- Imagine you are a forensic chemist investigating a suspicious liquid recovered from a laboratory.
- Analysis shows that it contains four different aromatic compounds mixed together.
- Before identifying each compound, you must first separate them without changing their chemical structures.
- In this lesson we explore how chemists use differences in solubility and acid–base properties to separate aromatic compounds efficiently and accurately.
- Guiding question How can chemists separate compounds that look similar but have different chemical properties?
- A mixture contains aniline, phenol, salicylic acid and nitrobenzene.
- Without using chromatography or distillation, answer the following and write your predictions before studying the separation procedure.
- Which compound would dissolve in dilute hydrochloric acid? (Worked out: aniline, a weak base, forms a water-soluble salt.)
- Which would react with sodium hydrogen carbonate? (Worked out: salicylic acid, a carboxylic acid stronger than carbonic acid. Phenol does not.)
- Which would remain unchanged? (Worked out: nitrobenzene, a neutral compound.)
(a) Separation experiment
- Compounds can be separated with a separating funnel by dividing the liquid into an aqueous layer and a layer of an organic solvent such as diethyl ether (the ether layer) (Figure 4-15-1).
- Substances that are highly soluble in water move to the aqueous layer.
- Substances that are highly soluble in organic solvents move to the ether layer.
- Separating funnel , A separating funnel is a piece of glassware used for liquid–liquid extraction, in which two immiscible layers, the aqueous layer and the ether layer, are separated from each other.
(b) Properties of aromatic compounds
- Between water and organic solvents
- aromatic compounds are highly soluble in organic solvents.
(c) Separation by neutralisation reaction
- When aromatic compounds become salts through a neutralisation reaction
- they become highly soluble in water.
- Acids react with a base to form a salt.
- Bases react with an acid to form a salt.
- Neutral substances do not react with either acids or bases.
- Aromatic compounds generally dissolve better in organic solvents than in water.
- Acid–base reactions can convert neutral molecules into water-soluble salts.
- Separating funnels allow efficient liquid–liquid extraction.
- Key concepts organic solvents, hydrochloric acid, neutral substances.
- Research question How does changing the pH affect the solubility of aromatic compounds?
- Investigate:
- Which compounds become salts? (Worked out: aniline with hydrochloric acid; salicylic acid with sodium hydrogen carbonate; phenol with sodium hydroxide.)
- Which remain neutral? (Worked out: nitrobenzene.)
- Which layer (aqueous or ether) does each compound occupy after each treatment? (Worked out: see the table below.)
| Treatment |
Aqueous layer |
Ether layer |
| Dilute HCl |
Aniline hydrochloride |
Salicylic acid, phenol, nitrobenzene |
| NaHCO3 |
Sodium salicylate |
Phenol, nitrobenzene |
| NaOH |
Sodium phenoxide |
Nitrobenzene |
- Construct a separation flowchart based on your observations. (Worked out: mixture in ether → add dilute HCl → aniline hydrochloride in the aqueous layer; ether layer → add NaHCO3 → sodium salicylate in the aqueous layer; ether layer → add NaOH → sodium phenoxide in the aqueous layer; nitrobenzene remains in the ether layer.)
(d) Liberation of weak acids and weak bases
- A salt of a weak acid reacts with an acid stronger than it to liberate the weak acid.
- A salt of a weak base reacts with a base stronger than it to liberate the weak base.
- Liberation of a weak acid , Liberation of a weak acid is the reaction of a salt of a weak acid with an acid stronger than it, which releases the weak acid.
- Liberation of a weak base , Liberation of a weak base is the reaction of a salt of a weak base with a base stronger than it, which releases the weak base.
Acid strength
- Hydrochloric acid
- sulfuric acid > sulfonic acids > carboxylic acids > carbonic acid > phenols
Base strength
- Aqueous sodium hydroxide solution > aniline
- A pharmaceutical company must separate valuable organic compounds from industrial waste with minimal environmental impact.
- Design a separation process that:
minimizes solvent use,
allows solvent recycling,
reduces chemical waste,
- maximizes product recovery.
- How would your design improve industrial sustainability?
- (Worked out, open answer extract with a small volume of solvent in several portions, recover the solvent by evaporation and condensation and reuse it, neutralise and recycle the acidic and basic aqueous layers, and liberate each product from its salt so that little is lost. Less solvent, less waste and more product recovered make the process cheaper and more sustainable.)
- The figure shows the procedure for separating each compound from an ether solution containing a mixture of aniline, salicylic acid, nitrobenzene and phenol.
- Answer the following questions.
- Procedure the ether solution of the mixture → (i) add dilute hydrochloric acid → aqueous layer I and ether layer I; ether layer I → (ii) add aqueous NaHCO3 solution → aqueous layer II and ether layer II; ether layer II → (iii) add aqueous NaOH solution → aqueous layer III and ether layer III.
- Write the structural formulas of the aromatic compounds contained in aqueous layers I to III.
- Briefly describe the change that occurs when an aqueous sodium hydroxide solution is added to aqueous layer I.
Explanation
- (a) Since all four substances are aromatic compounds, they are dissolved in the ether solution.
- Their properties are: aniline is weakly basic, salicylic acid is weakly acidic, nitrobenzene is neutral, and phenol is weakly acidic.
- Verify the reactions in order.
- Aqueous layer I The dilute hydrochloric acid added in (i) is strongly acidic, so the basic aniline is neutralised to form a salt, which dissolves in water and moves to the aqueous layer. Aqueous layer I therefore contains aniline hydrochloride, C6H5NH3Cl (the ring carries NH3Cl).
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Aqueous layer II | The NaHCO3 added in (ii) is a salt of carbonic acid, so it reacts with stronger acids. Of salicylic acid and phenol, the acid stronger than carbonic acid is salicylic acid, an aromatic carboxylic acid, so salicylic acid becomes a salt and moves to the aqueous layer. Aqueous layer II therefore contains sodium salicylate, HOC6H4COONa (the ring carries OH and COONa). | NaHCO3addedsaltcarbonic |
| Aqueous layer III | The aqueous NaOH solution added in (iii) is strongly basic, so it neutralises the acidic phenol, from the nitrobenzene and phenol remaining in the ether layer, to produce a salt. Aqueous layer III therefore contains sodium phenoxide, C6H5ONa (the ring carries ONa). | NaOHsolutionaddedstrongly |
- (b) When sodium hydroxide, a strong base, is added to aniline hydrochloride, a salt of a weak base, aniline is liberated: C6H5NH3Cl + NaOH → C6H5NH2 + NaCl + H2O.
- This is the liberation of a weak base.
| Step |
Reagent added |
Compound removed |
| I |
Dilute HCl |
Aniline |
| II |
NaHCO3 |
Salicylic acid |
| III |
NaOH |
Phenol |
| Remaining |
Ether layer |
Nitrobenzene |
- Questions with answers worked out:
- Why is hydrochloric acid added first? Aniline is the only basic compound in the mixture. The acid turns it into a water-soluble salt, while the acidic and neutral compounds do not react and stay in the ether layer.
- Why doesn’t sodium hydrogen carbonate remove phenol? Phenol is a weaker acid than carbonic acid, so it cannot liberate carbonic acid from its salt and does not form a salt with NaHCO3.
- Why is nitrobenzene left in the ether layer? It is neutral and does not react with acids or bases, so it forms no salt and stays dissolved in the organic solvent.
- Predict what would happen if NaOH were added first. Both salicylic acid and phenol would form sodium salts and move together into the aqueous layer, so they could not be separated from each other.
- Read the following text and answer the questions below.
- 1. Consider a diethyl ether solution containing dissolved phenol, aniline, salicylic acid and nitrobenzene.
| Comparison aspect | Main idea | Keywords |
|---|
| Operation I | Add 5% aqueous sodium hydrogen carbonate solution and shake well to obtain aqueous layer I and ether layer I | aqueoussodiumhydrogencarbonate |
| Operation II | - After separating aqueous layer I and ether layer I
- add 2 mol/L aqueous sodium hydroxide solution to ether layer I and shake well to obtain aqueous layer II and ether layer II
| Afterseparatingaqueouslayer |
| Operation III | - After separating aqueous layer II and ether layer II
- add A to ether layer II and shake well to obtain aqueous layer III and ether layer III
| Afterseparatingaqueouslayer |
| • | (a) Choose one suitable reagent for A from options a to d | Choosesuitablereagentoptions |
a. 10% aqueous sodium chloride solution
b. 2 mol/L hydrochloric acid
- c. 2 mol/L aqueous sodium hydrogen carbonate solution
d. 0.1 mol/L aqueous sodium hydroxide solution
- Answer (worked out) b. Ether layer II holds aniline and nitrobenzene. Only aniline is basic, so hydrochloric acid moves it into aqueous layer III as aniline hydrochloride.
- (b) Write the structural formulas of the organic compound salts dissolved in aqueous layers I to III.
- Answer (worked out) aqueous layer I, sodium salicylate HOC6H4COONa; aqueous layer II, sodium phenoxide C6H5ONa; aqueous layer III, aniline hydrochloride C6H5NH3Cl.
- (c) Fill in the blanks (i) to (iv) with the appropriate structural formulas.
- When enough dilute hydrochloric acid was added to aqueous layer I, a white solid (i) precipitated.
- When enough carbon dioxide was passed through aqueous layer II, (ii) was obtained.
- When enough aqueous sodium hydroxide solution was added to aqueous layer III, (iii) was obtained.
- When ether layer III was evaporated, an oily liquid, (iv), remained.
- Answer (worked out) (i) salicylic acid HOC6H4COOH; (ii) phenol C6H5OH (carbonic acid is stronger than phenol, so it liberates phenol from sodium phenoxide); (iii) aniline C6H5NH2; (iv) nitrobenzene C6H5NO2.
Choose the correct answer
- 1. Which compound remains in the ether layer after sodium hydrogen carbonate is added?
(a) Salicylic acid
(b) Aniline hydrochloride
(c) Nitrobenzene
(d) Sodium salicylate
- Answer (worked out) (c) nitrobenzene. It is neutral and forms no salt.
- 2. Why is sodium hydroxide added after sodium hydrogen carbonate?
- (a) It is a stronger oxidizing agent.
- (b) It converts phenol into a soluble salt.
- (c) It evaporates the solvent.
- (d) It neutralizes nitrobenzene.
- Answer (worked out) (b). Phenol does not react with NaHCO3 but forms soluble sodium phenoxide with NaOH.
Answer the following questions
- Consider a solution containing aniline, phenol and salicylic acid dissolved in diethyl ether.
- Each component of this mixed solution was separated by the operations shown in the figure: add aqueous NaOH solution and shake, giving an aqueous layer and an ether layer; evaporate the ether of the ether layer; make the aqueous layer acidic with hydrochloric acid and collect the produced solid; after neutralising with hydrochloric acid, add aqueous NaHCO3 solution and ether, shake, and evaporate the ether.
- The products are labelled a, b and c.
- (a) Write the structural formulas for the compounds a to c in the figure.
- (b) Choose the reagent that reacts with only one of the compounds a to c from options A to D, and select the appropriate letter.
A. Fehling’s solution
B. Bleaching powder
C. Aqueous iron(III) chloride solution
D. Iodine and aqueous sodium hydroxide solution
- (c) If toluene was also contained in the initial mixed solution, where among a to c in the figure would toluene be separated?
- Select the appropriate letter.
- Answers (worked out; the letters a, b, c could not be matched to the figure from the text, so the compounds are given by the step that gives them): the three compounds are aniline C6H5NH2, phenol C6H5OH and salicylic acid HOC6H4COOH.
- Aniline stays in the ether layer after NaOH and is left when that ether is evaporated.
- Phenol and salicylic acid both go into the aqueous layer as sodium salts.
- After acidifying and adding NaHCO3 and ether, phenol is in the ether and is left when it is evaporated, while salicylic acid is the solid collected from the aqueous layer after acidifying with hydrochloric acid. (b) B: bleaching powder gives a coloured reaction only with aniline, whereas iron(III) chloride reacts with both phenol and salicylic acid, and Fehling’s solution and the iodine and sodium hydroxide reagent react with none of them. (c) Toluene is neutral and stays in the first ether layer with aniline, so it is separated together with aniline, in the same ether fraction.
- Suppose the mixture also contained benzoic acid.
- Would the same separation sequence still work?
- If not, examples may include: what would change, which reagent should be added first, and why.
- (Worked out it would not work completely. Benzoic acid is a carboxylic acid stronger than carbonic acid, so, like salicylic acid, it would react with NaHCO3 and move to aqueous layer II together with sodium salicylate, and the two acids would not be separated. Adding dilute HCl first would still remove aniline, and the two carboxylic acids would be removed together by NaHCO3 before phenol is removed by NaOH. To separate the two acids from each other another method would be needed.)
- Many organic solvents used in extraction are hazardous to human health and the environment. Modern chemistry promotes:
greener solvents,
solvent recycling,
waste reduction,
- safer laboratory practices.
- Extraction techniques similar to those in this lesson are used to:
isolate caffeine from tea,
purify medicines,
remove pollutants from wastewater,
analyze forensic evidence,
produce fragrances,
- recover natural products from plants.