- Imagine you leave a bicycle outside for several weeks.
- The shiny metal slowly turns reddish-brown as rust forms.
- In a laboratory, a technician adds a few drops of different solutions to an unknown sample, and within seconds the colour changes, showing which metal ion is present.
- Iron, copper and silver are all metals, but each behaves differently because of its electron arrangement, its oxidation states and the properties of its compounds.
- In this lesson you explore how chemists use colour changes, precipitates and complex ions to identify transition metal ions, and why these metals matter in engineering, medicine and environmental science.
Guiding question→Why do different transition metal ions produce different colours and reactions?
Exploration
- Look at these everyday observations.
- An old iron gate develops reddish-brown rust.
- Copper roofs slowly become green after many years.
- Old silver jewellery sometimes becomes black.
- Before studying the lesson, discuss:
- Why do different metals change into different colours?
- Why does not every metal rust in the same way?
- How could a chemist identify these metals if they were dissolved in water?
- Many transition elements have more than one oxidation state.
- Many transition metal ions and their compounds are coloured.
- Transition metals can often be identified because they form distinctive coloured ions, precipitates and complex ions during chemical reactions. The colours of precipitates and complex solutions help in the qualitative detection of ions.
- A change in oxidation state, or in the ligands around the ion, can change the colour.
- Transition elements
- Oxidation states
- Oxidation and reduction
- Coordination bonding
- Complex ions
- Precipitation
- Qualitative analysis
(a) Iron ions
- Iron forms the iron(II) ion Fe2+ and the iron(III) ion Fe3+. When Fe2+ is oxidised, it becomes Fe3+.
(b) Reactions of iron ions in aqueous solutions
- Fe2+ and Fe3+ react differently with the added aqueous solutions. The colour changes are:
| Aqueous solution added |
NaOH or NH3 |
H2S |
K4[Fe(CN)6] |
K3[Fe(CN)6] |
KSCN |
| Solution containing Fe2+ |
Greenish-white precipitate |
Black precipitate |
Bluish-white precipitate |
Dark blue precipitate |
No change |
| Solution containing Fe3+ |
Reddish-brown precipitate |
Black precipitate |
Dark blue precipitate |
Brown solution |
Blood-red solution |
- When aqueous sodium hydroxide NaOH or aqueous ammonia NH3 is added to a solution containing Fe2+, a precipitate of iron(II) hydroxide, Fe(OH)2, is produced:
Fe2+ + 2OH− → Fe(OH)2↓
- When the same reagents are added to a solution containing Fe3+, a precipitate of iron(III) hydroxide is produced.
- Iron(III) hydroxide cannot be represented by a single chemical formula.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Iron(II) hydroxide | , Iron(II) hydroxide, Fe(OH)2, is the greenish-white precipitate formed when hydroxide ions react with Fe2+ ions. | greenishwhiteprecipitateformed |
| Iron(III) hydroxide | , Iron(III) hydroxide is the reddish-brown precipitate formed when hydroxide ions react with Fe3+ ions; it cannot be written with a single chemical formula. | reddishbrownprecipitateformed |
- Without performing the experiment, predict what happens when a chemist adds sodium hydroxide solution separately to Fe2+, Fe3+, Cu2+ and Ag+ solutions.
- Complete the table.
| Metal ion |
Prediction (worked out from the reactions in this lesson) |
| Fe2+ |
Greenish-white precipitate of Fe(OH)2 |
| Fe3+ |
Reddish-brown precipitate of iron(III) hydroxide |
| Cu2+ |
Bluish-white precipitate of Cu(OH)2 |
| Ag+ |
Brown precipitate of Ag2O |
(a) Reactions of copper
- Heating copper in air produces black copper(II) oxide, CuO.
- Dissolving copper in hot concentrated sulfuric acid produces copper(II) sulfate, CuSO4.
- Adding an aqueous base produces a bluish-white precipitate of copper(II) hydroxide, Cu(OH)2.
- Passing hydrogen sulfide through the solution produces a black precipitate of copper(II) sulfide, CuS.
- Cu2+ + 2OH− → Cu(OH)2↓
Adding excess aqueous ammoniatetraamminecopper(II) ions, [Cu(NH3)4]2+, form, giving a deep blue aqueous solution.
HeatingCu(OH)2 decomposes to produce black copper(II) oxide, CuO.
Dissolving in dilute sulfuric acid or hydrochloric acidcopper(II) ions, Cu2+, form.
Cu(OH)2 + 4NH3 → [Cu(NH3)4]2+ + 2OH−
Tetraamminecopper(II) ion→, The tetraamminecopper(II) ion, [Cu(NH3)4]2+, is the deep blue complex ion formed when copper(II) hydroxide dissolves in excess aqueous ammonia.
- Engineers designing water distribution systems must choose pipe materials carefully.
- Copper pipes are commonly used because under certain conditions they resist corrosion better than iron.
- Question Why would copper be a better material than iron for drinking-water pipes? Consider:
corrosion and the rate of corrosion
durability and service life
- water quality, including the acidity of the drinking water and the chance of copper ions moving into the water
installation and maintenance costs
availability of alternatives
Answer (worked out, the book gives none)→Iron rusts in damp conditions, and the reddish-brown rust weakens the pipe and colours the water. Copper corrodes more slowly under typical drinking-water conditions, so copper pipes last longer, keep the water cleaner and need less maintenance, which lowers the long-term cost. The cost of installation and the possible release of copper ions into the water must still be weighed.
(a) Reactions of the silver ion, Ag+
- Adding an aqueous base solution a brown precipitate of silver oxide, Ag2O, forms.
- Further adding aqueous ammonia silver oxide dissolves and colourless diamminesilver(I) ions, [Ag(NH3)2]+, form.
- Passing hydrogen sulfide through a black precipitate of silver sulfide, Ag2S, forms.
- 2Ag+ + 2OH− → Ag2O↓ + H2O
- Ag2O + 4NH3 + H2O ⇌ 2[Ag(NH3)2]+ + 2OH−
- 2Ag+ + S2− → Ag2S↓
(b) Silver halides
- Silver halides , Silver halides are compounds of silver with the halogens (Cl, Br, I), formed by the reaction of silver ions with halide ions.
- When silver halides are exposed to light, they decompose to give silver metal. Example:
- 2AgBr → 2Ag + Br2 (in light)
Table 3-9-1→Colours of silver halides
| Name |
Chemical formula |
Colour |
| Silver chloride |
AgCl |
White |
| Silver bromide |
AgBr |
Light yellow (cream) |
| Silver iodide |
AgI |
Yellow |
- Silver compounds have been used for over a century in photography.
- Light-sensitive silver halides were used in photographic film: exposure to light forms a latent image, which then appears during chemical developing and fixing.
- When silver bromide is exposed to light, it decomposes to produce metallic silver.
- Although digital cameras have largely replaced photographic film, this light-sensitive reaction remains an important example of photochemistry and is still used in specialised imaging technologies.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| • | Answer the following questions | Answerfollowingquestions |
| (a) | - Identify the chemical formulas for (A)
- (B) and (C) in this passage: When dilute sulfuric acid is added to iron
- it dissolves while generating hydrogen
- producing a cation represented by (A). This ion is oxidised by hydrogen peroxide to become an ion represented by (B). The formation of (B) can be confirmed because the aqueous solution turns blood-red when an aqueous solution of (C) is added to it
| Identifychemicalformulaspassage |
| (b) | Answer these questions from the figure showing the reactions of copper and its compounds (Cu, Cu2+ and Cu(OH)2, with substances A, B and C and steps (i), (ii) and (iii); H2S and heating are marked). | Answerthesequestionsfigure |
- (I) Identify the chemical formulas of substances A, B and C. Note that C is a complex ion.
- (II) Select the most appropriate reagent or procedure for (i) to (iii) from the options below.
- Each option can be used only once: a.
- Heating, b.
- O2, c.
- H2, d.
- NH3, e.
- NaOH.
Explanation
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| (a) | A: Fe2+; B: Fe3+; C: KSCN. | KSCN |
| (b)(I) | A: When hydrogen sulfide is passed through an aqueous solution containing copper(II) ions, a precipitate of copper(II) sulfide is produced. Answer: CuS. B: Heating copper produces copper(II) oxide. Answer: CuO. C: The complex ion produced by the reaction of copper(II) hydroxide with ammonia is the tetraamminecopper(II) ion. Answer: [Cu(NH3)4]2+. | hydrogensulfidepassedthrough |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| (II) | (i): Heating copper(II) hydroxide produces copper(II) oxide. (ii): Adding an aqueous base solution to an aqueous solution containing copper(II) ions produces a precipitate of copper(II) hydroxide. (iii): Adding excess aqueous ammonia to copper(II) hydroxide produces tetraamminecopper(II) ions. Since aqueous ammonia NH3 corresponds to (iii), NaOH, the remaining aqueous base, corresponds to (ii). | Heatingcopperhydroxideproduces |
| From the above | | |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| • | - The book gives no answer key for these questions
- the answers below were worked out from the lesson
| bookgivesanswerthese |
| 1. | A pale green solution is suspected to contain Fe2+ ions. A student adds sodium hydroxide solution. Which observation is most likely? A. A greenish-white precipitate; B. A deep blue solution; C. A brown solution; D. No visible change. Answer: A. | palegreensolutionsuspected |
| 2. | A solution gives a blood-red colour after adding potassium thiocyanate (KSCN). Which ion is present? A. Fe2+; B. Fe3+; C. Cu2+; D. Ag+. Answer: B, Fe3+. | solutiongivesbloodcolour |
| 3. | Answer these questions from the diagram of the reactions of iron and its compounds. Fe reacts with dilute sulfuric acid to give Fe2+, which is oxidised to Fe3+. Fe2+ and Fe3+ each react with NH3 to give precipitates A and (B). Fe2+ reacts with reagent a to give a dark blue precipitate, Fe3+ reacts with reagent b to give a dark blue precipitate, and Fe3+ reacts with reagent c to give a blood-red solution. | Answerthesequestionsdiagram |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| (a) Formula and colour of A | | greenishwhite |
| (b) Colour of B | reddish-brown (iron(III) hydroxide) | reddishbrownironhydroxide |
| • | (c) Reagents (choose from (i) KCl, (ii) KSCN, (iii) NaOH, (iv) K3[Fe(CN)6], (v) K4[Fe(CN)6]): a = (iv) K3[Fe(CN)6]; b = (v) K4[Fe(CN)6]; c = (ii) KSCN. | ReagentschooseKSCNNaOH |
| 4. | Answer these questions from the diagram in which Cu reacts with O2 on heating to give (A), Cu2+ reacts with H2S to give (B) and with NaOH or a small amount of NH3 to give (C), and (C) reacts with excess NH3 to give solution (D). | Answerthesequestionsdiagram |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| (a) Formulas of A to C | - A is CuO
- B is CuS
- C is Cu(OH)2
| |
| • | (b) The complex ion in solution (D) is the tetraamminecopper(II) ion, [Cu(NH3)4]2+. | complexsolutiontetraamminecopper |
| 5. | - Identify the chemical formulas and colours of substances A
- B and C. Experiment I: aqueous sodium chloride was added to aqueous silver nitrate and precipitate A was produced. Experiment II: when precipitate A was exposed to light
- it decomposed to give fine particles of B. Experiment III: when excess aqueous ammonia was added to precipitate A
- complex ion C was produced
| Identifychemicalformulascolours |
- A: AgCl, white precipitate.
- B: Ag, silver metal as fine particles (dark grey to black).
- C: [Ag(NH3)2]+, colourless.
- The book gives no answer key for these questions; the answers below were worked out from the lesson, following the arrows of each diagram.
- 1. Diagram of the reactions of iron and its compounds: Fe2+ reacts with NaOH or NH3 to give precipitate A, and Fe3+ reacts with NaOH or NH3 to give precipitate B. Fe2+ gives a dark blue precipitate with reagent C, Fe3+ gives a dark blue precipitate with reagent D and a blood-red solution with reagent E, and Fe2+ is oxidised to Fe3+.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| (a) Precipitate A | | greenishwhite |
| (b) Precipitate B | - iron(III) hydroxide
- reddish-brown
| ironhydroxidereddishbrown |
| (c) Options | - (i) KSCN
- (ii) K4[Fe(CN)6]
- (iii) KCl
- (iv) K3[Fe(CN)6]. C = (iv) K3[Fe(CN)6]
- D = (ii) K4[Fe(CN)6]
- E = (i) KSCN
| KSCN |
| 2. | Diagram of the reactions of copper: Cu gives Cu2+ (step a) and CuO on heating; Cu2+ gives A with H2S and B with NaOH; B gives C with excess NH3; CuO gives Cu (step b); B gives CuO (step c). | Diagramreactionscoppergives |
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| (a) A | - CuS
- B: Cu(OH)2
- C: [Cu(NH3)4]2+
| |
| (b) Options | - (i) H2
- (ii) O2
- (iii) HCl
- (iv) HNO3
- (v) heating. a = (iv) HNO3 (Cu to Cu2+)
- b = (i) H2 (CuO to Cu)
- c = (v) heating (Cu(OH)2 to CuO)
| HNO3heating |
| 3. | - Aqueous sodium hydroxide
- dilute hydrochloric acid
- aqueous potassium bromide and aqueous hydrogen sulfide were added to aqueous silver nitrate
- giving precipitates A
- C and D respectively. Identify the chemical formulas and colours
| Aqueoussodiumhydroxidedilute |
| Precipitate |
Formula |
Colour |
| A |
Ag2O |
Brown |
| B |
AgCl |
White |
| C |
AgBr |
Light yellow (cream) |
| D |
Ag2S |
Black |
- A forensic scientist finds a colourless solution that may contain chloride ions.
- After adding silver nitrate, a white precipitate appears.
- Later, the precipitate darkens after being exposed to sunlight.
- Which silver compound was probably formed? Silver chloride, AgCl.
- Why did its colour change after exposure to light? Light decomposes silver chloride, and fine particles of silver metal form, which are dark.
- What property of silver halides makes them useful in photography? They are sensitive to light: exposure decomposes them to silver metal and so forms an image.
- Answers worked out; the book gives none.