Curriculum
Course: Edexcel IAL Physics (IAS & A2)
Login

Curriculum

Edexcel IAL Physics (IAS & A2)

1. Mechanics and Materials

0/71 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

2. Waves and Electricity

0/108 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

3. Practical Skills in Physics I

0/52 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

4. Further Mechanics, Fields and Particles

0/90 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

5. Thermodynamics, Radiation, Oscillations and Cosmology

0/96 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material
Text lesson

3.2.6 Evaluating Experiments

3.2.6 Evaluating Experiments — IAL Physics Notes — EDEXCEL IAL PHYSICS (IAS & A2) notes: Evaluate the quality of an investigation by judging its accuracy, precision and validity, identifying sources of error and suggesting specific improvements.

Purpose of an evaluation
Purpose of an evaluation
Judgement

an evaluation decides how good the results are and how far they support the conclusion.It identifies specific limitations of the method and explains their effect on the data.It proposes a specific improvement for each limitation and checks that the data really support the claim made.
1Accuracy · Precision · Reliability2Validity
Accuracy · Precision · Reliability
Accuracy
compare the result with an accepted value and calculate the percentage difference.
If the accepted value lies inside the uncertainty range, the result is consistent with it.
Precision
look at the scatter of repeat readings and the closeness of points to the best-fit line.
Small scatter means high precision.
Reliability
repeated readings and repeated experiments should agree with one another.
1 / 2Next ▶
Validity
Validity
only the independent variable should be changed and the method must measure what it claims to measure.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Identifying the limitations2Identifying the limitations
Identifying the limitations
Identifying the limitations
Largest percentage uncertainty it dominates the final uncertainty and is the key limitation to address.
Systematic errors zero error, mis-calibration, heating of a wire, resistance of leads, heat lost to the surroundings and friction.
They show as non-zero intercepts or consistent departures from theory.
Random errors timing by hand, reading scales and judging a position by eye.
They show as scatter about the trend.
Uncontrolled variables temperature drift, a battery running down and draughts.
1 / 2Next ▶
Free-body diagram of a pendulum bob at angle theta showing tension along the string, weight downward and air drag opposing the motion.
Identifying the limitations
Free-body diagram of a pendulum bob at angle theta showing tension along the string, weight downward and air drag opposing the motion." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Identifying the limitations
Limited range or too few readings the pattern of the relationship may be missed.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Reducing errors in the method2Reducing errors in the method3Reducing errors in the method
Reducing errors in the method
1

Repeat measurements and use mean values this increases accuracy and reduces the effect of random error.
2

Reduce systematic errors methods that remove systematic errors increase accuracy.
3

Time many oscillations human reaction time is a common timing error.
4

Time 10 or more oscillations of a pendulum and divide by the number of oscillations to find the period.
5

Increasing the total time measured reduces the percentage uncertainty in one period.
6

Use a fiducial marker a fixed reference mark improves timing of oscillations.
1 / 3Next ▶
Reducing errors in the method
Reducing errors in the method
It marks the centre of the oscillation

where the pendulum moves fastestso the moment of passing is easier to judge.
Use a large initial amplitude for a mass on a spring the period is then longer

which reduces the effect of reaction time.
Damping makes later oscillations smaller

so the effect is reduced if the first oscillations have a large amplitude.
The spring must not exceed its elastic limit, or it will not return to its original length.
The oscillations must be vertical

so the mass is not pulled down at an angle.
◀ Previous2 / 3Next ▶
Graph of period squared against length for a simple pendulum: data points, expected line through origin, and a red best-fit line with a y-intercept offset of 0.12 s2.
Reducing errors in the method
◀ Previous3 / 3
Set square · Plumb line
Set square
a right-angled triangle used to check that an object is vertical, that two objects are at right angles or that two lines are parallel.
Aligned against a ruler and the bottom of a spring, it shows that the ruler is parallel to the spring

so the extension h1 − h2 is read correctly.
Plumb line
a weighted string that shows whether a setup is vertically aligned.
Suggesting improvements
Suggesting improvements
Specific change

each improvement must be linked to a stated weakness and give the expected effect.Use light gates and a datalogger instead of a stopwatch to remove the reaction-time uncertainty of about 0.2 s.Use a micrometer instead of a ruler for a wire diameter so the percentage uncertainty falls.Insulate a calorimeter with lagging and a lid to reduce heat loss.Take at least six values over a wider range and repeat each three times.
1Result · Aim · Intercept2Evidence
Result · Aim · Intercept
Result
state the value with its unit and uncertainty, and compare it with the accepted value or expected relationship.
Aim
say whether the aim has been met and whether the data support the hypothesis within the uncertainty.
Intercept
if the line does not pass through the origin as predicted, state this and give the likely systematic cause.
1 / 2Next ▶
Evidence
1

support each statement with figures from the experiment, such as a 10% uncertainty from a 0.2 s reaction time on a 2.0 s interval.
2

Experimental (operator) errors create one-off anomalous readings that should be found during evaluation before conclusions are drawn.
3

A repeat is anomalous only when it lies far beyond the spread of the other readings, not merely within normal timing spread.
4

Readings should be taken at equal intervals, with the step between values being 1, 2 or 5, or a multiple of ten.
5

Voltages and currents must stay well below the limit of each component, or the components may overheat and fail.
6

Zeros before all non-zero digits are never significant

so 0.00079 has only two significant figures.
◀ Previous2 / 2
More from the specification
Instrument Resolution and Significant Figures
  • Recorded experimental data must match the resolution of the measuring device, preserving trailing zeros to reflect the correct number of decimal places and significant digits.
    • (e.g. 2.30 mm vs 2.3 mm)
Identifying Anomalous Data
  • When conducting multiple repeat trials for current or time, anomalous readings that deviate substantially from the pattern must be excluded before taking a mean.
Precision in Derived Calculations
  • When performing calculations, intermediate results should maintain extra decimal digits,
  • while the final answer must be rounded to match the lowest number of significant figures in the raw data.
Graph Evaluation and Best-Fit Lines
  • When plotting experimental data on a graph, error bars illustrate uncertainty,
  • and a line of best fit must be drawn with a balanced scatter of points, ignoring identified anomalies.
Instrument Resolution and Significant Figures
  • Recorded experimental data must match the resolution of the measuring device, preserving trailing zeros to reflect the correct number of decimal places and significant digits.
    • (e.g. 2.30 mm vs 2.3 mm)
Identifying Anomalous Data
  • When conducting multiple repeat trials for current or time, anomalous readings that deviate substantially from the pattern must be excluded before taking a mean.
Precision in Derived Calculations
  • When performing calculations, intermediate results should maintain extra decimal digits,
  • while the final answer must be rounded to match the lowest number of significant figures in the raw data.
Graph Evaluation and Best-Fit Lines
  • When plotting experimental data on a graph, error bars illustrate uncertainty,
  • and a line of best fit must be drawn with a balanced scatter of points, ignoring identified anomalies.
Potential difference
  • Work done by a unit charge passing through a component.
Current
  • Flow of electrons in a circuit.
Resolution
  • Smallest change an instrument can detect.
Apparatus
  • The equipment needed to carry out an experiment.
Significant figures
  • Digits carrying meaningful information in a number.
Anomalous reading
  • A measurement that does not fit the pattern of the other data.
Decimal place
  • A digit to the right of the decimal point.
Key terms
Term Meaning
Accuracy Closeness of a result to the true or accepted value.
Precision Closeness of repeated readings to each other.
Validity Whether an experiment measures what it is intended to measure.
Percentage difference Difference between the result and the accepted value as a percentage of the accepted value.
Fiducial marker A fixed reference mark used to judge when an oscillating object passes its centre position.
Evaluation Judgement of the quality of the method, data and conclusion.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Listing vague limitations such as “human error”name the specific error, its effect and its size.
2Avoid this
Suggesting improvements not linked to a weaknesseach change must remove a stated limitation.
3Avoid this
Not comparing percentage uncertainty with percentage difference from the accepted valuecompare them to judge agreement.
1 / 2Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
4Avoid this
Not saying what a systematic error does to the resultsstate whether it causes an offset or a gradient that is too large or small.
5Avoid this
Concluding the aim was met without considering the uncertaintythe conclusion must be judged within the uncertainty.
◀ Previous2 / 2
Accepted payment methods