Curriculum
Course: AQA A Level Physics 7408
Login

Curriculum

AQA A Level Physics 7408

2. Particles and Radiation

0/58 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

3. Waves

0/39 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

4. Mechanics and Materials

0/77 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

5. Electricity

0/25 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

6. Further Mechanics and Thermal Physics

0/77 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

7. Fields and Their Consequences

0/111 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

8. Nuclear Physics

0/56 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

9. Astrophysics

0/65 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

10. Medical Physics

0/64 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

11. Engineering Physics

0/46 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

12. Turning Points in Physics

0/56 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material
Text lesson

10.6.7 Comparing Imaging Techniques

10.6.7 Comparing Imaging Techniques — AQA A Level Physics 7408 notes: Compare X-ray, CT, ultrasound, MRI and radionuclide imaging in terms of what they show, radiation risk, resolution, cost and suitability.

1What the techniques measure2What the techniques measure3What the techniques measure4What the techniques measure
What the techniques measure
What the techniques measure
Each technique uses a different interaction between radiation and the body

so each gives different information.
1 / 4Next ▶
What the techniques measure
1

X-ray radiograph
2

absorption of X-rays by tissues

shows
3

structure
4

, especially bone, in 2D.
5

CT
6

absorption of X-rays from many angles

shows
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
What the techniques measure
What the techniques measure
in 3D slices with good soft tissue contrast.
Ultrasound
reflection of sound at boundaries between tissues

shows structure and movement in real time, and blood flow with Doppler.
MRI
radio-frequency signals from hydrogen nuclei in a magnetic field

shows soft tissue structure in great detail.
Gamma camera / SPECT and PET
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
What the techniques measure
What the techniques measure
radiation from tracers in the body

show
function
and metabolism (where the tracer goes), with lower spatial resolution.
◀ Previous4 / 4
1Radiation and risk2Non-ionising
Radiation and risk
1

X-ray imaging, CT and radionuclide imaging use ionising radiation

which has a small risk of causing cancerso the dose has to be justified.
2

Typical effective doses are of the order of 0.02 mSv for a chest X-ray, 1–5 mSv for many radionuclide scans,
3

and about 5–15 mSv for a CT scan, compared with the average natural background dose of about 2–3 mSv per year.
1 / 2Next ▶
Non-ionising
1

Ultrasound and MRI use
2

non-ionising
3

radiation (sound and radio waves), with no known cancer risk at diagnostic levels,
4

and so are preferred for repeated scans and for pregnancy,
5

although MRI has hazards from strong magnetic fields and metal implants.
6

Doses are kept as low as reasonably achievable, and children and pregnant women receive special consideration.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Comparison table
Technique Shows Ionising Resolution Cost / speed
X-ray Bone, lungs (2D) Yes (low dose) Good (< 1 mm) Cheap, fast
CT 3D slices, bone and soft tissue Yes (high dose) About 0.5–1 mm Expensive, fast
Ultrasound Soft tissue, movement, blood flow No 1–2 mm Cheap, portable, real time
MRI Soft tissue in detail No About 1 mm Very expensive, slow
Gamma camera / PET Function, metabolism Yes (tracer dose) 5–10 mm (PET 4–5 mm) Expensive, slow; PET needs a cyclotron
1Choosing a technique2Choosing a technique
Choosing a technique
1

Factors to consider: what must be seen (bone, soft tissue, function), the radiation risk and the age and condition of the patient, resolution, cost and availability, speed (an emergency head injury needs a quick CT, not a long MRI), and any contraindications (pacemaker for MRI, pregnancy for ionising methods). For example:
2

1
3

A suspected broken arm: X-ray (cheap, quick, shows bone clearly).
4

2
5

Checking a fetus: ultrasound (non-ionising, real time).
6

3
1 / 2Next ▶
Choosing a technique
Choosing a technique
A suspected brain tumour or torn ligament: MRI (excellent soft tissue contrast, no ionising radiation).
4
Internal bleeding after trauma: CT (fast, 3D).
5
Checking whether a cancer has spread and whether the tumour is active: PET-CT (function plus structure).
Often techniques are combined

because structure and function information complement each other.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Evaluating evidence
Evaluating evidence
In an evaluation question, state the advantage of the method, the limitation, and compare them in terms of the specific patient and diagnosis. Always link statements to physics: for example, ultrasound cannot image the lungs because of the large impedance difference at the air boundary

while MRI shows brain tissue clearly because of the differences in hydrogen density and relaxation times between grey and white matter.
Worked examples
1

Worked example 1. A patient has a chest X-ray (0.02 mSv) and a CT scan of the chest (7.0 mSv). How many chest X-rays are equivalent in dose to the CT scan?
2

7.0 / 0.02 = 350 chest X-rays.
3

Worked example 2. The natural background dose is 2.5 mSv per year. For how many days of natural background is a 5.0 mSv scan equivalent?
4

5.0 / 2.5 = 2.0 years = 2.0 × 365 = 730 days.
5

Worked example 3. A doctor suspects that a pregnant patient has gall stones. Suggest and justify a suitable imaging technique.
6

Ultrasound is suitable because it is non-ionising and so poses no known radiation risk to the fetus. It is cheap and real time, and gall stones show as strong reflectors, often with an acoustic shadow behind them.
Key terms
Term Meaning
Structural imaging Shows anatomy, such as X-ray, CT, MRI and ultrasound.
Functional imaging Shows processes, such as PET and gamma camera.
Ionising radiation Radiation able to remove electrons from atoms and damage cells.
Contraindication A condition that makes a procedure unsuitable.
Effective dose Measure of the risk from radiation, in sieverts.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Saying MRI uses X-rays or ionising radiation. It uses radio waves and a strong magnetic field.Avoid this
2Avoid this
Claiming ultrasound is always the best. It cannot image through air or bone.Avoid this
3Avoid this
Forgetting that PET and gamma cameras show function and have poorer resolution.Avoid this
1 / 2Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
4Avoid this
Stating only advantages when asked to compare. Include limitations too.Avoid this
5Avoid this
Assuming CT has a dose similar to a radiograph. It is far higher.Avoid this
◀ Previous2 / 2
Accepted payment methods