic of organic compounds can the operation of Experiment III detect?
- (b) Answer the questions about the compounds with the molecular formula C3H8O.
- (i) Among these compounds, name the substance that becomes an aldehyde upon gentle oxidation and a carboxylic acid upon further oxidation.
- (ii) Write the structural formulas of the aldehyde and the carboxylic acid produced in (i).
- (iii) Among these compounds, name the substance that becomes a ketone upon oxidation.
- (iv) Does the compound in (iii) show the iodoform test?
- (i) Since copper(II) oxide changed to red, it changed to copper. Answer: copper.
- (ii) From (i), copper(II) oxide was reduced to copper, so methanol was oxidised. Oxidising methanol gives formaldehyde. Name: formaldehyde (methanal); structural formula: H–CHO (a carbonyl carbon bonded to two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom, H2C=O).
- (iii) The reaction of Experiment III is the silver mirror test, in which Ag+ in the solution is reduced and silver precipitates. It is caused by the reducing property of aldehydes, and organic compounds having a formyl group are called aldehydes. Thus the silver mirror test detects organic compounds containing a formyl group (an aldehyde group).
(b)
- (i) A primary alcohol becomes a carboxylic acid through an aldehyde on gentle oxidation. In a primary alcohol the hydroxyl group is bonded to the terminal carbon atom, CH3CH2CH2OH. The substance is 1-propanol.
- (ii) Aldehyde CH3CH2CHO (propanal). Carboxylic acid: CH3CH2COOH (propanoic acid).
- (iii) A secondary alcohol becomes a ketone upon oxidation. In a secondary alcohol the hydroxyl group is bonded to the central carbon atom, CH3CH(OH)CH3. The substance is 2-propanol.
- (iv) Yes, it shows the reaction (it has the unit CH3–CH(OH)–).
- Students analyse the following results.
| Compound |
Silver mirror |
Fehling’s |
Oxidation product |
| Methanal |
Yes |
Yes |
Methanoic acid |
| Ethanal |
Yes |
Yes |
Ethanoic acid |
| Propanone |
No |
No |
No reaction |
- Questions Which compounds are aldehydes? Which compound is a ketone? Which compound is easiest to oxidise? Explain the pattern.
- Answers (worked out):
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Aldehydes | methanal and ethanal (both give a positive silver mirror and Fehling’s result) | methanalethanalbothgive |
| Ketone | propanone | propanone |
| Easiest to oxidise | - the aldehydes
- methanal and ethanal
- both oxidise easily to acids
- methanal
- whose carbonyl carbon carries two hydrogen atoms and no alkyl group
- is generally taken as the most easily oxidised. Propanone is not oxidised
| aldehydesmethanalethanalboth |
| Pattern | - compounds with the formyl group give positive tests and are oxidised to carboxylic acids
- the ketone
- with no hydrogen on the carbonyl carbon
- gives no reaction
| compoundsformylgroupgive |
| Note on the book | - the table does not show the rate of oxidation
- so it cannot by itself separate methanal from ethanal
- the ranking above rests on general chemistry
| tabledoesshowrate |
1.→About 5.0 mL of methanol is placed in a test tube and warmed in water at 50°C. After warming, a spiral copper wire heated in the air with a gas burner is brought close to the liquid surface of the methanol while it is hot, as shown in the figure, and this operation is repeated 5 to 6 times. Answer the questions.
- (a) What did methanol change into? Write the condensed structural formula and name the product.
- (b) To confirm the product of (a), an ammoniacal silver nitrate aqueous solution was added. What change occurred? Name the test.
- (c) An approximately 37% aqueous solution of the substance produced is used for preserving biological specimens. What is this solution called?
- Answers (worked out):
- (a) HCHO, formaldehyde (methanal).
- (b) A silver mirror formed on the inner wall of the test tube (silver ions were reduced to silver); this is the silver mirror test.
- (c) Formalin.
- 2. (a) Fill in the blanks. Aldehydes are compounds having a (i) group –CHO, and (ii) are compounds having a carbonyl group. As an experiment to confirm the properties of an aldehyde, an ammoniacal silver nitrate aqueous solution is added to an aldehyde and heated; this is called the (iii) test. One representative aldehyde is (iv), which is obtained by oxidising ethanol with potassium dichromate acidified with sulfuric acid. Ketones have representative substances such as acetone. When iodine is added to a basic aqueous solution of acetone and allowed to react, a yellow precipitate with a characteristic odour is produced. This reaction is called the (v) test.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| • | - (b) Write A if the description applies to acetaldehyde and B if it applies to acetone: I produced by the oxidation of a primary alcohol
- II produced by the oxidation of a secondary alcohol
- III becomes a carboxylic acid when oxidised
- IV has reducing properties
| Writedescriptionappliesacetaldehyde |
| Answers (worked out) | - (a) (i) formyl (aldehyde)
- (ii) ketones
- (iii) silver mirror
- (iv) acetaldehyde
- (v) iodoform. (b) I = A
- II = B
- III = A
- IV = A
| formylaldehydeketonessilver |
| 3. | Compounds A, B and C have the molecular formula C3H8O. A and B react with sodium to generate a gas, but C does not. On gentle oxidation, D is obtained from A and E from B. When ammoniacal silver nitrate is added to D and E, only E gives a positive test. (a) Write the structural formulas of A to E. (b) Which of A to E give a yellow precipitate with iodine and aqueous sodium hydroxide? (c) Which give a red precipitate with heated Fehling’s solution? | CompoundsmolecularformulaC3H8O |
Answers (worked out)→A and B are alcohols (they release hydrogen with sodium); C is an ether. Only E reduces silver ions, so E is an aldehyde and comes from a primary alcohol: B = 1-propanol, E = propanal. A is therefore 2-propanol and D = acetone. (a) A: CH3CH(OH)CH3; B: CH3CH2CH2OH; C: CH3OCH2CH3 (ethyl methyl ether); D: CH3COCH3; E: CH3CH2CHO. (b) A and D. (c) E.
- Formaldehyde is useful for preserving biological materials, but prolonged exposure may affect human health.
- Scientists and governments regulate its use in schools, hospitals and workplaces.
Choose the correct answer
- A chemist wants to distinguish an aldehyde from a ketone using a simple laboratory test. Which reagent should be used? A. Bromine water; B. Ammoniacal silver nitrate solution; C. Dilute hydrochloric acid; D. Sodium chloride solution.
- A primary alcohol is gently oxidised. What is the first organic product formed? A. Ketone; B. Alkene; C. Aldehyde; D. Carboxylic acid.
Answers (worked out)→1 = B (only the aldehyde gives a silver mirror); 2 = C.
Answer the following questions
3.→After strongly heating a copper wire with a gas burner, it was immediately brought close to the liquid surface of methanol in a test tube, and the copper wire returned to its original colour. By repeating this operation, compound A with a pungent odour was produced. A has ((i) oxidising property / reducing property), and when an aqueous solution containing A is added to Fehling’s solution and heated, a ((ii) red / yellow) precipitate of (iii) (Cu2O / CHI3) is formed. Also, when added to an ammoniacal silver nitrate solution and warmed, the (iv) test is observed. (a) Choose the words or formulas for (i) to (iii). (b) Give the word for (iv). (c) Why did the copper wire return to its original colour? Use all of: reduction, copper(II) oxide, copper, methanol.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Answers (worked out) | A is formaldehyde. (a) (i) reducing property; (ii) red; (iii) Cu2O. (b) silver mirror. (c) The heated copper wire is covered with black copper(II) oxide. When it touches the methanol, copper(II) oxide undergoes reduction to copper while methanol is oxidised to formaldehyde, so the wire returns to the reddish colour of copper. | formaldehydereducingpropertyCu2O |
| 4. | - (a) Fill in the blanks. When a primary alcohol is oxidised with an oxidising agent
- it first changes to a (i)
- and upon further oxidation produces a (ii). When a secondary alcohol is oxidised
- it changes to a (iii). For example
- oxidising 2-propanol gives (iv)
- which is a kind of (iii). (b) For formaldehyde and acetone
- write A if a property applies only to formaldehyde
- B if only to acetone
- and C if to both: (i) has the structure –CO–
- (ii) reduces Fehling’s solution
- (iii) shows the iodoform test
- (iv) becomes a carboxylic acid when oxidised
- (v) becomes a secondary alcohol when reduced
| Fillblanksprimaryalcohol |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Answers (worked out) | - (a) (i) aldehyde
- (ii) carboxylic acid
- (iii) ketone
- (iv) acetone. (b) (i) C (both contain the carbonyl group)
- (ii) A
- (iii) B
- (iv) A
- (v) B (reducing formaldehyde gives a primary alcohol
- methanol)
| aldehydecarboxylicacidketone |
| Note on the book | - in (i)
- “–CO–” strictly means a carbonyl carbon joined to two carbon groups
- which only acetone has
- the answer C reads it as the carbonyl group
- which both compounds contain
| strictlymeanscarbonylcarbon |
| 5. | Compounds A to C have the molecular formula C3H8O. A and B are alcohols, and C is an isomer of A and B. D is obtained by the oxidation of A, or by the thermal decomposition of calcium acetate without air. E shows a reducing property and is obtained by the oxidation of B, and when E is further oxidised it becomes F, a weak acid. (a) Name A, B and D. (b) Write the structural formulas of C and E. (c) Among A to F, how many show the iodoform test? | CompoundsmolecularformulaC3H8O |
Answers (worked out)→D is acetone, so A is 2-propanol; B is 1-propanol; E is propanal and F is propanoic acid; C is ethyl methyl ether. (a) A = 2-propanol, B = 1-propanol, D = acetone (propanone). (b) C: CH3OCH2CH3; E: CH3CH2CHO. (c) Two: A (2-propanol) and D (acetone).
- A chemist performs the following tests on an unknown compound: Tollens’ test positive, Fehling’s test positive, iodoform test negative.
- Predict which functional group is present, suggest one possible compound, and explain your reasoning using the evidence.
- Answer (worked out) The functional group is the formyl (aldehyde) group –CHO. Positive Tollens’ and Fehling’s tests show a reducing compound, which is an aldehyde. The negative iodoform test shows there is no CH3–CO– or CH3–CH(OH)– unit, so the compound is not acetaldehyde. A possible compound is propanal CH3CH2CHO (formaldehyde would also fit).