Curriculum
Course: Biology for AP Courses
Login

Curriculum

Biology for AP Courses

Text lesson

14.1 Historical Basis of Modern Understanding

14.1 Historical Basis of Modern Understanding — BIOLOGY FOR AP COURSES notes: You will be able to describe the classic experiments that showed DNA, not protein, carries heritable information, and use Chargaff’s base-pairing rules to find the base composition of a DNA sample.

Learning objectives
Learning objectives
This section answers three questions. What is transformation of DNA, and how do Griffith’s experiments from 1928 relate to our modern understanding of how DNA works? Which historic experiments identified DNA as the genetic material? What are Chargaff’s rules of nitrogenous base pairing?
1Connection for AP Courses2Connection for AP Courses3Connection for AP Courses
Connection for AP Courses
1

Today the letters DNA are linked with crime solving, paternity testing, human identification and genetic testing. All of these procedures are possible because of a discovery made in the middle of the twentieth century: DNA is the genetic material. Several classic experiments prepared the way for the large growth in our knowledge of how DNA stores and transmits genetic information.
2

DNA was first isolated from white blood cells by Friedrich Miescher in the 1860s.
3

1
4

More than fifty years later, Frederick Griffith’s work on transforming strains of the bacterium
5

Streptococcus pneumoniae
6

gave the first clue that DNA,
1 / 3Next ▶
Connection for AP Courses
Connection for AP Courses
and not protein as some scientists argued, is the universal molecule of heredity.
2
Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod and Maclyn McCarty later supported Griffith’s conclusions.
3
Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase, working with the bacteriophage T2

then showed decisively that DNA is the genetic material.
4
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Connection for AP Courses
Connection for AP Courses
Shortly afterward, Chargaff measured the ratios of adenine, thymine, cytosine and guanine in DNA.
5
He found paired relationships, with A = T and C = G, and found that the percentages of the four bases differ between species.
◀ Previous3 / 3
AP Biology framework links
1

This section supports learning objectives in Big Ideas 3 and 4 of the AP Biology Curriculum Framework. Each AP learning objective combines essential knowledge with one of the seven science practices. The table shows how the pieces fit together for this topic.
2

The Science Practice Challenge Questions for this section

which help prepare for the AP exam, are tied to the learning objective codes 3.2, 3.28, 1.11, 1.16, 3.1 and 4.1.
Framework item What it means for this topic
Big Idea 3 Living systems store, pass on and respond to the information that life processes depend on.
Enduring understanding 3.A Inherited information keeps life continuous from one generation to the next.
Essential knowledge 3.A.1 DNA, and in some cases RNA, is the main source of inherited information.
Science practice 6.5 Evaluate alternative scientific explanations.
Learning objective 3.1 Build scientific explanations that use the structure and mechanisms of DNA to support the claim that DNA carries heritable information.
Science practice 4.1 Justify the choice of data needed to answer a scientific question.
Learning objective 3.2 Justify the choice of historical data that supports the claim that DNA is the source of heritable information.
Big Idea 4 Biological systems interact, and these systems and their interactions have complex properties.
Enduring understanding 4.A Interactions within biological systems produce complex properties.
Essential knowledge 4.A.1 The parts of a biological molecule and the order in which they are arranged determine the properties of that molecule.
Science practice 7.1 Connect phenomena and models across spatial and temporal scales.
Learning objective 4.1 Explain how the sequence and building blocks of a biological polymer relate to its properties.
1Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids2Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids3Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids
Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids
Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids
Modern understanding of DNA evolved from the discovery of nucleic acids to the development of the double-helix model.
1 / 3Next ▶
Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids
Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids
In the 1860s, Friedrich Miescher, a physician by profession, was the first person to isolate phosphate-rich chemicals from white blood cells,
which are also called leukocytes.
He named these chemicals nuclein

because he had isolated them from the nuclei of the cells.
We now know that nuclein contained the two nucleic acids, RNA and DNA.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
A portrait of Friedrich Miescher, the physician who discovered nucleic acids in the nuclei of white blood cells. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Friedrich Miescher and the discovery of nucleic acids
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries2Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries3Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
The book’s link to learning points to a step-by-step review of Miescher’s experiments

which showed the key roles of DNA and proteins in the nucleus, and to a short profile of Phoebus Levene.
1 / 3Next ▶
Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
The main idea of Levene’s work is about how the parts of DNA are joined.
In a phosphodiester bond, one phosphate group bridges two sugars

so the nucleotides in a chain are held together in a backbone.
This discovery led to our current understanding of DNA’s structure.
Levene also held an incorrect view.
He believed that the four nucleotides in DNA repeated in the same fixed pattern.
Later work showed that the four nucleotides can be linked and repeated in a wide variety of arrangements.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
Link to Learning: Phoebus Levene discoveries
So the best answer to the book’s question about Levene is that he discovered the phosphodiester bonds that hold nucleotides together, even though his repeating-pattern idea was wrong.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Griffith transformation experiments2Griffith transformation experiments3Griffith transformation experiments4Griffith transformation experiments5Griffith transformation experiments6Griffith transformation experiments
Griffith transformation experiments
Griffith transformation experiments
Frederick Griffith, a British bacteriologist, was perhaps the first person to show that hereditary information can be transferred from one cell to another horizontally, rather than only by descent from parent to offspring.
1 / 6Next ▶
Griffith transformation experiments
Griffith transformation experiments
In 1928 he reported the first demonstration of bacterial transformation.
This is a process in which a cell takes up external DNA

which changes its morphology (appearance) and physiology (function).
He worked with
Streptococcus pneumoniae
, the bacterium that causes pneumonia.
Griffith worked with two strains.
◀ Previous2 / 6Next ▶
Griffith transformation experiments
1

1
2

The R strain is non-pathogenic

which means it does not cause disease.
3

2
4

It is called rough because it has a cell wall but no capsule

so its surface looks uneven under the microscope.
5

3
6

The S strain is pathogenic

which means it causes disease.
◀ Previous3 / 6Next ▶
Griffith transformation experiments
Griffith transformation experiments
4
It has a capsule outside its cell wall

so it looks smooth under the microscope.
Griffith ran three kinds of injection into mice.
Mice injected with the live R strain survived.
Mice injected with the heat-killed S strain also survived.
When he injected a mixture of live R strain and heat-killed S strain, the mice died.
◀ Previous4 / 6Next ▶
Griffith transformation experiments
Griffith transformation experiments
He then isolated live bacteria from the dead mice, and only the S strain was recovered.
5
When this recovered S strain was injected into fresh mice, those mice died too.
Griffith concluded that something had passed from the heat-killed S strain into the live R strain and transformed it into the pathogenic S strain. He called this the transforming principle. These experiments are now famously known as Griffith’s transformation experiments.
◀ Previous5 / 6Next ▶
Two mice from Griffith’s experiments: the mouse given heat-killed S strain lives, while the mouse given heat-killed S strain mixed with live R strain dies. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Griffith transformation experiments
◀ Previous6 / 6
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty identify the transforming principle
1

In 1944, Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod and Maclyn McCarty set out to explore the transforming principle further. They isolated the S strain from the dead mice and separated its proteins and nucleic acids, RNA and DNA. Each of these was a possible candidate for the molecule of heredity.
2

They used a systematic elimination study. Enzymes that break down one specific component were used to remove that component from each extract. Each mixture was then tested separately on the R strain. When DNA was destroyed, the remaining mixture could no longer transform the bacteria. Every other combination still transformed them. They concluded that DNA is the transforming principle.
Component destroyed before testing Did the mixture transform the R strain?
DNA No
RNA Yes
Proteins Yes
1Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis2Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis3Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis4Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis5Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis6Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
DNA evidence was used for the first time to solve an immigration case.
1 / 6Next ▶
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
1

A teenage boy was returning to London from Ghana to live with his mother.
2

Immigration officers at the airport suspected that he was travelling on a forged passport.
3

After much persuasion he was allowed to live with his mother,
4

but the authorities still began deportation proceedings against him,
5

and all types of evidence,
6

including photographs, were given to them.
◀ Previous2 / 6Next ▶
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
At about the same time, Dr. Alec Jeffreys of Leicester University in the United Kingdom had invented a technique known as DNA fingerprinting.
1
The immigration authorities asked him for help.
2
He took DNA samples from the mother, three of her children and an unrelated woman, and compared them with the boy’s DNA.
3
◀ Previous3 / 6Next ▶
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
The biological father was not available

so the DNA of the three children was compared with the boy’s DNA.
4
He found a match between the boy and both the mother and his three siblings, and concluded that the boy was indeed the mother’s son.
Forensic scientists analyze many kinds of evidence, including documents, handwriting, firearms and biological samples.
For DNA, they analyze hair, semen, saliva and blood, and compare the profiles with a database of DNA profiles of known criminals.
The analysis includes DNA isolation, sequencing and sequence analysis.
◀ Previous4 / 6Next ▶
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
1

Most forensic DNA work uses the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to copy short tandem repeat (STR) loci,
2

then electrophoresis to measure the length of each PCR-amplified fragment.
3

Mitochondrial DNA is also sequenced for forensic cases.
4

Forensic scientists must appear at court hearings to present their findings.
5

Most work in the crime labs of city and state government agencies.
6

Geneticists who work with DNA techniques also find jobs in research organizations, pharmaceutical companies, and college and university labs.
◀ Previous5 / 6Next ▶
Career connection: forensic scientists and DNA analysis
1

A student who wants to become a forensic scientist should have at least a bachelor’s degree in chemistry, biology or physics,
2

and preferably some laboratory experience.
◀ Previous6 / 6
1Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity2Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity3Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity
Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity
Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity
In this activity you build a model of a short piece of DNA. Work through the steps below, using a molecular modeling kit or a virtual kit such as Jmol.
1 / 3Next ▶
Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity
1

Build a model of each of the four nucleotides in DNA, using structural diagrams from this chapter or from reliable online sources.
2

Find where each nucleotide forms hydrogen bonds with its complementary base, and add these bonds to hold the two pairs together.
3

Adenine and thymine form two hydrogen bonds

while guanine and cytosine form three.
4

Consider how the bonding differs between the two pairs.
5

Look at a structural diagram of a complete DNA molecule.
6

Connect your two base pairs along the sugar-phosphate backbone.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity
Science practice connection: DNA necklace activity
You may first need to break the hydrogen bonds between the complementary bases.
Identify which atoms and molecules you must remove and add to build the backbone.
Each phosphodiester bond forms when a water molecule is released.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments2Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments3Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments4Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments5Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments6Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
The question asks why radioactive sulfur and phosphorus were used to label T2 bacteriophages.
1 / 6Next ▶
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
1

Sulfur is found in proteins but not in DNA

so labeling with radioactive sulfur (
2

35
3

S) tags the protein coat.
4

Phosphorus is found in DNA, in the phosphate groups of its backbone

but not in proteinso labeling with radioactive phosphorus (
5

32
6

P) tags the DNA.
◀ Previous2 / 6Next ▶
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
1

Because each label marked a different molecule, the team could tell which molecule had entered the bacteria.
2

Hershey and Chase carried out their experiments in 1952. They showed that DNA, not protein, is the genetic material.
3

1
4

A bacteriophage is a virus that infects bacteria.
5

2
6

Viruses typically have a simple structure: a protein coat, called the capsid, surrounding a nucleic acid core that contains the genetic material, either DNA or RNA.
◀ Previous3 / 6Next ▶
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
3
The bacteriophage attaches to the surface of a host bacterium and injects its nucleic acid inside.
4
The phage DNA then makes many copies of itself using the host’s machinery,
and eventually the host cell bursts, releasing a large number of new bacteriophages.
Hershey and Chase labeled one batch of phage with 35S and another batch with 32P.
◀ Previous4 / 6Next ▶
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
1

Each batch was allowed to infect bacterial cells separately.
2

The infected mixture was then put in a blender

which detached the phage coats from the host cells.
3

Next, the suspension was spun in a centrifuge.
4

The heavier bacterial cells settled into a pellet

while the lighter phage particles remained in the liquid above, called the supernatant.
5

In the tube with phage labeled with 35S, the radioactivity was in the supernatant, and none was found in the pellet.
6

This means the protein coat stayed outside the bacteria.
◀ Previous5 / 6Next ▶
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
Think About It: Hershey and Chase experiments
In the tube with phage labeled with
P, the radioactivity was found in the pellet.
This means the phage DNA entered the bacterial cells.
Since the DNA carried the information for making new phages, DNA is the genetic material.
◀ Previous6 / 6
1Chargaff base-pairing rules2Chargaff base-pairing rules3Chargaff base-pairing rules
Chargaff base-pairing rules
Chargaff base-pairing rules
Chargaff determined the amounts of adenine (A), thymine (T), cytosine (C) and guanine (G) in DNA. His results are summarized as Chargaff’s rules of nitrogenous base pairing:
1 / 3Next ▶
Chargaff base-pairing rules
1

The amount of adenine equals the amount of thymine

so A = T.
2

The amount of cytosine equals the amount of guanine

so C = G.
3

The percentages of A, T, C and G differ between species

so the base composition of DNA is characteristic of each species.
4

In these equations each symbol stands for the amount of one base as a percentage of the total bases in the sample.
5

The percentage is a dimensionless ratio

so it has no SI unit.
6

The rules describe a single DNA molecule of one species.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Chargaff base-pairing rules
1

Because A pairs with T and C pairs with G, the two strands of DNA are complementary.
2

Chargaff’s findings proved very useful to James Watson and Francis Crick as they prepared their model of the DNA double helix.
3

Once it was known that A always matched T and C always matched G, it was clear how two strands could fit together in a regular, stable structure, with each strand carrying the information needed to make the other.
4

Chargaff’s rules therefore linked the chemistry of DNA to the structure that later explained how DNA is copied.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Putting the evidence together2Putting the evidence together
Putting the evidence together
Putting the evidence together
Griffith showed that a heritable trait could be transferred between bacterial cells.
1
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty then showed that the transferred material was DNA.
2
Hershey and Chase confirmed, using a virus, that DNA rather than protein enters the cell and carries the genetic information.
3
1 / 2Next ▶
Putting the evidence together
1

Chargaff added the base-pairing patterns that later helped scientists understand how DNA is copied and stored.
2

4
3

Together, these experiments shaped our present understanding of DNA.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Example 1: Finding cytosine when adenine is given · Example 2: Finding adenine when cytosine is given
Example 1: Finding cytosine when adenine is given
Problem: a DNA sample is 30% adenine. What percentage of its bases is cytosine?
Step 1: Chargaff’s rule gives T = A

so T = 30%. Step 2: A + T = 60%so G + C = 100% − 60% = 40%. Step 3: C = Gso C = 40% ÷ 2 = 20%. Check: 30% + 30% + 20% + 20% = 100%. Answer: 20% cytosine.
Example 2: Finding adenine when cytosine is given
Problem: a DNA sample contains 18% cytosine. What percentage of its bases is adenine?
Step 1: G = C = 18%

so G + C = 36%. Step 2: A + T = 100% − 36% = 64%. Step 3: A = T = 64% ÷ 2 = 32%. Check: 32% + 32% + 18% + 18% = 100%. Answer: 32% adenine.
Key terms
Term Meaning
Transformation A process in which a cell takes up external DNA, which changes its morphology and physiology.
Transforming principle Griffith’s name for the substance that passed from heat-killed S strain cells and turned the R strain into the pathogenic S type.
Non-pathogenic Not able to cause disease. The R strain of S. pneumoniae is non-pathogenic.
Pathogenic Able to cause disease. The S strain of S. pneumoniae is pathogenic.
Capsule An outer layer lying outside the cell wall of the S strain, which gives it a smooth appearance.
Nuclein Miescher’s name for phosphate-rich chemicals isolated from cell nuclei, later known to be RNA and DNA.
Nucleic acid A class of molecules, DNA and RNA, that store and carry genetic information.
Phosphodiester bond The link in which one phosphate group joins two sugars, holding nucleotides together in a chain.
Bacteriophage A virus that infects bacteria.
Capsid The protein coat that surrounds the nucleic acid core of a virus.
Pellet The heavier material, here bacterial cells, that settles at the bottom of a centrifuge tube.
Supernatant The liquid above the pellet after centrifugation, which here contains the lighter phage particles.
Elimination study A method that removes one component at a time, using specific enzymes, to test which component is needed for an effect.
Chargaff’s rules The rules of nitrogenous base pairing: A = T, C = G, and base percentages differ between species.
Base pairing The specific pairing in which adenine pairs with thymine and cytosine pairs with guanine.
Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) A laboratory technique that makes many copies of a chosen piece of DNA.
Short tandem repeat (STR) A short DNA sequence repeated in a row, whose length varies between people and is used in forensic profiling.
Mitochondrial DNA DNA found in mitochondria, which is sequenced in forensic work.
DNA fingerprinting A technique, invented by Alec Jeffreys, for comparing DNA profiles to identify or link individuals.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes3Avoid these mistakes4Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Saying that Griffith proved DNA is the genetic materialGriffith showed that something could transform bacteria.
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty later identified that substance as DNA.Avoid this
2Avoid this
Mixing up the R and S strainsThe R strain is non-pathogenic, has no capsule and looks rough.
The S strain is pathogenic, has a capsule and looks smooth.Avoid this
1 / 4Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
3Avoid this
Thinking that heat-killed S strain alone killed the miceIt did not.
Only the mixture of heat-killed S strain and live R strain killed them, and the bacteria recovered from those mice were S type.Avoid this
4Avoid this
Reversing the Hershey and Chase labelsRadioactive sulfur (
35Avoid this
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
S) marks protein, and radioactive phosphorus (Avoid this
32Avoid this
P) marks DNA.Avoid this
5Avoid this
Confusing the pellet with the supernatantThe heavier bacterial cells form the pellet, and the lighter phage particles stay in the supernatant.
6Avoid this
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
Assuming that base percentages are the same in every speciesChargaff found that A = T and C = G within a DNA molecule,
but the overall percentages differ between species.Avoid this
◀ Previous4 / 4
Accepted payment methods