Curriculum
Course: Chemistry 2e
Login

Curriculum

Chemistry 2e

Unit 9: Gases

0/23 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 10: Liquids and Solids

0/28 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 12: Kinetics

0/32 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 14: Acid-Base Equilibria

0/32 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 17: Electrochemistry

0/32 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 18: Representative Metals, Metalloids, and Nonmetals

0/52 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 19: Transition Metals and Coordination Chemistry

0/16 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material

Unit 21: Nuclear Chemistry

0/28 Dr Dabour Hub Science Diagram and Course Material
Text lesson

7.4 Formal Charges and Resonance

7.4 Formal Charges and Resonance — CHEMISTRY notes: You will be able to calculate formal charges, use them to choose the most likely Lewis structure, and explain resonance forms and resonance hybrids.

1Expanded octets and interhalogens2Expanded octets and interhalogens
Lewis structure of XeF6 with six Xe–F bonds, one lone pair on xenon and three lone pairs on each fluorine. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Expanded octets and interhalogens
Expanded octets and interhalogens: Lewis structure of XeF6 with six Xe–F bonds, one lone pair on xenon and three lone pairs on each fluorine." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Expanded octets and interhalogens
Some central atoms can hold more than eight electrons. Xenon has empty valence d orbitals

so it can accommodate more than eight electrons. In XeF2, the Lewis structure has two bonding pairs and three lone pairs of electrons around the xenon atom.
In XeF6, place three lone pairs of electrons on each fluorine atom. These lone pairs account for 36 electrons. Two electrons remain, and they form one lone pair on the xenon atom. Xenon therefore has six bonding pairs and one lone pair

which means 14 electrons surround it.
The halogens form interhalogen compounds, in which halogen atoms bond covalently to each other. Bromine trichloride, BrCl3, has bromine bonded to three chlorine atoms, with two lone pairs on bromine. The ICl4− ion has iodine bonded to four chlorine atoms, with two lone pairs on iodine. Both structures are shown below.
1 / 2Next ▶
Lewis structures of the interhalogen BrCl3 (left) and the ICl4 ion (right). Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Expanded octets and interhalogens
Expanded octets and interhalogens: Lewis structures of the interhalogen BrCl3 (left) and the ICl4 ion (right)." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

Check Your Learning. Write the Lewis structures for the interhalogens BrCl3 and ICl4−. Answer: BrCl3 has 28 valence electrons.
2

Three Br–Cl bonds use 6 of them, and the remaining 22 form three lone pairs on each Cl and two on Br.
3

ICl4− has 36 valence electrons.
4

Four I–Cl bonds use 8, and the remaining 28 form three lone pairs on each Cl and two on I.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Calculating formal charge2Calculating formal charge
Calculating formal charge
Calculating formal charge
The formal charge of an atom in a molecule is the hypothetical charge the atom would have if the electrons in each bond were shared evenly between the atoms.
Equivalently, take the number of valence electrons of the neutral atom, subtract the nonbonding electrons on that atom,
and then subtract the number of bonds the atom forms in the Lewis structure.
A double bond counts as two bonds and a triple bond as three.
Formal charge = valence electrons − nonbonding electrons − number of bonds
Two checks help.
1 / 2Next ▶
Calculating formal charge
Calculating formal charge
For a neutral molecule, the formal charges of all atoms must sum to zero.
For an ion, they must sum to the charge of the ion.
Formal charge is only a bookkeeping method.
It does not show that an atom actually carries that charge in the molecule.
◀ Previous2 / 2
1Using formal charge to predict molecular structure2Using formal charge to predict molecular structure3Using formal charge to predict molecular structure4Using formal charge to predict molecular structure
Using formal charge to predict molecular structure
1

The arrangement of atoms in a molecule or ion is called its molecular structure. Following the Lewis-structure steps can give more than one possible molecular structure, with different placements of multiple bonds and lone pairs, or different arrangements of atoms. Four guidelines based on formal charge help decide which structure is most likely:
2

1
3

A structure in which all formal charges are zero is preferable to one in which some formal charges are not zero.
4

2
5

If the Lewis structure must have nonzero formal charges, the arrangement with the smallest nonzero formal charges,
6

and with the fewest atoms carrying a nonzero charge, is preferable.
1 / 4Next ▶
Using formal charge to predict molecular structure
1

3
2

Structures are preferable when adjacent formal charges are zero or of opposite sign.
3

4
4

When several structures have similar charge distributions, the one with negative formal charges on the more electronegative atoms is preferable.
5

Consider carbon dioxide, CO2.
6

Less electronegative atoms usually occupy the central position, and formal charge explains why.
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
Three possible Lewis structures of CO2 with the formal charge on each atom; the O=C=O structure has zero on every atom. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Using formal charge to predict molecular structure
Using formal charge to predict molecular structure: Three possible Lewis structures of CO2 with the formal charge on each atom; the O=C=O structure has zero on every atom." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Using formal charge to predict molecular structure
Three arrangements can be drawn: carbon in the center with two double bonds, carbon in the center with one single and one triple bond,

and oxygen in the center with two double bonds.
The first arrangement has only zero formal charges

so Guideline 1 identifies it as the preferred structure.
The thiocyanate ion is made of carbon, nitrogen and sulfur, and it can have three atom arrangements: NCS−, CNS− or CSN−.
Each has a total charge of −1

but their formal charges differ.
The NCS− arrangement has only one atom with a nonzero formal charge, the fewest of the three (Guideline 2).
It also places the negative charge on the more electronegative nitrogen, with the carbon atom in the center (Guideline 4).
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
The three possible arrangements of the thiocyanate ion, with the formal charge on each atom listed below its structure. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Using formal charge to predict molecular structure
◀ Previous4 / 4
1Resonance2Resonance3Resonance4Resonance
The two Lewis structures of the nitrite ion, with the double bond on either of the two N–O bonds. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Resonance
Resonance: The two Lewis structures of the nitrite ion, with the double bond on either of the two N–O bonds." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Resonance
The nitrite ion, NO2−, is a useful case. Its most likely structure can be drawn in two ways, depending on whether the double bond is on the left or the right N–O bond. Both drawings are shown below.
If nitrite had one single and one double N–O bond, the two bonds should differ in length and strength

because a double bond is shorter and stronger than a single bond between the same two atoms.
Experiments show that both N–O bonds in nitrite have the same strength and length, and are identical in all other properties.
No single Lewis structure gives nitrogen an octet and two equivalent bonds

so chemists use resonance.
In resonance, when two or more Lewis structures with the same arrangement of atoms can be written for a molecule or ion, the actual distribution of electrons is the average of those structures.
Each individual Lewis structure is a resonance form.
1 / 4Next ▶
The two nitrite resonance forms joined by a double-headed arrow, which shows that they describe one ion. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Resonance
Resonance: The two nitrite resonance forms joined by a double-headed arrow, which shows that they describe one ion." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Resonance
The actual electronic structure

which is the average of all the resonance forms, is the resonance hybrid.
In nitrite, each N–O bond is an average of a double bond and a single bond.
A double-headed arrow between Lewis structures shows that they are resonance forms of the same molecule.
A resonance hybrid never has the electronic structure of either resonance form alone, and it does not flip back and forth between them.
Its electronic structure is always the average of all the resonance forms.
George Wheland, a pioneer of resonance theory, gave a helpful analogy.
◀ Previous2 / 4Next ▶
Resonance
1

A medieval traveler who had never seen a rhinoceros described it as a mix of a dragon and a unicorn

because it shared features with both.
2

A rhinoceros is never a dragon at one moment and a unicorn at another.
3

In the same way, a resonance hybrid is never either of its forms at a given moment.
4

It is a real entity that experiments confirm, and the resonance forms are convenient imaginary pictures used to describe it.
5

The carbonate ion, CO32−, gives a second example of resonance.
6

Its central carbon needs one double bond to complete its octet,

but all three oxygen atoms are equivalent,so the double bond could form with any one of them.
◀ Previous3 / 4Next ▶
The three equivalent resonance structures of the carbonate ion, with the double bond placed on each oxygen atom in turn. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Resonance
Resonance: The three equivalent resonance structures of the carbonate ion, with the double bond placed on each oxygen atom in turn." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

This gives three identical resonance forms.
2

Because the forms are identical, the actual arrangement of electrons is the average of the three,

and experiments confirm that all three C–O bonds have exactly the same length and strength.
3

The online practice box in this section points to a quiz on drawing resonance structures and estimating formal charges. Practising those two skills on several ions and molecules is the best way to master this section.
◀ Previous4 / 4
1Example 7.6: Formal charges in the ICl4 ion2Example 7.6: Formal charges in the ICl4 ion3Example 7.7: Formal charges in BrCl34Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O5Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O6Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O7Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
Lewis structure of the ICl4 ion used in Example 7.6, with two lone pairs on iodine and three on each chlorine. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Example 7.6: Formal charges in the ICl4 ion
Worked examples: Lewis structure of the ICl4 ion used in Example 7.6, with two lone pairs on iodine and three on each chlorine." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

Problem. Assign formal charges to each atom in the interhalogen ion ICl4−.
2

Solution. Step 1. Divide the bonding electron pairs equally for all I–Cl bonds

so each bond gives one electron to iodine and one to chlorine.
3

Step 2. Assign the lone pairs to their atoms.
4

Each Cl has three lone pairs (6 electrons) plus one bonding electron

so 7 electrons in total.
5

Iodine has two lone pairs (4 electrons) plus four bonding electrons

so 8 electrons in total.
6

Step 3. Subtract these from the valence electrons of the neutral atoms: I: 7 − 8 = −1, and each Cl: 7 − 7 = 0.
1 / 7Next ▶
Example 7.6: Formal charges in the ICl4 ion
1

The formal charges sum to −1 + 0 + 0 + 0 + 0 = −1

which matches the charge of the ion.
2

Check Your Learning. Calculate the formal charge on each atom in carbon monoxide, CO. Answer: C is −1 and O is +1. Carbon has one lone pair and three bonds: 4 − 2 − 3 = −1. Oxygen has one lone pair and three bonds: 6 − 2 − 3 = +1. The sum is zero, as required for a neutral molecule.
◀ Previous2 / 7Next ▶
Lewis structure of BrCl3, with bromine in the center bonded to three chlorine atoms and two lone pairs on bromine. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Example 7.7: Formal charges in BrCl3
Worked examples: Lewis structure of BrCl3, with bromine in the center bonded to three chlorine atoms and two lone pairs on bromine." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Example 7.7: Formal charges in BrCl3
Problem. Assign formal charges to each atom in the interhalogen molecule BrCl3.
Solution. Step 1. Assign one electron from each Br–Cl bond to the Br atom and one to the Cl atom in that bond.
Each Cl has seven electrons, and Br also has seven electrons (two lone pairs plus three bonding electrons).
Step 3.

Subtract these from the valence electrons of the neutral atoms: Br: 7 − 7 = 0, and Cl: 7 − 7 = 0.All atoms have a formal charge of zero, and the sum is zero, as it must be for a neutral molecule.
Check Your Learning. Determine the formal charge for each atom in NCl3. Answer: N is 0 and each of the three Cl atoms is 0. Nitrogen has one lone pair and three bonds: 5 − 2 − 3 = 0. Each chlorine has three lone pairs and one bond: 7 − 6 − 1 = 0.
◀ Previous3 / 7Next ▶
Lewis structure of NCl3, with one lone pair on nitrogen and three lone pairs on each chlorine. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
Worked examples: Lewis structure of NCl3, with one lone pair on nitrogen and three lone pairs on each chlorine." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
Problem. Nitrous oxide, N2O, is commonly known as laughing gas and is used as an anesthetic in minor surgery, such as a routine wisdom-tooth extraction. Which is the more likely structure?
◀ Previous4 / 7Next ▶
The two candidate Lewis structures of nitrous oxide, one with a terminal oxygen and one with a central oxygen. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
Worked examples: The two candidate Lewis structures of nitrous oxide, one with a terminal oxygen and one with a central oxygen." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
Solution. Determine the formal charges for each structure.
◀ Previous5 / 7Next ▶
Formal charges on each atom in the two nitrous oxide structures. The terminal-oxygen structure has 0, +1 and −1, while the other has −1, +2 and −1. Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
Worked examples: Formal charges on each atom in the two nitrous oxide structures. The terminal-oxygen structure has 0, +1 and −1, while the other has −1, +2 and −1." loading= - Dr Khaled Dabour Academy⤢ Enlarge
1

The structure with a terminal oxygen atom best satisfies the criteria for the most stable distribution of formal charge. It has the fewest atoms with formal charges (two, against three in the other structure), and no formal charge larger than one in magnitude (the other has +2). Its negative formal charge is on the more electronegative oxygen (Guideline 4).
2

Check Your Learning. Which is the most likely molecular structure for the nitrite ion, NO2−? Answer: ONO−, with nitrogen in the center and an oxygen atom at each end. The alternative arrangement puts nitrogen at one end

which gives larger formal charges and is less favorable under the guidelines.
◀ Previous6 / 7Next ▶
Two possible atom arrangements of the nitrite ion: nitrogen at one end (left) or nitrogen in the center (right). Image: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, CC BY 4.0.
Example 7.8: Most likely structure of nitrous oxide, N2O
◀ Previous7 / 7
Key terms
Term Meaning
Formal charge The hypothetical charge an atom would have if the electrons in each bond were shared evenly between the bonded atoms.
Molecular structure The arrangement of atoms in a molecule or ion, including which atoms are bonded and where multiple bonds and lone pairs are placed.
Interhalogen A compound in which halogen atoms are covalently bonded to one another, such as BrCl3 or ICl4−.
Resonance The situation in which two or more Lewis structures with the same arrangement of atoms describe one molecule or ion, and the actual electron distribution is their average.
Resonance form One of the individual Lewis structures used to describe a molecule or ion that shows resonance.
Resonance hybrid The actual electronic structure of a molecule or ion, which is the average of all of its resonance forms.
1Avoid these mistakes2Avoid these mistakes
Avoid these mistakes
1Avoid this
Treating a formal charge as the real charge on an atom. Formal charge is bookkeeping only.Avoid this
2Avoid this
Forgetting that the formal charges must add up to zero for a neutral molecule, or to the ion charge for an ion.Avoid this
3Avoid this
Counting a double bond as one bond, or a triple bond as two, when subtracting bonds in the formal charge calculation.Avoid this
1 / 2Next ▶
Avoid these mistakes
4Avoid this
Choosing the structure with the most formal charges, instead of the one with zeros or the smallest nonzero charges.Avoid this
5Avoid this
Putting the negative formal charge on the less electronegative atom when a choice is available.Avoid this
6Avoid this
Thinking a resonance hybrid switches between its resonance forms, or that the resonance forms are separate molecules.Avoid this
◀ Previous2 / 2
Accepted payment methods