Curriculum
Course: Biology for AP Courses
Login

Curriculum

Biology for AP Courses

Text lesson

20.2 Determining Evolutionary Relationships

20.2 Determining Evolutionary Relationships — BIOLOGY FOR AP COURSES notes: You will be able to tell homologous traits from analogous traits, explain how each is used to infer evolutionary relatedness, describe how cladistics and cladograms are built, and apply the principle of maximum parsimony.

1Learning objectives2Learning objectives3Learning objectives
Learning objectives
Learning objectives
By the end of this section you should be able to answer three questions:
1 / 3Next ▶
Learning objectives
1

What is the difference between homologous and analogous traits, and how are these traits used to judge evolutionary relatedness?
2

What is cladistics, and how does a cladogram differ from a phylogenetic tree?
3

What is parsimony?
4

Before the main text, one idea from the opening paragraphs deserves attention.
5

Classification systems were built mainly by grouping organisms according to the traits they share on the surface.
6

Such groupings do not always reflect how groups are related through evolution.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Learning objectives
Learning objectives
A hippopotamus looks more like a pig than a whale, yet genetic studies suggest that the hippopotamus is the closest living relative of the whale.
Phylogenetic trees are therefore hypotheses.
They are revised whenever new data, especially genetic data, become available.
A link in the earlier section invited you to classify a bear, an orchid and a sea cucumber from kingdom to species using an online game. The lesson for this section is the same: a bear belongs to the kingdom Animalia because it is a multicellular organism that gets its energy by eating other organisms

while an orchid belongs to Plantae because it photosynthesizes.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Connection for AP courses2Connection for AP courses3Connection for AP courses4Connection for AP courses5Connection for AP courses6Connection for AP courses
Connection for AP courses
Connection for AP courses
1
A phylogenetic tree can only be built if scientists collect accurate information about the relationships among organisms.
They use two kinds of data: morphological data,
which describe the form and structure of organisms,
and molecular data,
which come from DNA and proteins.
1 / 6Next ▶
Connection for AP courses
1

From these data, scientists identify characteristics that are homologous and characteristics that are analogous (similar because they evolved separately).

(shared because of common ancestry)
2

Earlier, you saw how these two kinds of similarity connect to convergent and divergent evolution.
3

2
4

Cladograms are built by using shared derived traits to separate groups of species.
5

For example, lizards, rabbits and humans all descended from a common ancestor that had an amniotic egg,
6

so these three groups belong to the same clade.
◀ Previous2 / 6Next ▶
Connection for AP courses
1

Vertebrata is a larger clade that also includes fish and lampreys.
2

The closer two species or groups sit on a phylogenetic tree or cladogram, the more recently they shared a common ancestor.
3

3
4

New information can change a tree.
5

Computer programs such as BLAST help determine how closely organisms are related by comparing DNA sequences.
6

A phylogenetic tree is usually drawn according to the simplest explanation of evolutionary history,
◀ Previous3 / 6Next ▶
Connection for AP courses
Connection for AP courses
which uses the fewest evolutionary steps.
This principle is called maximum parsimony.
4
Understanding phylogeny reaches well beyond the history of life on Earth.
For botanists, phylogeny is a guide to finding new plants that can be used for food, medicine and clothing.
For doctors, phylogenies explain where diseases come from and how they can be treated.
◀ Previous4 / 6Next ▶
Connection for AP courses
1

HIV and AIDS are one example.
2

This section supports concepts from Big Idea 1 of the AP Biology Curriculum Framework: the process of evolution drives the diversity and unity of life.
3

Two enduring understandings are central.
4

The first is that change in the genetic makeup of a population over time is evolution,

which is supported by evidence from many disciplines,including mathematics.
5

The second is that organisms are linked by lines of descent from a common ancestor,

which is shown by conserved core processes and features shared across life.
6

Phylogenetic trees and cladograms are graphical models of evolutionary history, and they can be tested.
◀ Previous5 / 6Next ▶
Connection for AP courses
Connection for AP courses
The AP learning objectives combine this content with science practices such as posing scientific questions, evaluating data, justifying claims with evidence, designing a plan for collecting data,

and building models or diagrams of evolutionary processes.
◀ Previous6 / 6
1Two options for similarities2Two options for similarities
Two options for similarities
Two options for similarities
Organisms that share similar physical features and similar genomes tend to be more closely related than organisms that do not.
A feature that overlaps both in form (morphology) and in genetic makeup is called a homologous structure.
Homologous structures arise from developmental similarities that are the result of evolution.
The bones in the wings of bats and birds are an example of morphological homology: both groups have the same grouping of several bones arranged in the same way.
1 / 2Next ▶
Bird and bat wings are built from the same arrangement of bones, which indicates that the two groups inherited the structure from a shared evolutionary past. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Two options for similarities
Two options for similarities: Bird and bat wings are built from the same arrangement of bones, which indicates that the two groups inherited the structure from a shared evolutionary past." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

The complexity of a feature matters.
2

A single bone could arise by chance

but a group of bones arranged the same way is much less likely to appear independently.
3

Imagine two people in different countries who each design a car with exactly the same parts in exactly the same arrangement, without any shared knowledge.
4

That result would be very unlikely.
5

If two people each invent a hammer, however, it is reasonable to conclude that each could have had the idea alone

because a hammer is simple.
6

The same reasoning applies to homologous structures: the more complex the shared feature, the more likely it is that the overlap reflects a common ancestor.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Misleading appearances2Misleading appearances3Misleading appearances
Misleading appearances
1

Appearances can mislead.
2

A minor genetic change can cause a large difference in form between two closely related organisms

so they look very different.
3

In the other direction, unrelated organisms can be distantly related yet look very much alike.
4

This usually happens because both organisms have adaptations that evolved under similar environmental conditions.
5

When a resemblance comes from environmental pressures and not from a close evolutionary relationship, it is called an analogy, or homoplasy.
6

Insects, bats and birds all fly with wings

but the wings differ in structure and embryonic origin.
1 / 3Next ▶
Misleading appearances
Misleading appearances
These wings are analogous structures.
Homologous structures share a similar embryonic origin, whereas analogous structures have a similar function.
The bones in the front flipper of a whale are homologous to the bones in a human arm, and the two are not analogous.
The wings of a butterfly and the wings of a bird are analogous but not homologous.
Some structures are both: the wings of a bird and the wings of a bat are homologous,

because they share bone structure,and analogous,because they both serve flight.
Scientists therefore have to determine which kind of similarity a feature shows before they can reconstruct the phylogeny of the organisms under study.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
A honeybee wing has the same shape and function as bat and bird wings, but it has no bones and a different embryonic origin, so the resemblance is an analogy. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Misleading appearances
Misleading appearances: A honeybee wing has the same shape and function as bat and bird wings, but it has no bones and a different embryonic origin, so the resemblance is an analogy." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

A link in this section points to examples that show how appearances can mislead when working out the phylogenetic relationships of organisms. Studying those examples is a good way to practise spotting the difference between a true relationship and a coincidental resemblance.
2

James Lake of the UCLA/NASA Astrobiology Institute proposed that eukaryotic cells developed from a fusion of genes from the two other domains of life, Archaea and Bacteria.
3

Which genetic evidence would best support this hypothesis?
4

The correct answer is that some eukaryotic genes resemble those of Archaea, some resemble those of Bacteria,

and some are unlike the genes of either domain.
5

A mixture of gene types of this kind is what a fusion of two lineages would be expected to produce.
6

The other options fail: mitochondrial DNA resembling that of other eukaryotes, a double membrane around chloroplasts,

and all eukaryotic genes matching one domain do not point to a mixed origin.
◀ Previous3 / 3
Molecular comparisons
Molecular comparisons
Advances in DNA technology have made molecular systematics, the study of relationships using information at the molecular level, a fast-growing field. Computer programs now confirm many earlier classifications and also reveal earlier mistakes. DNA sequences can still be misleading, however.
Two very closely related organisms can appear unrelated if a mutation changes the genetic code.
An insertion or a deletion shifts the reading frame

so each nucleotide base is moved over by one place, and two similar codes look unrelated.
In the other direction, two segments of DNA from distantly related organisms can share a high percentage of bases at the same positions purely by chance,

so the organisms appear to be closely related when they are not.
Computer methods have been developed to correct for these problems.
Ultimately, combining morphological and molecular information gives the most reliable picture of phylogeny.
1Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters2Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters3Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters
Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters
Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters
Evolutionary biologists could list many reasons why phylogeny matters in everyday human life. For botanists, phylogeny guides the search for new plants that people can use. Humans use plants for food, medicine and clothing. If one plant contains a compound that treats a disease well, scientists may examine that plant’s relatives for other useful drugs.
A research team in China identified a segment of DNA thought to be shared by some medicinal plants of the legume family, Fabaceae.
After testing many species in this family, the team found a DNA marker, a known location on a chromosome that identifies a species.
Using the DNA to reconstruct relationships, the team could decide whether a newly discovered plant belonged to the family and then assess its possible medicinal value.
The plant Dalbergia sissoo carries this marker and belongs to the legume family, and later testing showed that it has fungicidal activity.
This supports the idea that DNA markers can be used to screen plants for medicinal properties.
1 / 3Next ▶
A botanical drawing of Dalbergia sissoo, a legume-family tree that carries a DNA marker shared with related species that have antifungal activity. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters
Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters: A botanical drawing of Dalbergia sissoo, a legume-family tree that carries a DNA marker shared with related species that have antifungal activity." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

The following practice item asks you to read a broad tree of life.
2

The image shows a tree comparing most organisms, with branch points marked by inherited character changes.
3

Make a claim about fungi based on this tree.
4

Fungi are more closely related to animals than to plants.
5

The correct claim is therefore that fungi are closer to animals than plants.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
A broad tree of life comparing bacteria, plants, fungi and animals, with branch points marked by inherited character changes and hypothetical common ancestors. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Evolution connection: why phylogeny matters
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Building phylogenetic trees2Building phylogenetic trees
Building phylogenetic trees
Building phylogenetic trees
How do scientists construct phylogenetic trees?
After homologous and analogous traits have been sorted, scientists often organize the homologous traits with a system called cladistics.
Cladistics sorts organisms into clades

which are groups of organisms that descended from a single ancestor.
In the example below, every organism in the coloured region evolved from one ancestor that had amniotic eggs.
Consequently, all of these organisms have amniotic eggs and form a single clade, also called a monophyletic group.
A clade must include all of the descendants of a branch point.
1 / 2Next ▶
Lizards, rabbits and humans descend from a common ancestor with an amniotic egg, so they form the amniote clade. The vertebrate clade is larger and also includes fish and lampreys. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Building phylogenetic trees
Building phylogenetic trees: Lizards, rabbits and humans descend from a common ancestor with an amniotic egg, so they form the amniote clade. The vertebrate clade is larger and also includes fish and lampreys." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

Eukaryotic mitochondria contain their own DNA, called mitochondrial DNA or mtDNA.
2

Nuclear DNA and mitochondrial DNA are thought to have separate evolutionary origins,

because mitochondrial DNA is derived from the circular chromosome of a bacterium that was engulfed by an ancient prokaryotic cell.
3

The question is whether the presence of mtDNA suggests that organisms share conserved core processes and features that evolved and are widely distributed today.
4

The answer is yes

because it suggests that eukaryotes carry traits that were likely inherited from prokaryotic ancestors.
5

The distractors are wrong: prokaryotes do not share the same organelles in the sense of eukaryotic mitochondria, mtDNA is not unused by eukaryotic cells,

and the presence of mtDNA is not evidence that the two kinds of DNA are unrelated.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Clades and non-clades2Clades and non-clades
Clades and non-clades
Clades and non-clades
Clades can vary in size depending on which branch point is under study.
The essential rule is that every organism in a clade, or monophyletic group, descends from a single point on the tree.
The word itself helps: “mono” means one, and “phyletic” refers to an evolutionary relationship.
A clade can contain several large groups, such as animals, fungi and plants together, or a single group, such as a particular flagellate lineage.
1 / 2Next ▶
Groups that come from a single branch point form clades, whereas groups that split at different branch points or leave out some members of a branch are not clades. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Clades and non-clades
Clades and non-clades: Groups that come from a single branch point form clades, whereas groups that split at different branch points or leave out some members of a branch are not clades." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Clades and non-clades
Glycolysis is the breakdown of glucose.
Almost all organisms use it to release the energy stored in glucose, and the energy is stored in cells as ATP for use when needed.
What does the fact that glycolysis is so widespread show about the evolutionary history of cells?
The best answer is that glycolysis has been conserved even though the three domains of life evolved independently.
The Krebs cycle and the electron transport chain are not required for prokaryotes,

and the statement that glycolysis is the only way to break down glucose is not supported by the evidence.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Shared characteristics2Shared characteristics3Shared characteristics
Shared characteristics
1

Organisms evolve from common ancestors and then diversify. Scientists use the phrase “descent with modification” because related organisms share many characteristics and genetic codes, yet changes accumulate over time. The same pattern repeats across the phylogenetic tree of life:
2

1
3

A change in the genetic makeup of an organism produces a new trait that becomes common within the group.
4

2
5

Many organisms descend from that point and inherit the trait.
6

3
1 / 3Next ▶
Shared characteristics
1

New variations keep arising. Some are adaptive and persist, leading to new traits.
2

4
3

With the new traits, a new branch point forms, and the cycle begins again at step 1.
4

If a characteristic is present in the ancestor of a group, it is a shared ancestral character

because every organism in the taxon or clade has the trait.
5

The vertebrate backbone shown in the amniote tree is a shared ancestral character.
6

A trait that appeared at some point in the history of a group and is held only by some of its members is a shared derived character.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Shared characteristics
Shared characteristics
The amniotic egg is one example in that tree: only some of the organisms have it.
These terms are relative.
The same trait can be ancestral or derived depending on which diagram is used.
In the amniote tree, the amniotic egg is a shared ancestral character for lizards, rabbits and humans,

whereas hair is a shared derived character found only in humans and rabbits.
For the amniotes as a group, however, the amniotic egg is a shared derived character that is not seen in fish.
Recognizing these terms helps scientists tell clades apart when they build phylogenetic trees.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Choosing the right relationships2Choosing the right relationships3Choosing the right relationships4Choosing the right relationships
Choosing the right relationships
1

Organizing the evolutionary relationships of all life on Earth is far harder than organizing the items in a department store.
2

Scientists must span enormous stretches of time and work with information from long-extinct organisms.
3

Homologies and analogies make it hard to decide which connections are real, and an accurate tree of life is extremely difficult to build.
4

DNA technology now supplies large quantities of genetic sequences

which adds data but also complexity.
5

Taxonomy is partly a subjective discipline,

because many organisms have more than one plausible connection to one another,so each taxonomist decides how the connections are ordered.
6

To make phylogenies accurate, scientists often rely on maximum parsimony

which means that events happened in the simplest, most obvious way.
1 / 4Next ▶
Choosing the right relationships
Choosing the right relationships
Suppose a group of people enters a forest preserve to go hiking.
Under maximum parsimony, the most likely prediction is that most of them will use the established trails rather than forge new ones.
Scientists reconstructing evolutionary pathways apply the same idea.
The most likely pathway contains the fewest major events that agree with the evidence.
Starting from all the homologous traits in a group, scientists look for the simplest order of evolutionary events that could have produced those traits.
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
Choosing the right relationships
Choosing the right relationships
A link in this section shows how maximum parsimony is applied to build phylogenetic trees from species data.
It is a useful way to see the principle at work

because the tree with the fewest character changes is preferred.
Practice item: What do phylogenetic relationships refer to?
The answer is the shared common ancestors of organisms.
Similarities and differences are the evidence used to infer relationships

but the relationship itself is about common ancestry.
Scientists rely on many tools and concepts to reveal the evolutionary history of life,
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
Choosing the right relationships
1

and newer technologies have produced surprising results.
2

For example, people appear to be more closely related to fungi than fungi are to plants.
3

As DNA sequence information grows, scientists will map the evolutionary history of all life on Earth more precisely.
◀ Previous4 / 4
Science practice connection for AP courses
1

Activity: Using a data set from your teacher or another source, construct a phylogenetic tree or cladogram that shows the evolutionary history of a group of organisms based on shared characteristics. Then share it with classmates for review and revision.
2

Lab Investigation 3 in the AP Biology investigative labs uses BLAST (Basic Local Alignment Search Tool) to compare several genes from different organisms. You use the comparison to construct a cladogram of evolutionary relatedness

then use BLAST to track one gene through several species. Bioinformatics, the use of computer tools to analyze biological data, has many applications, including the study of genetic disease.
3

Think about it: Why must scientists distinguish between homologous and analogous characteristics before building phylogenetic trees? Do more closely related organisms share homologous or analogous traits? Which type of trait supports convergent evolution, and which supports divergent evolution?
4

Scientists separate the two kinds of similarity because only homologous traits

which come from a common ancestor, reflect relatednessanalogous traits can evolve separately and mislead you.
5

More closely related organisms share homologous traits.
6

Analogous traits support convergent evolution, in which unrelated lineages evolve similar traits,

while homologous traits support divergent evolution, in which one ancestor gives rise to lineages with different forms.
1Example: reading a clade from a tree2Example: reading a clade from a tree · Example: applying max
Example: reading a clade from a tree
1

A tree has a branch point that gives rise to lizards, rabbits and humans.
2

Another branch point gives rise to lampreys, fish and the group containing lizards, rabbits and humans.
3

Which group is a clade?
4

Step 1: check whether the group contains every descendant of one branch point.
5

The group lizard, rabbit and human stems from one branch point, and nothing from that point is left out

so it is a clade, named Amniota.
6

Step 2: check the larger group of lampreys, fish, lizards, rabbits and humans.
1 / 2Next ▶
Example: reading a clade from a tree · Example: applying maximum parsimony
Example: reading a clade from a tree
It also stems from a single branch point and includes all its descendants

so it is a larger clade, named Vertebrata.
Step 3: a group made of rabbits and fish alone would not be a clade,

because those two organisms do not come from a single branch point that includes all their descendants.
Example: applying maximum parsimony
Three possible trees explain the distribution of a trait.
Tree A requires 3 evolutionary changes, tree B requires 5, and tree C requires 4.

Under maximum parsimony, the best hypothesis is the one with the fewest changes, so tree A is preferred.
The preference is for the simplest explanation, not for the most complicated one,

and tree A would be revised only if new data showed that its 3 steps do not fit the evidence.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Key terms
Term Meaning
Homologous structure A feature that overlaps in form and genetic makeup because the organisms inherited it from a common ancestor.
Analogous structure A similar feature that evolved separately in unrelated organisms because they share a function or environment, not a common origin.
Analogy (homoplasy) A resemblance caused by similar environmental conditions and not by a close evolutionary relationship.
Molecular systematics The study of evolutionary relationships using information at the molecular level, including DNA analysis.
Cladistics A system that sorts organisms into clades by using their shared derived characteristics.
Clade A group of organisms that descended from a single ancestor and includes all of that ancestor’s descendants.
Monophyletic group Another name for a clade; all members stem from a single point on the tree.
Phylogenetic tree A branching diagram that shows the hypothesized evolutionary history and relationships of organisms.
Cladogram A branching diagram built only from shared derived traits to show which groups form clades.
Shared ancestral character A trait present in the ancestor of a group and therefore found in every member of the clade.
Shared derived character A trait that arose at some point in a group’s history and is found only in some of its members.
Descent with modification The idea that organisms evolve from common ancestors and diversify as changes accumulate over time.
Maximum parsimony The principle that the best evolutionary explanation is the one requiring the fewest evolutionary steps.
DNA marker A known location on a chromosome that can be used to identify a species or group.
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) The DNA found inside mitochondria, which is derived from the circular chromosome of an ancient bacterium.
Insertion or deletion mutation A change that adds or removes bases, shifting the genetic code and making related sequences look different.
Bioinformatics The use of computer tools and databases to store, compare and analyze biological data such as DNA sequences.
BLAST A common bioinformatics tool that compares a DNA or protein sequence with sequences in a database to find related genes.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes3Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Assuming that a shared appearance always means a close relationshipWings of insects and birds look alike, but they are analogous, not homologous.
2Avoid this
Confusing homologous and analogous structuresHomologous structures share an embryonic origin, while analogous structures share a function.
3Avoid this
Calling a group a clade when it leaves out some descendants of a branch pointA clade must include every descendant of one ancestor.
1 / 3Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
4Avoid this
Treating a shared derived character as if it were present in the whole treeA derived trait is held only by some members of a group.
5Avoid this
Using the number of similarities alone to build a treeTrees should be built from shared derived traits,
and the simplest explanation with the fewest steps is preferred.Avoid this
6Avoid this
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
Assuming that DNA sequences are always reliableMutations and chance matches can make unrelated organisms look related,
so morphological and molecular data should be combined.Avoid this
◀ Previous3 / 3
Accepted payment methods