Curriculum
Course: AQA A Level Physics 7408
Login

Curriculum

AQA A Level Physics 7408

2. Particles and Radiation

0/58 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

3. Waves

0/39 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

4. Mechanics and Materials

0/77 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

5. Electricity

0/25 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

6. Further Mechanics and Thermal Physics

0/77 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

7. Fields and Their Consequences

0/111 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

8. Nuclear Physics

0/56 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

9. Astrophysics

0/65 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

10. Medical Physics

0/64 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

11. Engineering Physics

0/46 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

12. Turning Points in Physics

0/56 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material
Text lesson

8.4.4 Binding Energy

8.4.4 Binding Energy — AQA A Level Physics 7408 notes: Interpret the graph of binding energy per nucleon against nucleon number and explain why fusion of light nuclei and fission of heavy nuclei both release energy.

1The curve of binding energy per nucleon2The curve of binding energy per nucleon3The curve of binding energy per nucleon
The curve of binding energy per nucleon
The curve of binding energy per nucleon
Plotting binding energy per nucleon against nucleon number A gives a characteristic curve:
1 / 3Next ▶
The curve of binding energy per nucleon
1

it rises steeply for the lightest nuclei, with a small peak at helium-4 (about 7 MeV per nucleon) standing above its neighbours
2

it reaches a broad maximum of about 8.8 MeV per nucleon near iron-56 (A ≈ 56)
3

it then falls slowly, reaching about 7.6 MeV per nucleon for uranium-235 and 238.
4

For most of the range A from about 20 to 200 the value stays between 8 and 9 MeV

so it is nearly constant. This near-constancy follows from the short range of the strong force, since each nucleon is bound only by its nearest neighbours.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Binding energy per nucleon (MeV) against nucleon number A, rising steeply for light nuclei, peaking near iron-56 at about 8.8 MeV, falling to about 7.6 MeV for uranium-238, with fusion and fission arrows.
The curve of binding energy per nucleon
◀ Previous3 / 3
Why the shape? · Why the shape?
Why the shape?
At low A, most nucleons are at the surface and have few neighbours

so they are bound less tightly: the curve rises as the surface-to-volume ratio falls.
Why the shape?
At high A the long-range electrostatic repulsion between the many protons increasingly offsets the strong force

which lowers the binding energy per nucleon again.
Helium-4 is exceptionally stable because its two protons and two neutrons fill the lowest levels

which is why α particles are emitted from heavy nuclei.
1Energy release by fusion and fission · Fusion2Fission
Energy release by fusion and fission · Fusion
Energy release by fusion and fission
A reaction releases energy when the products have a higher binding energy per nucleon than the reactants (the nucleons end up more tightly bound and the extra comes out as kinetic energy):
Fusion
two light nuclei join to make a heavier one, moving up the left side of the curve. The change per nucleon is large

so fusion releases more energy per kilogram than fission.
1 / 2Next ▶
Bar chart of total binding energy: uranium-235 nucleus about 1786 MeV before fission versus two fragments about 1998 MeV after fission, with the energy released of about 210 MeV marked.
Fission
Bar chart of total binding energy: uranium-235 nucleus about 1786 MeV before fission versus two fragments about 1998 MeV after fission, with the energy released of about 210 MeV marked." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

a heavy nucleus splits into two medium ones, moving up the right side towards the peak. The release is smaller per nucleon but the change is still of order 1 MeV per nucleon, about 200 MeV per uranium-235 nucleus.
2

Neither process can release energy by passing beyond iron: fusing nuclei heavier than iron, or splitting nuclei lighter than iron, takes in energy.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Calculating the energy released2Calculating the energy released3Calculating the energy released
Calculating the energy released
Calculating the energy released
Energy released = (total binding energy of the products) − (total binding energy of the reactants).
1
Note the direction: it is the
products
that must be more tightly bound.
2
1 / 3Next ▶
Calculating the energy released
1

Do not mix this up with mass: the products have less mass than the reactants.
2

3
3

Total binding energy = binding energy per nucleon × A.
4

4
5

For example, in the fusion reaction
6

H +
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Calculating the energy released
Calculating the energy released
H →
He + n the free neutron has no binding energy

so only the three nuclei need to be considered.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Reading the curve in exam questions2Reading the curve in exam questions
Reading the curve in exam questions
Reading the curve in exam questions
Exam questions usually give the graph, or a table of values, and ask you to read off binding energies per nucleon.
1 / 2Next ▶
Reading the curve in exam questions
1

To use them, first decide the direction of the change on the graph

then convert to total energy.
2

For fission, the reactant is one point at high A (about 7.6 MeV per nucleon) and the products are at A of about 90 and 140

where the value is higher, around 8.5 MeV.
3

For fusion, the reactants are at low A on the steep part of the curve and the product is nearer the peak.
4

You should also be able to explain in words why a typical fusion reaction gives more energy per kilogram than fission.
5

The gain per nucleon is larger (for example, from about 1.1 MeV per nucleon for deuterium to about 7 MeV per nucleon for helium), and a kilogram of light nuclei contains more nuclei than a kilogram of uranium.
6

However, fusion needs temperatures of tens of millions of kelvin to overcome the electrostatic repulsion between the nuclei

which is why it needs the very high temperatures found in stars and why it is difficult to harness on Earth.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Stability and decay link2Stability and decay link3Stability and decay link
Stability and decay link
Stability and decay link
The binding energy curve also explains the pattern of decays seen earlier.
1 / 3Next ▶
Stability and decay link
Stability and decay link
A heavy nucleus can lower its energy by emitting an α particle

because helium-4 is so tightly bound that the decay releases energy even though the daughter has a similar binding energy per nucleon to the parent.
Nuclei beyond uranium become increasingly unstable because the repulsion between so many protons outweighs the extra strong-force binding.
When you compare two nuclei, the one with the higher binding energy per nucleon is the more stable

but you must not infer that it has the greater
total
binding energy: a large nucleus with a lower value per nucleon can still have the larger total.
The mass defect is the amount by which a nucleus’s mass is less than the combined mass of its separate nucleons.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Stability and decay link
1

Mass and energy are equivalent

so the mass lost when a nucleus forms is released as energy.
2

Nuclear binding energies are in MeV, far above atomic electron binding energies

so nuclear reactions release far more energy.
3

Fission of a heavy nucleus is usually induced when a neutron strikes it, producing two or more smaller daughter nuclei.
4

Neutrons released by fission can hit other nuclei and set off a chain reaction.
5

In power stations the chain reaction is controlled

but an uncontrolled one could cascade into the destructive effects of a nuclear bomb.
◀ Previous3 / 3
1Worked examples2Worked examples
Worked examples
Worked examples
Worked example 1. Calculate the energy released in the fusion reaction 21H + 31H → 42He + 10n, given the total binding energies: 2H 2.22 MeV, 3H 8.48 MeV, 4He 28.3 MeV.
Reactants: 2.22 + 8.48 = 10.70 MeV. Products: 28.3 MeV (the neutron has none).
Energy released = 28.3 − 10.70 = 17.6 MeV.
Worked example 2. Estimate the energy released when one uranium-235 nucleus splits into two fragments, using binding energies per nucleon of 7.6 MeV for uranium and 8.5 MeV for the fragments.
Total binding energy before = 235 × 7.6 = 1786 MeV. After = 235 × 8.5 = 1998 MeV (ignoring the few free neutrons).
Energy released = 1998 − 1786 = 212 MeV, roughly 2 × 102 MeV

which matches the accepted value of about 200 MeV.
1 / 2Next ▶
Worked examples
Worked examples
Worked example 3. The binding energy per nucleon of iron-56 is 8.8 MeV. What is the total energy needed to separate a nucleus completely into nucleons? Give your answer in joules.
Total = 56 × 8.8 = 493 MeV.
In joules: 493 × 1.60 × 10−13 = 7.9 × 10−11 J.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Key terms
Term Meaning
Binding energy per nucleon Binding energy of a nucleus divided by its nucleon number.
Fusion Joining of two light nuclei to form a heavier nucleus.
Fission Splitting of a heavy nucleus into two lighter ones.
Iron-56 peak Region of greatest stability, about 8.8 MeV per nucleon.
Strong force saturation Binding energy per nucleon stays roughly constant because the force acts only between near neighbours.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Saying fusion of iron releases energy: iron is at the peak, so neither fusion nor fission releases energy there.Avoid this
2Avoid this
Mixing up which reactants/products must have the greater binding energy: the products must be more tightly bound for energy to be released.Avoid this
3Avoid this
Forgetting to multiply the binding energy per nucleon by A to get the total.Avoid this
1 / 2Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
4Avoid this
Thinking helium-4 has the highest binding energy per nucleon: its value is a local peak, but iron and nickel are higher.Avoid this
5Avoid this
Believing the binding energy per nucleon rises steadily with A: it peaks and then falls.Avoid this
◀ Previous2 / 2
Accepted payment methods