Curriculum
Course: Biology for AP Courses
Login

Curriculum

Biology for AP Courses

Text lesson

19.3 Adaptive Evolution

19.3 Adaptive Evolution — BIOLOGY FOR AP COURSES notes: Students will be able to explain how natural selection changes the variation of a population and compare stabilizing, directional, diversifying, frequency-dependent and sexual selection.

Science practice connection: artificial selection lab
Science practice connection: artificial selection lab
The AP Biology investigative lab on artificial selection uses Wisconsin Fast Plants. In this lab, students select plants to increase or decrease the genetic variation of a population

and then test whether extreme selection can change the expression of a quantitative traitwhich is a trait such as plant height that varies continuously and is influenced by many genes.
Think about it (answer): Genetic drift would most likely happen more quickly on an island than on the mainland. A small, isolated island population has fewer individuals

so chance events have a bigger effect on its allele frequencies. The calculations for the flower populations are in the worked examples below.
1Connections for AP courses2Connections for AP courses3Connections for AP courses4Connections for AP courses5Connections for AP courses
Connections for AP courses
1

1
2

In this section, you will explore two questions: what different ways natural selection can shape populations,
3

and how these forces lead to different outcomes for population variation.
4

2
5

Natural selection acts on individuals.
6

Individuals with higher fitness,
1 / 5Next ▶
Connections for AP courses
Connections for AP courses
meaning greater reproductive success than the rest of the population, leave more offspring,
so natural selection favors the most adaptive variation for a given environment.
In a stable environment, the fittest phenotypes lead to stabilizing selection

which lowers the variation in the population.
When conditions change, directional selection shifts the population toward a new and more favorable phenotype.
Diversifying selection increases variation by favoring two or more distinct phenotypes.
3
◀ Previous2 / 5Next ▶
Connections for AP courses
Connections for AP courses
Sexual selection occurs when one sex has more reproductive success than the other.
Because the sexes then face different pressures, they often develop distinct differences called sexual dimorphisms.
For example, male birds often have more colorful plumage than females of the same species.
4
Natural selection cannot create a perfect organism.
It acts on variation that already exists,
◀ Previous3 / 5Next ▶
Connections for AP courses
1

and other forces of evolution,
2

such as genetic drift and gene flow, can introduce harmful alleles into the gene pool.
3

Evolution has no purpose.
4

It is simply the sum of these forces acting on the genetic and phenotypic variation of a population.
5

This section supports Big Idea 1 of the AP Biology Curriculum Framework

which states that the process of evolution drives the diversity and unity of life.
6

The enduring understanding is that a change in the genetic makeup of a population over time is evolution.
◀ Previous4 / 5Next ▶
Connections for AP courses
1

Essential knowledge 1.A.1 states that natural selection is a major mechanism of evolution,

and 1.A.2 states that natural selection acts on phenotypic variation in populations.
2

The matching science practices are applying mathematical routines to quantities that describe natural phenomena (practice 2.2), evaluating evidence provided by data sets (practice 5.3),

and connecting phenomena and models across spatial and temporal scales (practice 7.1).
3

Learning objective 1.2 asks students to evaluate data to investigate the role of natural selection in evolution,

and learning objective 1.5 asks students to connect evolutionary change over time to a change in the environment.
◀ Previous5 / 5
1Adaptive evolution2Adaptive evolution3Adaptive evolution4Adaptive evolution
Adaptive evolution
Adaptive evolution
1
Natural selection acts only on heritable traits.
When it favors beneficial alleles and works against deleterious alleles, the frequency of those alleles changes in the population.
This process is called adaptive evolution.
2
Natural selection does not act on single alleles.
1 / 4Next ▶
Adaptive evolution
1

It acts on whole organisms.
2

An individual may carry a beneficial allele that increases its ability to reproduce (fecundity),
3

but if the same individual also carries an allele that causes a fatal childhood disease, the beneficial allele will not reach the next generation,
4

because the individual will not live to reproductive age.
5

3
6

The contribution an organism makes to the gene pool of the next generation is its evolutionary, or Darwinian, fitness.
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
Adaptive evolution
Adaptive evolution
Scientists can often measure fitness in the field.
However, what matters is relative fitness

which compares an individual’s fitness with that of the other organisms in the population.
Relative fitness shows which individuals contribute more offspring, and therefore how the population is likely to change.
4
Selection can affect population variation in five main ways: stabilizing selection, directional selection, diversifying selection, frequency-dependent selection and sexual selection.
As selection changes allele frequencies, individuals can become more or less genetically similar,
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
Adaptive evolution
Adaptive evolution
and the phenotypes in the population can become more or less alike.
◀ Previous4 / 4
Stabilizing selection
1

Stabilizing selection occurs when natural selection favors an average phenotype and acts against extreme variation.
2

Consider mice that live in a forest where the ground is a fairly consistent shade of brown.
3

Mice whose coats closely match that color are least likely to be spotted by predators,

so they survive, reproduce and pass on their genes for a brown coat.
4

Mice with coats that are a little lighter or darker stand out against the ground and are more likely to be eaten.
5

Over time, stabilizing selection decreases the genetic variability of the population.
1Directional selection2Directional selection3Directional selection
Directional selection
1

Directional selection happens when the environment changes and natural selection favors phenotypes at one end of the existing range of variation.
2

As a result, the population’s average shifts toward that end.
3

A classic example is the peppered moth in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century England.
4

Before the Industrial Revolution, most moths were light in color

which let them blend in with light-colored trees and lichens.
5

As factories released soot, the trees darkened, and the light moths became easier for predatory birds to spot.
6

Darker, melanic moths blended in with the sooty trees and survived better in polluted habitats,
1 / 3Next ▶
Directional selection
Directional selection
so the frequency of the dark form increased over time.
Directional selection can also be observed directly.
Suppose a population of rabbits that eat flowers is introduced into an environment with flowering plants.
Once the rabbits eat the flowers, the plants cannot reproduce.
Over time, the flowers grow taller

so that the rabbits cannot reach them.
The diagram below shows this pattern.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Small herbivores that eat flowers drive directional selection for taller flowers, because plants whose flowers are out of reach keep reproducing. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Directional selection
Directional selection: Small herbivores that eat flowers drive directional selection for taller flowers, because plants whose flowers are out of reach keep reproducing." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

Link to learning (idea): Scientists revise their ideas when new evidence appears. Recent work has questioned some of the facts behind the peppered moth story

so the example also shows how a textbook account can be updated as new data arrive.
2

Check your learning: What is fitness the measure of? (a) the frequency of beneficial alleles

(b) the effect of chance on a population’s gene pool(c) successful reproduction(d) the abnormalities in a population. Answer: (c) successful reproduction. Fitness measures how much an individual contributes to the next generation through reproduction, compared with other individuals.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Diversifying selection2Diversifying selection
Diversifying selection
Diversifying selection
Diversifying selection favors two or more distinct phenotypes, each of which has an advantage

while the intermediate phenotypes are on average less fit.
Many animal populations with several male forms show this pattern.
Large, dominant alpha males win mates by force

while small males sneak in for brief copulations with females in an alpha male’s territory.
Both the alpha males and the sneaker males are selected for,

but medium-sized males can neither overpower the alpha males nor sneak past them,so they are selected against.
Diversifying selection can also occur when environmental change favors individuals at both ends of the range.
Imagine mice living on a beach with light-colored sand and patches of tall grass.
1 / 2Next ▶
Three graphs compare selection types: stabilizing selection favors the average, directional selection shifts the spread toward one end, and diversifying selection favors both extremes while selecting against the average. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Diversifying selection
Diversifying selection: Three graphs compare selection types: stabilizing selection favors the average, directional selection shifts the spread toward one end, and diversifying selection favors both extremes while selecting against the average." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Diversifying selection
Light mice that blend in with the sand are favored, and so are dark mice that can hide in the grass.
Medium-colored mice match neither background and are more likely to be eaten.
The result is increased genetic variability as the population becomes more diverse.
Check your learning: The number of dark-colored moths has increased until they are the most common color. This is an example of which type of selection? (a) directional selection

(b) stabilizing selection(c) frequency-dependent selection(d) diversifying selection. Answer: (a) directional selection. The population shifted in one direction, toward dark coloration, after the environment changed.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Frequency-dependent selection2Frequency-dependent selection3Frequency-dependent selection
Frequency-dependent selection
1

Frequency-dependent selection favors a phenotype according to how common it is.
2

Positive frequency-dependent selection favors common phenotypes

which usually decreases genetic variability.
3

Negative frequency-dependent selection favors rare phenotypes

which increases genetic variability.
4

A clear example is the side-blotched lizard of the Pacific Northwest.
5

Males come in three throat colors, and each color has a different mating strategy.
6

Orange males are the strongest and fight other males for access to females.
1 / 3Next ▶
Frequency-dependent selection
1

Blue males are medium-sized and form strong pair bonds with their mates.
2

Yellow males are the smallest, look somewhat like females, and sneak copulations.
3

The three forms form a rock-paper-scissors pattern.
4

Orange beats blue

because large orange males can fight off blue males and mate with the females that blue males have paired with.
5

Blue beats yellow

because blue males guard their mates against yellow sneaker males.
6

Yellow beats orange

because yellow males can sneak copulations from the potential mates of the large orange males.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
A yellow-throated side-blotched lizard is smaller than the blue- or orange-throated males and looks somewhat like a female, which lets it sneak matings. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Frequency-dependent selection
Frequency-dependent selection: A yellow-throated side-blotched lizard is smaller than the blue- or orange-throated males and looks somewhat like a female, which lets it sneak matings." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Frequency-dependent selection
Because of this pattern, the frequencies of the three forms rise and fall over generations.
When blue males dominate, orange males are favored.
When orange males dominate, yellow males are favored.
When yellow males are the majority, blue males are favored.
The lizard population therefore cycles through the three forms.
Because the rare form is favored, this is negative frequency-dependent selection.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Sexual selection2Sexual selection
Sexual selection
1

Males and females of many species differ in ways beyond their reproductive organs.
2

Males are often larger and show elaborate colors and adornments, like the peacock’s tail,

while females are usually smaller and more plainly decorated.
3

These differences are called sexual dimorphisms.
4

They arise because, in many animal populations, male reproductive success varies much more than female reproductive success.
5

Some males, often the largest, strongest or most decorated, obtain most of the matings

while others obtain none.
6

This can happen because males win fights with other males, or because females choose the bigger or more decorated males.
1 / 2Next ▶
Sexual dimorphism appears in peacocks and peahens, in Argiope spiders where the female is much larger than the male, and in wood ducks. Image: OpenStax, Biology for AP Courses, CC BY 4.0.
Sexual selection
Sexual selection: Sexual dimorphism appears in peacocks and peahens, in Argiope spiders where the female is much larger than the male, and in wood ducks." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Sexual selection
Sexual dimorphism varies widely among species, and some species are sex-role reversed. In those cases, females have more variable reproductive success than males, and females are the ones selected for larger body size and elaborate traits.
The selection pressures that help males and females obtain matings are called sexual selection.
Sexual selection can produce secondary sexual characteristics

which help an individual win mates rather than survive.
It can even favor traits that lower survival.
The peacock’s large tail is brightly colored and attracts females

but it makes the bird more visible to predators and slower to escape.
Females still prefer the largest tails.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Handicap principle and good genes hypothesis2Handicap principle and good genes hypothesis
Handicap principle and good genes hypothesis
Handicap principle and good genes hypothesis
The handicap principle proposes that a costly trait is an honest signal of quality. A large tail is risky

so only the best males survive while carrying it. The bigger the tail, the more fit the male is likely to be, and females who choose such males select for fitness.
The good genes hypothesis states that males display impressive traits to show an efficient metabolism or a strong ability to fight disease.
Females choose the males with the most impressive traits because those traits signal superior genetic quality,

which the females’ offspring will inherit.
Choosing carefully can reduce the number of offspring

but fewer and healthier offspring may improve survival more than many weaker ones.
Link to learning (idea): In 1915, Ronald Fisher proposed the Fisherian runaway model. In it, a female preference for a male trait and the trait itself become linked, and a self-reinforcing process drives both to increase in the population.
Check your learning: Which statement best describes the handicap principle for the peacock’s tail?
1 / 2Next ▶
Handicap principle and good genes hypothesis
1

(a) A healthy tail discourages predation

so the birds with tails survive.
2

(b) The tail must be an advantage

because a trait that handicaps its carrier cannot evolve.
3

(c) The longest tails are eaten

so the average tail length falls.
4

(d) The tail is a clear disadvantage,

but only the most fit males can survive with it,so a healthy tail is an honest signal of quality that wins more matings. Answer: (d).
◀ Previous2 / 2
1No perfect organism2No perfect organism3No perfect organism4No perfect organism
No perfect organism
1

1
2

Natural selection is a driving force of evolution, and it can produce populations that are better adapted to their environments.
3

However, it cannot produce a perfect organism.
4

It acts only on existing variation,
5

so it is limited by the population’s genetic variability and by the new alleles that arise through mutation and gene flow.
6

2
1 / 4Next ▶
No perfect organism
No perfect organism
Natural selection is also limited because it works on individuals rather than alleles.
Some alleles are linked because they lie close together on the genome and are usually passed on together, a pattern called linkage disequilibrium.
A good allele can therefore be lost if it is carried by individuals that also have several very harmful alleles.
A harmful allele can persist if it is carried by individuals that have enough beneficial alleles to be fit overall.
3
Selection can also be constrained by the relationships among phenotypes.
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
No perfect organism
1

Return to the beach mice: light mice blend with the sand and dark mice blend with the grass

but medium-colored mice are poorly camouflaged.
2

Even if dark mice are fitter than light mice, the light mice cannot gradually evolve darker coats.
3

Each step toward dark coloring would pass through the medium-colored intermediates

which are less fit and more likely to be eaten.
4

4
5

Not all evolution is adaptive.
6

Genetic drift and gene flow often introduce deleterious alleles into a population’s gene pool.
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
No perfect organism
No perfect organism
Evolution has no purpose and does not move a population toward a preset ideal.
It is simply the sum of these forces and how they influence the genetic and phenotypic variability of the population.
◀ Previous4 / 4
Science practice connection: Think about it
Science practice connection: Think about it
In recent years, factories have become cleaner and release less soot. Predict the effect on the distribution of moth color in the population.
Answer: Dark moths had an advantage only because soot darkened the trees.
With less soot, the trees become lighter again

so light-colored moths are better camouflaged and dark moths lose their advantage.
Over generations, the frequency of the dark form should decline and light-colored moths should become more common again.
The size of the change depends on how fully the trees are cleaned and how strongly birds select for moth color.
1Example 1: Frequency of red flowers in the two populations2Example 1: Frequency of red flowers in the two populations
Example 1: Frequency of red flowers in the two populations
1

Frequency is the number of individuals with a given form divided by the total number in the population.
2

It has no SI unit

it is a fraction from 0 to 1which can also be written as a percentage.
3

Before the split, the population had 200 red flowers and 600 blue flowers, for a total of 800 flowers.
4

The frequency of red flowers was 200 ÷ 800 = 0.25 (25%).
5

After the river split the population, population 1 had 10 red and 125 blue flowers, a total of 135. Its red frequency is 10 ÷ 135 = 0.074 (about 7.4%). Population 2 had 300 red and 450 blue flowers, a total of 750. Its red frequency is 300 ÷ 750 = 0.40 (40%).
6

Interpretation: Red flowers fell from 25% to about 7.4% in population 1, a drop of about 17.6 percentage points.
1 / 2Next ▶
Example 1: Frequency of red flowers in the two populations
1

Population 1 is small, and in small populations chance events can shift allele frequencies a lot

so genetic drift is the more likely cause.
2

Red flowers rose from 25% to 40% in population 2, a gain of 15 percentage points.
3

Population 2 is much larger

so chance alone is less likely to produce such a consistent shift, and natural selection is the more likely cause.
4

Counts alone cannot prove the cause

but they support this reasoning.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Key terms
Term Meaning
Natural selection The process by which individuals with heritable traits suited to their environment survive and reproduce more than others.
Adaptive evolution Change in a population’s genetic makeup caused by natural selection favoring beneficial alleles and reducing deleterious alleles.
Evolutionary (Darwinian) fitness The contribution an organism makes to the gene pool of the next generation through reproduction.
Relative fitness An individual’s fitness compared with the fitness of the other individuals in the same population.
Stabilizing selection Selection that favors an average phenotype and acts against extreme phenotypes, which reduces variation.
Directional selection Selection that favors phenotypes at one end of the existing range, shifting the population’s average toward that end.
Diversifying selection Selection that favors two or more distinct phenotypes while selecting against intermediate phenotypes, which increases variation.
Frequency-dependent selection Selection in which the advantage of a phenotype depends on how common that phenotype is in the population.
Positive frequency-dependent selection Selection that favors common phenotypes, which usually decreases genetic variability.
Negative frequency-dependent selection Selection that favors rare phenotypes, which increases genetic variability.
Sexual selection Selection caused by differences in reproductive success between the sexes, which can favor traits that help mating success even when they lower survival.
Sexual dimorphism Visible differences in size, color or ornaments between males and females of the same species.
Secondary sexual characteristic A trait that helps an individual obtain mates and reproduce rather than helping it survive.
Handicap principle The idea that a costly, risky trait is an honest signal of quality, because only the fittest individuals can survive while carrying it.
Good genes hypothesis The idea that females choose males with impressive traits because those traits signal genetic quality that the offspring will inherit.
Linkage disequilibrium The tendency of alleles that lie close together on a chromosome to be inherited together.
Deleterious allele An allele that reduces the fitness of the individuals that carry it.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes3Avoid these mistakes4Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Saying that natural selection acts on single allelesIt acts on whole organisms,
and an allele’s effect depends on the fitness of the individuals that carry it.Avoid this
2Avoid this
Describing natural selection as creating new traits from scratchIt acts only on variation that already exists in the population.
3Avoid this
1 / 4Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
Confusing directional selection,Avoid this
which shifts the average toward one extreme, with diversifying selection,Avoid this
which favors both extremes and selects against the averageDirectional selection shifts the average toward one extreme,
while diversifying selection favors both extremes and selects against the average.Avoid this
4Avoid this
Assuming frequency-dependent selection always changes variation in the same wayPositive frequency-dependent selection usually decreases variation,
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
while negative frequency-dependent selection increases it.Avoid this
5Avoid this
Treating fitness as absolute survivalFitness is measured relative to the other individuals in the population.
6Avoid this
Concluding that evolution has a goalEvolution has no purpose, and genetic drift and gene flow can add harmful alleles.
7Avoid this
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
Assuming sexual selection always favors traits that help survivalIt can favor traits that make survival harder, such as large, conspicuous tails.
◀ Previous4 / 4
Accepted payment methods